Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[iguanaiguana]

Joseph is okay too.

[iguanaiguana]

It just always scares me when the lynchpool is the two most commonly mislynched players : /

[gkrieg13]

It just always scares me when the lynchpool is the two most commonly mislynched players : /

Agreed.  I'm also always up to lynch Joseph's partner SA first.

[SpaceAnemone]

It just always scares me when the lynchpool is the two most commonly mislynched players : /

Agreed.  I'm also always up to lynch Joseph's partner SA first.

Weird how high-variance people's reads on me here are. Pretty sure I said I'm okay with a Joseph lynch, and I don't mind putting my vote there if you want. It was J Reggie I just didn't see the case on, and I may have mixed them up at one point because they both start with the same letter.

[J Reggie]

I just reread Witherweaver. I'm on a phone now so I can't do one of those big compilation posts. D1 seemed scummier than D2. There's a lot of stuff there but none of it particularly points to him being town. I'd be down for a vote: WW.

Also, the further this game has gotten, the better I've felt about lynching RR.

[gkrieg13]

Here's what I remember:

Gkrieg has towny rereads. Still my top town.

Gkrieg's reread of WW that he calls "null" reads as scummy to me.

But just after that WW produces some very towny content and the mid-day wagon on him made me feel town on WW overall.

Lalight's intent to hammer on WW and Roadrunner's sheep vote on WW both read as super scummy to me.

Lalight has a lot of posts where he indicates that he trusts other people's opinion's more than his own opinions, or that he is waiting for someone else to say something about another player (like WW) in order to form an opinion of that player. These seem to indicate a scum frame of mind to me because a) town trust themselves over other players for the most part (not knowing who else is town) and b) scum are trying to appease town while staying on a mislynch, so they are always waiting for a plausible but incorrect theory to add their vote onto.

In other words, LaLight is basically not scum hunting at all, seems like he already knows who the scum are.

Roadrunner has one towny post, where he asks if using posts from the RSP forum would constitute cheating. I wonder whether that question occurs to him as scum. However, his other posts are either null or scummy, and I actually happen to remember that he's asked that very same question in the past, so I'm leaning scum on him now I GUESS. (I hate to vote RR.)

so my new scum list might be: Lalight, Joseph, RR where J Reggie and WW slipped into null and my towns are Faust > II > Schadd > Space ...............................and who am I forgetting?

I mean if you want to look for someone who isn't scum hunting, look no further than RR.

[iguanaiguana]

That's his new meta tho.

[iguanaiguana]

Alright then.

Vote: Roadrunner

[faust]

So here comes a reads list. Unfortunately, it is not as well-informed as I would like, but this week has been awfully busy.

Witherweaver - I thought he was quite scummy on D1. I wanted to test waters and voted for him. I really didn't like that wagon, and he had some townie posts in between.
LaLight - one of my highest townreads. I think he stated intent to hammer twice? That's awfully bold for newbie!scum. And all his posts read townie to me.
gkrieg13 - he is very much in his town persona I think. But he's more capable of faking that than LaLight probably. Still, townread.
Roadrunner7671 - there is nothing and still noone bothered to vote for him until I pointed out that he did not do anything. That dynamic also leads me to believe that he is scum.
Joseph2302 - I don't think he's particularly scummy. Some people seem to think that; could they explain their reasoning?
SpaceAnemone - gives off scummy vibes to me. Also has not a lot of substance.
J Reggie - I think from the way wagons went on D1, it's more likely that they were all on town.
schadd - the guy just seems townie.
iguanaiguana - I don't articularly think that he is scum, but neither do I get the strong townreads given out to him.

[Witherweaver]

I would do LaLight, too.

[SpaceAnemone]

Roadrunner7671 - there is nothing and still noone bothered to vote for him until I pointed out that he did not do anything. That dynamic also leads me to believe that he is scum.

Thing is, he's been absent across the board. At least, I don't read much outside the Mafia games threads on here, but I haven't observed him being more than minimally active elsewhere. He probably looks like an easy mislynch wagon for scum, and I'm betting there's at least one of them on there already.

That said, if your alternative is going to be getting your pledged sheep to pile on me as the person you seem to be scum-reading most, then I'm definitely willing to take RR to L-1, since a chance of hitting scum is better than definitely losing town.

[ashersky]

Vote Count 2.7:

Joseph2302 (1): LaLight
Witherweaver (4): SpaceAnemone, Joseph2302, Roadrunner7671, J Reggie
Roadrunner7671 (4): schadd, Witherweaver, gkrieg13, iguana

Not Voting (1): faust

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

Day 2 ends on September 28 at 4:00 a.m. forum time.

[LaLight]

I would do LaLight, too.

Why?

[iguanaiguana]

Vote Count 2.7:

Joseph2302 (1): LaLight
Witherweaver (4): SpaceAnemone, Joseph2302, Roadrunner7671, J Reggie
Roadrunner7671 (4): schadd, Witherweaver, gkrieg13, iguana

Not Voting (1): faust

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

Day 2 ends on September 28 at 4:00 a.m. forum time.

When choosing between a wagon that has Schadd, WW, me and Gkrieg or Space, RR, Joseph and J Reggie it's pretty obvious that I'm on the right wagon.

The signs are there. RR is scum I guess.

[faust]

RR, it is time to claim. Do so in the next post you make.

[LaLight]

actually, I agree. Vote: Roadrunner. L-1

[Roadrunner7671]

I am a 1 shot cop. I haven't used my cop

[faust]

Vote: RR

[faust]

Because noone in their right mind does not use a cop shot on N1.

[faust]

Pretty sure that was a scum claim. So, well done, town, even if you all were a bit quiet.

[Witherweaver]

Any modification to your last reads list?

[gkrieg13]

Pretty sure that was a scum claim. So, well done, town, even if you all were a bit quiet.

I don't get what that first part means.  Are you saying that only scum would claim that?

[faust]

Any modification to your last reads list?

Well uh nothing much happened in between. If RR indeed flips scum, then that mostly reinforces my reads. Probably you will be townier for it.

[faust]

Pretty sure that was a scum claim. So, well done, town, even if you all were a bit quiet.

I don't get what that first part means.  Are you saying that only scum would claim that?

Yes.

[Witherweaver]

Any modification to your last reads list?

Well uh nothing much happened in between. If RR indeed flips scum, then that mostly reinforces my reads. Probably you will be townier for it.

And what do you think if he flips town?  Say, who are top scummy two or three.