Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Roadrunner7671]

Forum downtime is trash

[J Reggie]

(i'm realizing how scary it is to have this many scum in the voterbase, and it is maybe easier for 2 people to coordinate a non-suspicious hammer than 3? but, ofc, i've never witnessed this scenario so i dunno)

I wouldn't worry about this until much later. I haven't really seen scum double hammer this early in the game.

[schadd]

(i'm realizing how scary it is to have this many scum in the voterbase, and it is maybe easier for 2 people to coordinate a non-suspicious hammer than 3? but, ofc, i've never witnessed this scenario so i dunno)

I wouldn't worry about this until much later. I haven't really seen scum double hammer this early in the game.

i'm thinking something along the lines of:


me: vote on guy
scum1: vote on guy! yes!
scum2: ooh good yes! how about hammer, eh? discussion!?
scum1, scum3 in unison: yes, discussion! okay
scum2: alright. allow me to hammer now that we have discussioned
me (none the wiser): oh no, 'twas an innocent!


...if that makes sense

[Witherweaver]

So are you saying that happened?

[schadd]

So are you saying that happened?

no. it is an abstraction of the thing that i'm worried about could happen if i voted joseph right now. that would maybe not happen if i didn't

[Witherweaver]

So are you saying that happened?

no. it is an abstraction of the thing that i'm worried about could happen if i voted joseph right now. that would maybe not happen if i didn't

So what do you think scum did during yesterday's mislynch?

[schadd]

So what do you think scum did during yesterday's mislynch?

probably voted for mail-mi, and ~manipulated~ other people into it. but, i mean, faust and silverspawn were on that boat, so probably not all three of the scums needed to be egging that basket, or something. and that checks out: two of the people in my kinda tier voted for him (you and joseph, though the fact that joseph is the one whom i'm worried about accidentally complicitly killing clouds things a bit).


so, socrates, what's your scoop? corrupted any children lately, like, for example, rr, in your mafia qt? does it smell bad cop in here or is it just me? etc.

[Joseph2302]

(i'm realizing how scary it is to have this many scum in the voterbase, and it is maybe easier for 2 people to coordinate a non-suspicious hammer than 3? but, ofc, i've never witnessed this scenario so i dunno)

I wouldn't worry about this until much later. I haven't really seen scum double hammer this early in the game.

i'm thinking something along the lines of:


me: vote on guy
scum1: vote on guy! yes!
scum2: ooh good yes! how about hammer, eh? discussion!?
scum1, scum3 in unison: yes, discussion! okay
scum2: alright. allow me to hammer now that we have discussioned
me (none the wiser): oh no, 'twas an innocent!


...if that makes sense

Scum doesn't have day chat, so couldn't discuss this in-game.

Another townslip it seems.

[Joseph2302]

So what do you think scum did during yesterday's mislynch?

probably voted for mail-mi, and ~manipulated~ other people into it. but, i mean, faust and silverspawn were on that boat, so probably not all three of the scums needed to be egging that basket, or something. and that checks out: two of the people in my kinda tier voted for him (you and joseph, though the fact that joseph is the one whom i'm worried about accidentally complicitly killing clouds things a bit).


so, socrates, what's your scoop? corrupted any children lately, like, for example, rr, in your mafia qt? does it smell bad cop in here or is it just me? etc.

I didn't really want to vote for him, but he seemed like the least bad wagon.

[LaLight]

Schadd townslips again and again

[Joseph2302]

Schadd townslips again and again

Either he's been very well coached in the scum QT, which seems unlikely, or he's obv!town

[faust]

(i'm realizing how scary it is to have this many scum in the voterbase, and it is maybe easier for 2 people to coordinate a non-suspicious hammer than 3? but, ofc, i've never witnessed this scenario so i dunno)

I wouldn't worry about this until much later. I haven't really seen scum double hammer this early in the game.

i'm thinking something along the lines of:


me: vote on guy
scum1: vote on guy! yes!
scum2: ooh good yes! how about hammer, eh? discussion!?
scum1, scum3 in unison: yes, discussion! okay
scum2: alright. allow me to hammer now that we have discussioned
me (none the wiser): oh no, 'twas an innocent!


