Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[IDontPlayThisGame]

Think it's a bad deal to lynch the VLA guy on D2 when we expect at least 2 more scum to find today.

IDP, why are you not pro-SA lynch?

I'm neutral on SA because I've yet to feel like I have a solid read on them. I can go back and do a reread but it'll have to be a fast one.

PPE: 2

[Robz888]

I would rather lynch Space than Eevee. Pretty sure.

[Robz888]

Who do you want to lynch, IDP? I don't remember.

[Eevee]

@gkrieg's #1243

But that's what I tried to say! I meant that RR makes sense for a page-refreshing scum riding their town cred from the previous day.

[Robz888]

Who do you want to lynch, IDP? I don't remember.

Oh, it's RR. Well RR is not happening, he gets a pass for not being here. Which isn't how it should work, but it is.

[gkrieg13]

I think only EFHW and RR are not here currently

[IDontPlayThisGame]

Who do you want to lynch, IDP? I don't remember.

Oh, it's RR. Well RR is not happening, he gets a pass for not being here. Which isn't how it should work, but it is.

Which made me wonder about strategic VLAs but that seems like really, really bad form

[Robz888]

Maybe I'm just completely , wildly wrong about RR.

[pingpongsam]

I mean, I could do RR. IDP is voting him. Others are willing too. We could definitely secure his death over any others. He gives me the least feeling we'd hit scum out of all them. I feel so damned good about Lekkit or SA flipping scum everyone else would have to go over there before I'd follow.

[gkrieg13]

Who do you want to lynch, IDP? I don't remember.

Oh, it's RR. Well RR is not happening, he gets a pass for not being here. Which isn't how it should work, but it is.

Which made me wonder about strategic VLAs but that seems like really, really bad form

I'm pretty sure faking V/LA is against the moral rules of the FDS mafia community

[Eevee]

The scum slip argument is not "ridiculous." It might not be right, but it's not unthinkable given the cloud of suspicion already around EFHW.

Yeah, you can of course disagree, but does that really make me scummy gkrieg?

Something isn't adding up here, and efhw being scum would clear some of the bigger questions. As a lynch candidate it really sucks that the risk is lynching the doctor.

[gkrieg13]

I mean, I could do RR. IDP is voting him. Others are willing too. We could definitely secure his death over any others. He gives me the least feeling we'd hit scum out of all them. I feel so damned good about Lekkit or SA flipping scum everyone else would have to go over there before I'd follow.

Why wouldn't you go for Eevee?  What makes your town read on them so strong?

[gkrieg13]

The scum slip argument is not "ridiculous." It might not be right, but it's not unthinkable given the cloud of suspicion already around EFHW.

Yeah, you can of course disagree, but does that really make me scummy gkrieg?

Something isn't adding up here, and efhw being scum would clear some of the bigger questions. As a lynch candidate it really sucks that the risk is lynching the doctor.

For me my town read on McGarnacle/EFHW is strictly the claim from McGarnacle.  I think it was just too solid of a town claim for them to be scum.

[Eevee]

Who do you want to lynch, IDP? I don't remember.

Oh, it's RR. Well RR is not happening, he gets a pass for not being here. Which isn't how it should work, but it is.

Which made me wonder about strategic VLAs but that seems like really, really bad form

I don't think anyone is insinuating this is a strategic vla, but rr could still be scum regardless.

[Lekkit]

Based on the reads I am seeing I do not think I am a viable candidate today. If you won't be around at deadline could you at least move your vote to someone more viable? If I get NK'd you will have your answer. If I survive I will claim my role and at least N2's target tomorrow. Letting everyone know who is a PR today before I die seems like a bad idea.

But that's the thing. What if the PR is actually scum? Or do we just assume town got all the good stuff while scum got nothing? If you're town, I think "outing the PR" isn't necessarily only a bad thing.

[Lekkit]

I still want to lynch Robz, PPS or gkrieg. I would be willing to risk it with EFHW or SA. I don't think Eevee is the lynch.

[Robz888]

I'd lynch gkrieg but not PPS, SA but not EFHW. I think.

[gkrieg13]

Something about you just feels scummy.  I think I addressed it in my big reread posts.  Your insistence that the wagons stay on the town people D1 is one of the bigger points.  I also didn't like your rereads in #997 and #998, mainly the pressure vote, which just seemed strange.

Another main point is that there are people that want to lynch you, but your wagon isn't very big.  Also my scum reads mainly don't want to lynch you, other than Robz, which is a point toward you being scum and away from SA being scum. 

PPE: Lekkit, you still haven't explained why that is your lynch pool, you just put together a case on PPS and left.

[Robz888]

This is the weirdest end of day I've ever participated in and I'm trying to understand why. Something is going on.

[Robz888]

Lekkit lynch, anyone?

[gkrieg13]

This is the weirdest end of day I've ever participated in and I'm trying to understand why. Something is going on.

I agree.  It is weird from the perspective that scum just needs to get someone lynched that isn't them but they don't know who to put it on yet I don't think.  Another weird thing for me is that if one wagon gets more than 3 votes, I will probably start to get paranoid that we are lynching the wrong person.  The fact that it is like this points to one of two things in my mind, scum is either vets, or lurkers, so town is really just destroying itself by being active.

[gkrieg13]

Lekkit lynch, anyone?

My opinion is clear on that one.

[IDontPlayThisGame]

Reread SA, not seeing anything that makes me want to vote them. @PPS, I think there are better candidates right now.

PPE: 2

[Robz888]

Lekkit lynch, anyone?

My opinion is clear on that one.

The issue is if I switch my vote from Space to Lekkit I think I put PPS in danger because he has two votes against him.

[Lekkit]

Something about you just feels scummy.  I think I addressed it in my big reread posts.  Your insistence that the wagons stay on the town people D1 is one of the bigger points.  I also didn't like your rereads in #997 and #998, mainly the pressure vote, which just seemed strange.

Another main point is that there are people that want to lynch you, but your wagon isn't very big.  Also my scum reads mainly don't want to lynch you, other than Robz, which is a point toward you being scum and away from SA being scum. 

PPE: Lekkit, you still haven't explained why that is your lynch pool, you just put together a case on PPS and left.

Because PPS kind of breadcrumbed you and Robz as the ones who targeted Dylan.