Here comes my first reread in a lifetime!
Joseph. D1His first post:
My favourite ice-cream is honeycomb
The second one:
Guys, you caught me.
I'm the SK again
More fluff (actually nothing but fluff from the start):
Yay the forum is back.
Vote: fds for trying to hold up this game and inhibit discussion. Obvious scum tell.
Faust wagon:
Let's start a good wagon:
Vote: faust
More faust wagon:
Faust usually isn't *this* fluffy though.
So why do you think me being more fluffy than usual means that I'm scum?
I believe it does.
I have reasons, but since you asked mail-mi, I'll let him respond first.
And 4 pages between these two messages.
Then the list:
Lynch list:
1. Witherweaver - null to mildly town
2. LaLight - lots of content, pro-town
3. silverspawn - not a lot there
4. gkrieg13 - put mail-mi on L-1, which isn't great. Not a lot else
5. faust - leaning towards scum
6. Roadrunner7671 - for the first time in forever, don't think he's scum
7. Joseph2302 - me. Absolutely no useful content so far
8. SpaceAnemone - mild town read on them, from very little content
9. J Reggie - trying to get the game moving early, and decently towny with most other things
10. schadd - lots of short posts, kind of null
11. iguanaiguana - mild town read
12. mail-mi - his wagon seemed a bit too easy for my liking. As he hasn't done anything super-scummy, it's likely there was scum on the wagon, and therefore more likely that he's town. Also seems different to the scum!mail-mi in a previous game
He defends mail-mi and it's a good thing, idk why should he do this as scum.
Is this silence because I'm in another timezone or because noone has nothing to say? Deadline is close, we need to decide something
Both.
I agree, we need to do something.
I suggested things, it's just people didn't like them.
I didn't see such things.
Again:
My preference for these 3 wagons is:
(Most wanted first)
faust
Mail-mi
JReggie
Normally faust is different to this.
In my mind, if you're scum then it's likely a mislynch will happen, so you need to commit less effort.
On the other hand, if you're town, it takes more effort to find scum.
I don't know how to react on this one:
Normally faust is different to this.
In my mind, if you're scum then it's likely a mislynch will happen, so you need to commit less effort.
On the other hand, if you're town, it takes more effort to find scum.
Again, this is not how I play as scum. Every time you think "someone is different than normal", your first reaction should be that that's a townie sign.
I play different almost every game, and no-one assumes I'm towny all the time.
I don't like going after RR D1, for similar but opposite reasons that I don't like going after Faust. At least, not today. He gets a D1 pass from me.
I don't like D1 lynching RR again.
Why?
Worth noting: a majority (7) isn't needed to lynch.
The person with most votes at deadline dies.
Vote: mail-mi
Faust isn't happening, and I really think JReggie is town.
More so than mail-mi
And that's the end of D1. Nothing really useful.D2:Rules clarifications at most:
Also, this tells us a little about the setup.
Either:
(1). There was 1 M roll, and faust is lying (seems unlikely to me)
(2). There were (at least) 3 M rolls, which means we have at most 3 other PRs
Also, this tells us a little about the setup.
Either:
(1). There was 1 M roll, and faust is lying (seems unlikely to me)
(2). There were (at least) 3 M rolls, which means we have at most 3 other PRs
I think you don't understand the setup.
Why? Isn't he right?
No. It's impossible to have only one Mason. What good is that? If one m were rolled, the ub would convert to a Mason.
Oh. In which case there would be 2 Masons (the one randomly chosen & the UB). Course.
also, does the fact that only one person died mean that someone doctored? if i understand the setup correctly, there is supposed to be 3 scum and two people die nightly. if somebody did doctor, any speculations on who was saved? all things considered, the very likely candidate is faust; as i mentioned, they seemed maybe not scummy but definitely like they knew something, and scum may have presumed that to mean they were masons. in which case, silverspawn also assumed that they knew—this (following) post makes more sense with that in mind.
I'm afraid mail-mi will flip town and then I'll get NKd as the least suspicious person and will be out of the game 
this is so spicy, you guys. we are gonna have to reread silverspawn a lot of times.
There's only 1 kill, unless there's a serial killer.
Scum may choose someone to kill, and SK (if they exist) can do as well.
Correction:
There's no SK in the setup.
There might be a vigilante though, who would be able to kill.
Apart from that, 1 death per night, which could be stopped by a doctor.
Unless mafia use strongman ability, which nulls the doctor effect.
IDK what to think about mafia QT mentioning:
i'm also incidentally pretty suspicious of me.
Really, because I'm not.
If you were scum, you would have asked your "Do 2 people die at night?" question in the mafia QT, rather than here.
More rules clarifications:
there's other stuff that makes me feel like you have a much better handle on things than you're saying
thank you
Haha, don't thank me yet... One thing that's making me quite suspicious is that you have the only use of the word "townslip" in this entire thread, which isn't really a very newbie sort of thing to come out with unless you were coached in a scum QT or something...
that is a term that i came up with while pooping. is it a real thing?
Yes it's a real term.
having read the rules, it says that dead players can't post anywhere except in their role qt. can ss still say stuff in the mason qt? that seems like it would be kinda silly
also, for the life of me i can't find where the rules might say how many people die each night.
No dead masons can't post in the QT.
He pledged but somehow didn't pledge:
So, the weekend is over, and it's time for ou guys to put in some work, make cases, and such things. I have thoughts, but I will not reveal them. Instead, I want everyone to take the following pledge:
"If there is no lynch 12 hours before deadline, I will vote for whoever faust decides we should lynch."
/pledge
Although hopefully we'll have more meaningful discussion than just sheep the IC
Bringing attention to his list again. Why?
Lynch list:
1. Witherweaver - null to mildly town
2. LaLight - lots of content, pro-town
3. silverspawn - not a lot there
4. gkrieg13 - put mail-mi on L-1, which isn't great. Not a lot else
5. faust - leaning towards scum
6. Roadrunner7671 - for the first time in forever, don't think he's scum
7. Joseph2302 - me. Absolutely no useful content so far
8. SpaceAnemone - mild town read on him, from very little content
9. J Reggie - trying to get the game moving early, and decently towny with most other things
10. schadd - lots of short posts, kind of null
11. iguanaiguana - mild town read
12. mail-mi - his wagon seemed a bit too easy for my liking. As he hasn't done anything super-scummy, it's likely there was scum on the wagon, and therefore more likely that he's town. Also seems different to the scum!mail-mi in a previous game
Here's my old lynch list- I'll review it properly some point.
faust is clearly town now, as were ss and mail-mi.
Man, these reads look so bad with hindsight
I think this is just strange:
Going to bed now, but a serious, thought-provoking question before I do.
If you were scum, who would you have killed N1?
PPE: two I think
Author
Topic: M86: Ghibli Mafia - Game over. (Read 164638 times)