Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

Ok I have a new hot take. I'm calling a LL/EFHW scum team due to the these facts

1. EFHW. She has been perceived as for a while now and in my opinion the best D-2 lynch. If you want a more in depth case just look back. Also her interactions with LL have been weird (look in LL section for that)

2. LaLight. Well for one LL has been playing really well btw. In fact LL has almost been playing two well kind of like a godfather scum. Another reason is LL interactions with EFHW. At first LL hammered EFHW with reasons to lynch her but as soon as the wagon on EFHW started to get real she completely backed off changing the conversation away from EFHW.

Those are my highest scum reads but would still prefer a EFHW lynch over a LL because i'm more confident in that lynch

[LaLight]

Hm, firstly, I didn't hammer EFHW. Secondly I explained my case on her some times.

P.S. I'm fine with "she", everyone, don't mind, plz

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

My guess is EFHW/Calamitas or EFHW/Robz with a slight preference to the latter.

EFHW both times

[2.71828.....]

Jake's case is not amazing, but it is the type of case I expect more from town than scum

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

Simple PoE shows that I'm kinda right.

I believe now Calamitas is town. E is town. Jake seems town. Me is town.

This leaves SA, Robz, EFHW. SA is a hard opponent if scum. I'll look further.
This leaves EFHW and Robz.

Another post to kill EFHW

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

Actually, if and only if EFHW flips town I'm calling Robz/Jake team.

And then after this post you never mention EFHW again (this was around the time EFHW's wagon got serious)

[LaLight]

unvote

[LaLight]

New phone, inconvenient af

I believe Jake now. That was adequate case. That leaves me with 2,5 scum reads (0,5 being SA :-P)

Feeling well to return to vote: efhw

Fyi, Jake, I didn't stop seeing her as scum. You just seemed a better idea at that moment. I've made colored grid where you can see efhw being my scumread. So, this is it. I hope there's not a lot of tupos, new phone doesn't show me my post

[LaLight]

Lol the pnly typo is in the word typo

[2.71828.....]

Vote: LaLight

Going all day without voting until the end is no fun

[EFHW]

vote: Lalight. Why believe Jake now?  They didn't say anything new.

[LaLight]

Vote: LaLight

Going all day without voting until the end is no fun

Why?

[LaLight]

vote: Lalight. Why believe Jake now?  They didn't say anything new.

He made a good adequate case he'd never do being scum.

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

vote: Lalight. Why believe Jake now?  They didn't say anything new.

If you don't believe me why are you voting LL

[EFHW]

vote: Lalight. Why believe Jake now?  They didn't say anything new.

He made a good adequate case he'd never do being scum.

Against you maybe, not against me. And assuming for the moment that he did make some kind of adequate case, why wouldn't he make a good case as scum?  That's what most scum try to do when given enough scummy material to work with.

[EFHW]

vote: Lalight. Why believe Jake now?  They didn't say anything new.

If you don't believe me why are you voting LL

I'm voting him because his capitulating to your pressure is scummy.

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

vote: Lalight. Why believe Jake now?  They didn't say anything new.

If you don't believe me why are you voting LL

I'm voting him because his capitulating to your pressure is scummy.

So the logical town choice is to vote me if what you've said is what you believe but instead you vote LL.  Possible major scumtell folks take a hard look at EFHW when voting

[EFHW]

vote: Lalight. Why believe Jake now?  They didn't say anything new.

If you don't believe me why are you voting LL

I'm voting him because his capitulating to your pressure is scummy.

So the logical town choice is to vote me if what you've said is what you believe but instead you vote LL.  Possible major scumtell folks take a hard look at EFHW when voting

No, that's not actually logical.  I don't know for a fact that you are scum.  You have just been the scummiest.  I am open to other possibilities, including contradictory ones.  If a wagon on you becomes viable, I will be back.

[2.71828.....]

Vote: LaLight

Going all day without voting until the end is no fun

Why?

Because it is fun to vote. And you are scummier than others

[LaLight]

Vote: LaLight

Going all day without voting until the end is no fun

Why?

Because it is fun to vote. And you are scummier than others

How am i scummier?

[2.71828.....]

I find your voting history scummy

I find your recent jake/efhw switcharound scummy

I find your grid of calling scum teams scummy

But maybe that is just me

[JaketheBaseballGod22]

I would be fine with lynching LaLight

[Calamitas]

I find your voting history scummy

I find your recent jake/efhw switcharound scummy

I find your grid of calling scum teams scummy

But maybe that is just me

Could you elaborate a little?

[SpaceAnemone]

I find your voting history scummy

I find your recent jake/efhw switcharound scummy

I find your grid of calling scum teams scummy

But maybe that is just me

In my read-through, I've noted that LL has put Jake, Calamitas and EFHW at L-1 at various points in the game. And at no point was I on the Jake or EFHW wagons, meaning I could have hammered at any time. (Several others also could have, but I know I'm town, so that part matters here). So that made me kind of less suspicious of him being scum with either or them, or with Calamitas really, since there were loads of other towns there, like you or RR. Would scums bus their partner as much as that and risk losing them when there wasn't really all that much suspicion?

[Calamitas]

What I found weird about Jake and LaLight is the fact that Jake hasn't talked about LaLight at all until he expressed a scumread on him.