Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[SpaceAnemone]

This joke is scummy.  Plus emoticon.

Not superstrong, but I guess no D1 case ever is...

In the mean time, vote: Zigaton. Only posted twice, and both posts raised red flags for me.

Lol.You're wrong,dude.I voted for you to see your reaction.I think it is too early to draw any conclusions.

To be fair, I've noticed you're quite quiet, and I was beginning to wonder about it too. You probably should post more ideas and opinions about the rest of us :-) Yes, it's too early to build a strong case, but you can't just watch and wait till someone says something totally damning, because they probably don't do that at all in most games.

[McGarnacle]

Argh.. really sorry for not being present today :-( I've had a big concert this evening, and it went amazingly, but I've just come home from the afterparty and it's too late to do thinking... though I'd have a chance to phonepost between the rehearsals and concert, but I was rushed off my feet. I'll definitely make time to do proper reading tomorrow :-)

Being at a concert... Sounds scummy to me! 

This joke is scummy.  Plus emoticon.

                              

[Roadrunner7671]

That's a scummy reaction. McGarnle reminds me of myself in my first scum game

[Roadrunner7671]

Okay, the Mafia community really needs more people so I don't want McGarnacle to have a bad first experience but I'm pretty sure he's scum. So I'm actually sorry about this but Vote: McGarnacle

[McGarnacle]

That's a scummy reaction. McGarnle reminds me of myself in my first scum game

What??? Next time I play mafia I'll know to not post emoticons- only mafia use emoticons, apparently.

[Roadrunner7671]

That's a scummy reaction. McGarnle reminds me of myself in my first scum game

What??? Next time I play mafia I'll know to not post emoticons- only mafia use emoticons, apparently.

I don't care about you throwing a few emojis around. I do care about you sending a ton of emojis when people tell you it's scummy

[pacovf]

I think it's time for a read list:

Would lynch:

Zigaton (as far as I am concerned, his second post was super scummy. Might be me OMGUSing, I am hoping it isn't)
PPS (jumping on easy votes, makes me feel uneasy)
Lalight (has done some things typically attributed to scum)

McGarnacle (don't feel very strongly about this one, but will vote if necessary)

Would not lynch:

SpaceAnemone (strongish townread)
RoadRunner (mild townread)

No opinion:

ashersky (not as confrontational as he usually is, dunno how to feel about that)
J Reggie (barely present)

[ashersky]

Would lynch: lalight, paco, mcgarg, zig
Might lynch: Space, RR, J Reg
Rather not lynch: PPS

The difference between would and might is not a lot.

Basically I have one town read.  That's...not great.

[LaLight]

Would lynch: lalight, paco, mcgarg, zig
Might lynch: Space, RR, J Reg
Rather not lynch: PPS

The difference between would and might is not a lot.

Basically I have one town read.  That's...not great.

Sorry, but can you please spell McGarnacle correctly? =)

[ashersky]

Would lynch: lalight, paco, mcgarg, zig
Might lynch: Space, RR, J Reg
Rather not lynch: PPS

The difference between would and might is not a lot.

Basically I have one town read.  That's...not great.

Sorry, but can you please spell McGarnacle correctly? =)

I could.  But I like the nickname better.

Speaking of which, you need one too.  Loopsie?  I'm assuming that's where your name comes from.

[LaLight]

Would lynch: lalight, paco, mcgarg, zig
Might lynch: Space, RR, J Reg
Rather not lynch: PPS

The difference between would and might is not a lot.

Basically I have one town read.  That's...not great.

Sorry, but can you please spell McGarnacle correctly? =)

I could.  But I like the nickname better.

Speaking of which, you need one too.  Loopsie?  I'm assuming that's where your name comes from.

My name came from some strange FanFic of LoTR =) Call me whatever you want, though. What is Loopsie anyway?

[ashersky]

I misspelled it, actually.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lalaloopsy

[LaLight]

I misspelled it, actually.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lalaloopsy

Nice!

[pingpongsam]

Would lynch: lalight, paco, mcgarg, zig
Might lynch: Space, RR, J Reg
Rather not lynch: PPS

The difference between would and might is not a lot.

Basically I have one town read.  That's...not great.