...if that makes sense

Scum doesn't have day chat, so couldn't discuss this in-game.

Another townslip it seems.

This is not a townslip. The discussion that schadd imagines is clearly taking place in the game thread.

[schadd]

Schadd townslips again and again

Either he's been very well coached in the scum QT, which seems unlikely, or he's obv!town

vous have my permission to not point these out anymore

This is not a townslip. The discussion that schadd imagines is clearly taking place in the game thread.

perhaps. at least, the thing i theorized shouldn't need a daychat to work

[gkrieg13]

Schadd townslips again and again

Either he's been very well coached in the scum QT, which seems unlikely, or he's obv!town

vous have my permission to not point these out anymore

This is not a townslip. The discussion that schadd imagines is clearly taking place in the game thread.

perhaps. at least, the thing i theorized shouldn't need a daychat to work

Why wouldn't you want him to point them out anymore?

[iguanaiguana]

My list of towns from yesterday are still towns. Joseph is scum.

[schadd]

Schadd townslips again and again

Either he's been very well coached in the scum QT, which seems unlikely, or he's obv!town

vous have my permission to not point these out anymore

This is not a townslip. The discussion that schadd imagines is clearly taking place in the game thread.

perhaps. at least, the thing i theorized shouldn't need a daychat to work

Why wouldn't you want him to point them out anymore?

the point has been hammered into the ground. if i'm indeed being coached by my scumfriends (which seems to be the main concern?) then this is a bottomless well of town points. save it for when i'm about to be lynched at least.

[Joseph2302]

My list of towns from yesterday are still towns. Joseph is scum.

You're wrong.
I understand where people are coming from, but we need to find actual scum, not an idiot with a terrible reads list.
Lynching me is bad - easy mislynch, and what information will you get from it?

[Witherweaver]

I reread RR, that was a productive 17 seconds.  Said nothing D1.  Is lynchworthy. 

[gkrieg13]

My list of towns from yesterday are still towns. Joseph is scum.

You're wrong.
I understand where people are coming from, but we need to find actual scum, not an idiot with a terrible reads list.
Lynching me is bad - easy mislynch, and what information will you get from it?

I really don't like this defense.

[gkrieg13]

Schadd townslips again and again

Either he's been very well coached in the scum QT, which seems unlikely, or he's obv!town

vous have my permission to not point these out anymore

This is not a townslip. The discussion that schadd imagines is clearly taking place in the game thread.

perhaps. at least, the thing i theorized shouldn't need a daychat to work

Why wouldn't you want him to point them out anymore?

the point has been hammered into the ground. if i'm indeed being coached by my scumfriends (which seems to be the main concern?) then this is a bottomless well of town points. save it for when i'm about to be lynched at least.

Eh you look townie to me anyway.  You also seem like you would be terribly difficult to coach, because you have a very distinct style, and it seems like stuff that you were coached from would clearly not be from you if that makes sense.

[gkrieg13]

(i'm realizing how scary it is to have this many scum in the voterbase, and it is maybe easier for 2 people to coordinate a non-suspicious hammer than 3? but, ofc, i've never witnessed this scenario so i dunno)

I wouldn't worry about this until much later. I haven't really seen scum double hammer this early in the game.

There is no reason for scum to do this on D2.  It would look pretty suspicious.

[gkrieg13]

Day 1 Final Vote Count:

J Reggie (3):  iguanaiguana, schadd, LaLight
mail-mi (7): J Reggie, SpaceAnemone, gkrieg13, Joseph2302, faust, witherweaver, silverspawn
RoadRunner7671 (1): mail-mi

Not Voting (1): RR

With 12 alive, it took 7 to lynch.

So looking at the wagon, and knowing the alignments of silverspawn and faust, it leaves a pretty small list that probably contains at least one scum on it.  Unless all scum were on J Reggie (which seems pretty highly unlikely), then at least one is in the 4 people (WW, Joseph, SA, JReggie.)

I'll probably do rereads of those four later, but this makes me feel better about my vote on Joseph.

[Witherweaver]

Hm, that's not a bad point.

Except why are you assuming J Reggie is town?

[Witherweaver]

Oh, or maybe you're not.

[gkrieg13]

Ya I don't get where I'm assuming that.  And I'm not.