Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[gkrieg13]

Dylan, is this your first game?

It is

[Dylan32]

Dylan, is this your first game?

It is

Here on f.ds yes. irl no. but irl I've never seen the town have a chance to lynch before someone is killed.

[Ghacob]

I'm reading new!town into Dylan here. I remember the exact same thought process during one of my first games here (I know I'm town, and scum knows I'm town...)

[J Reggie]

I'm reading new!town into Dylan here. I remember the exact same thought process during one of my first games here (I know I'm town, and scum knows I'm town...)

Funny, I'm reading new!scum.

[SpaceAnemone]

I'm reading new!town into Dylan here. I remember the exact same thought process during one of my first games here (I know I'm town, and scum knows I'm town...)

Funny, I'm reading new!scum.

Ooh, is that because Dylan's in the scum QT with you?

[gkrieg13]

I'm reading new!town into Dylan here. I remember the exact same thought process during one of my first games here (I know I'm town, and scum knows I'm town...)

How can you guys be reading Dylan as anything right now?

[EFHW]

Don't we usually give newbies a pass day 1?

[2.71828.....]

Don't we usually give newbies a pass day 1?

yeah, usually.  Although that has kind of gone away as a "thing" recently because newbies hate to think that they are getting a free pass? maybe? I still have no reason to vote for Dylan.  In fact, I am very happy with where my vote is now.

[Dylan32]

Don't we usually give newbies a pass day 1?

yeah, usually.  Although that has kind of gone away as a "thing" recently because newbies hate to think that they are getting a free pass? maybe? I still have no reason to vote for Dylan.  In fact, I am very happy with where my vote is now.

All discussion about my role aside, if I say or have already said something that would normally get me killed on Day 1, I'd rather go ahead and get killed so I can figure out what people normally look for on Day 1.

Anyway, even if his attention was directed at someone else, I would still feel like Reggie is sounding pretty scummy.  So I guess I've got to Vote: J Reggie

[chairs]

I firmly believe in the D1 newbie pass.

[2.71828.....]

I firmly believe in the D1 newbie pass.

I firmly believe in a D1 pass for chairs in this game

[2.71828.....]

I also firmly believe that more people need to post

[Roadrunner7671]

I haven't really formed an opinion on Dylan. I suspect any opinion I do form wil be based off of almost nothing so there's no point in saying something if I think the drop of a pin will change my opinion.

2.7 is slight town for trying to keep the game moving I guess. That's my only real read so far and it's not very strong, but it's better than nothing.

[Ghacob]

I'm reading new!town into Dylan here. I remember the exact same thought process during one of my first games here (I know I'm town, and scum knows I'm town...)

How can you guys be reading Dylan as anything right now?

Because of the reason I just provided. Wait, frick. The situation is in fact the exact opposite as I described.

I had assumed that the following quote was in the same context of one of my earlier games (with e in this position at that.. multiple times?), but it was in fact the exact opposite

I sort of feel like I should change my vote since e was the first person to defend me, but I'm still not sure who I would change it to.  Reggie would be the easy choice but I don't want my first vote to be OMGUS already haha

I processed this as Dylan becoming suspicious of e after e defended him, which I had done (once or twice, the first, if it had happened, e was town, but the second, which did, e was scum) early in my forum mafia career as a tendency to overread situations. I, assuming Dylan had done the same, sympathized and voiced the presumed shared experience, putting him closer to town.
However, instead the exact opposite occured. Dylan was voting e, (until?) he defended Dylan. Dylan is less suspicious of e now.

Now uncertain, will return with thoughts. A good old null!read on e. You followed your "town meta" precisely, but you do that regardless I think.

[faust]

Vote Count 1.3

2.71828..... (2): EFHW, J Reggie
J Reggie (4): 2.71828....., SpaceAnemone, Roadrunner7671, Dylan32
Dylan32 (2): mail-mi, silverspawn
SpaceAnemone (1): schadd

Not Voting (3): chairs, Ghacob, gkrieg13

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch. Day 1 ends October 21 at 11 am forum time.

Deadline has been extended by 24 hours to account for forum downtime/lagginess.

[chairs]

Okay, I should be able to be a bit more active now.

vote: J Reggie seems fine to me.

[SpaceAnemone]

Vote: Ghacob

That's a very elaborate U-turn for an early D1 read, especially after gkrieg queried how anyone can have a read on Dylan at this point...

[J Reggie]

Okay, I should be able to be a bit more active now.

vote: J Reggie seems fine to me.

Btw that was an unannounced L-2.

I think scum wants to mislynch me here.

[schadd]

Okay, I should be able to be a bit more active now.

vote: J Reggie seems fine to me.

Btw that was an unannounced L-2.

I think scum wants to mislynch me here.

do they really?

[gkrieg13]

Okay, I should be able to be a bit more active now.

vote: J Reggie seems fine to me.

Btw that was an unannounced L-2.

I think scum wants to mislynch me here.

This once again isn't a thing

vote: SA

[2.71828.....]

Okay, I should be able to be a bit more active now.

vote: J Reggie seems fine to me.

Btw that was an unannounced L-2.

I think scum wants to mislynch me here.

do they really?

I don't think announcing L-2 and L-1 is nearly as big of a deal as people make it. Just pay attention to the votecounts. It's not like they are super sporadic in this game. I mean, our mod has more posts than some people......

[chairs]

It's not like I bother announcing L-1 half the time. Is announcing L-2 a thing now too?

[gkrieg13]

It's not like I bother announcing L-1 half the time. Is announcing L-2 a thing now too?

No but for some reason J Reggie wants to make it a thing

[Roadrunner7671]

It's not like I bother announcing L-1 half the time. Is announcing L-2 a thing now too?

No but for some reason J Reggie wants to make it a thing

I'd want it to be a thing. Especially with this wagon. Where's the case?

[chairs]

Personally, I like wagons and lynching people and I don't care for D1 that much.