Interesting, I hate when I have a bunch of town reads all,over the place, especially early on. Also I am suspicious of people who read town on everyone except a couple people, it is an easy scum tactic to softly direct for mislynches. I mean, yeah, when someone is scummy they are scummy and should make the list and not everyone is going to be scummy like that.

Today, I hold the idea we will actually hit scum very loosely and look for the most informative flip which is still pretty loose as well, it's D1 after all. I've got no strong town reads and no strong scum reads. Being a newbie game I suppose it's possible the Paco/LaLight pair have shown their hand that easily but it's a stretch. Paco omgusing me doesn't really sway me off the idea.

All that said, there's no one on my wouldn't lynch list today and probably wouldn't be unless we got someone to L-1 and they claimed a PR without a counter. Everyone is pretty null to me. RR gives me a faint town read.

[SpaceAnemone]

Would lynch: lalight, paco, mcgarg, zig
Might lynch: Space, RR, J Reg
Rather not lynch: PPS

The difference between would and might is not a lot.

Basically I have one town read.  That's...not great.

Sorry, but can you please spell McGarnacle correctly? =)

I could.  But I like the nickname better.

Whoa, this isn't good :-( Can we play nice?

[ashersky]

Why isn't it good, and why is a nickname bad?  No one is required to spell out my entirely false name I chose for use on the Internet.

[LaLight]

Let's not make this a RSP thread. If Ashersky feels comfortable with changing our nicknames, I'm OK with that. Though if anyone thinks that's offensive, I'd ask Ash not to offend people =) We are different people with different points but I think that our aim here is to enjoy the game. Again: we're not in RSP.

[ashersky]

I am honestly confused.  If there is something posted somewhere that said that McGarnacle is specifically sensitive about the spelling of their username, please point me to it.

This is a forum where vote: mom salon was an acceptable way of voting for mcmcsalot.

LaLight seemed to find the Lalaloopsy thing fun.  There are lots of abbreviations accepted (WW, SS, II, igu, ash, PPS, RR, galz, robz, joth, XP, SA) and unintentional misspellings (gkreig, etc.) throughout the forum.

I'm sure there are lots of other examples, too.

[McGarnacle]

I am honestly confused.  If there is something posted somewhere that said that McGarnacle is specifically sensitive about the spelling of their username, please point me to it.

This is a forum where vote: mom salon was an acceptable way of voting for mcmcsalot.

LaLight seemed to find the Lalaloopsy thing fun.  There are lots of abbreviations accepted (WW, SS, II, igu, ash, PPS, RR, galz, robz, joth, XP, SA) and unintentional misspellings (gkreig, etc.) throughout the forum.

I'm sure there are lots of other examples, too.

I don't really mind that people call me.

[ashersky]

Off-topic: there's an option in member profiles on f.ds where you can toggle off the "show online" green box.

In case you want to be able to lie and say you were here when you weren't or vice versa.

[pingpongsam]

Off-topic: there's an option in member profiles on f.ds where you can toggle off the "show online" green box.

In case you want to be able to lie and say you were here when you weren't or vice versa.

I thought we had a semi unwritten policy about that. Personally, I don't know what my setting is and don't care. If I'm here I'm probably playing and if I'm not it's because I was posting elsewhere. Never saw being online and not posting as guilt.

[pingpongsam]

Also, I'm a big fan of pushing buttons when I find them. If misspelling a name gets a rise I'll keep pushing that button. Reactions are analysis around here.

[McGarnacle]

Off-topic: there's an option in member profiles on f.ds where you can toggle off the "show online" green box.

In case you want to be able to lie and say you were here when you weren't or vice versa.

I think we should keep it normal. It would making lying just a bit easier. I think it will be hard enough to figure out who is scum without them being able to lie about one of the few ways to actually sort of nail them.

[pingpongsam]

Off-topic: there's an option in member profiles on f.ds where you can toggle off the "show online" green box.

In case you want to be able to lie and say you were here when you weren't or vice versa.

I think we should keep it normal. It would making lying just a bit easier. I think it will be hard enough to figure out who is scum without them being able to lie about one of the few ways to actually sort of nail them.

The quasi policy as I remember was you could have whatever settings you like but not lie about lurking while hidden.

[pingpongsam]

Clearly unenforceable.