Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[schadd]

Man, I'm so conflicted.

hey. you're the conflict, still.


i'm still inclined to agree with igu at the moment about j reggie. but faust also seems a little odd, like you're talking past people
mail-mi doesn't give me any bad impressions. it feels weird to me that none of the three people in front of the crosshairs seem particularly anxious (faust seems a bit millitant against his voters, maybe) but maybe that's just the way it goes. inexperienced, etc.

[J Reggie]

I realized that my case on J Reggie was based on a vague memory of a previous scum game of his, so I decided to dig up the quote.

It is here: http://forum.dominionstrategy.com/index.php?topic=15591.msg624261#msg624261

In Duel Mafia, scum!J Reggie takes a few stabs at scummy looking townies before giving up on having scumreads entirely. Before the end, he just says that he has no useful scumreads and doesn't even believe in the counter-wagon. Of course, in some ways he's being honest. He knew e was town, and had no useful scumreads. Odd though that he wouldn't put the effort in to make a case against e and try to get people off of him.

Anyway, in a non-obvious way, J Reggie's half-hearted stabs at this game and complete lack of pushing the game forward read very similarly to that scum game.

Could I be wrong and he be town? Sure, but I feel better about this case than most D1 cases that I push. I'm definitely not changing my vote.

How have I had a lack of pushing the game forward? I started the wagon on mail-mi. I still think he's scum. And I've been trying to figure Faust out. I think there's a good chance he's scum in this game as well. I get why you think I'm scum for meta reasons. I've been trying not to be the center of attention, which I usually do as town. And look how far that's gotten me.

[schadd]

I realized that my case on J Reggie was based on a vague memory of a previous scum game of his, so I decided to dig up the quote.

It is here: http://forum.dominionstrategy.com/index.php?topic=15591.msg624261#msg624261

In Duel Mafia, scum!J Reggie takes a few stabs at scummy looking townies before giving up on having scumreads entirely. Before the end, he just says that he has no useful scumreads and doesn't even believe in the counter-wagon. Of course, in some ways he's being honest. He knew e was town, and had no useful scumreads. Odd though that he wouldn't put the effort in to make a case against e and try to get people off of him.

Anyway, in a non-obvious way, J Reggie's half-hearted stabs at this game and complete lack of pushing the game forward read very similarly to that scum game.

Could I be wrong and he be town? Sure, but I feel better about this case than most D1 cases that I push. I'm definitely not changing my vote.

I started the wagon on mail-mi. I still think he's scum.

i'm pretty sure that's a bold-faced lie about bold-faced votes. you were the fifth vote on m-m, and i dunno if you can say that you started the wagon in the context of this post

[J Reggie]

I realized that my case on J Reggie was based on a vague memory of a previous scum game of his, so I decided to dig up the quote.

It is here: http://forum.dominionstrategy.com/index.php?topic=15591.msg624261#msg624261

In Duel Mafia, scum!J Reggie takes a few stabs at scummy looking townies before giving up on having scumreads entirely. Before the end, he just says that he has no useful scumreads and doesn't even believe in the counter-wagon. Of course, in some ways he's being honest. He knew e was town, and had no useful scumreads. Odd though that he wouldn't put the effort in to make a case against e and try to get people off of him.

Anyway, in a non-obvious way, J Reggie's half-hearted stabs at this game and complete lack of pushing the game forward read very similarly to that scum game.

Could I be wrong and he be town? Sure, but I feel better about this case than most D1 cases that I push. I'm definitely not changing my vote.

I started the wagon on mail-mi. I still think he's scum.

i'm pretty sure that's a bold-faced lie about bold-faced votes. you were the fifth vote on m-m, and i dunno if you can say that you started the wagon in the context of this post

Ok, I was wrong. For some reason I thought I started that wagon. Maybe it was because of interactions we had? Idk, I'll go back and reread when I have time.

[faust]

Man, I'm so conflicted.

hey. you're the conflict, still

I am the one who knocks.

[faust]

i'm still inclined to agree with igu at the moment about j reggie. but faust also seems a little odd, like you're talking past people
mail-mi doesn't give me any bad impressions. it feels weird to me that none of the three people in front of the crosshairs seem particularly anxious (faust seems a bit millitant against his voters, maybe) but maybe that's just the way it goes. inexperienced, etc.

It is. I mean, those are some bad votes right there. There's just nothing in terms of reasoning behind them. And I think of the possible wagons right now I am scum's favorite lynch by a large margin.

[faust]

Oh, and I started the mail-mi wagon! Pretty sure that means Reggie must now think I'm townie.

[J Reggie]

Oh, and I started the mail-mi wagon! Pretty sure that means Reggie must now think I'm townie.

You could be bussing 

[faust]

Oh, and I started the mail-mi wagon! Pretty sure that means Reggie must now think I'm townie.

You could be bussing 

So could you!

[schadd]

Oh, and I started the mail-mi wagon! Pretty sure that means Reggie must now think I'm townie.

well, to be fair. i was the first vote

[faust]

Oh, and I started the mail-mi wagon! Pretty sure that means Reggie must now think I'm townie.

well, to be fair. i was the first vote

True. But you voted, nothing happened. I voted, a wagon formed. Which isn't your fault really, people just like sheeping me a lot more than sheeping a newbie.

[schadd]

Oh, and I started the mail-mi wagon! Pretty sure that means Reggie must now think I'm townie.

well, to be fair. i was the first vote

True. But you voted, nothing happened. I voted, a wagon formed. Which isn't your fault really, people just like sheeping me a lot more than sheeping a newbie.

i would assert that people only voted with you because you're scum or something except the first one was igu and well i'm sheeping him (sorta) at the moment

[LaLight]

Oh, and I started the mail-mi wagon! Pretty sure that means Reggie must now think I'm townie.

You could be bussing 

So could you!

Or both of you. That could be really cool gambit: having you both and mail-mi scums in this game.

[iguanaiguana]

And as frustrating as it is, Faust is probably still a bad D1 lynch. He's too helpful as town, and scum will want too much for town to take him off of their hands without having to waste a night kill. He is a mislynch that scum loves to get on.

I am scum's favorite lynch by a large margin.

You could always credit your sources when you're paraphrasing something I just said ^^

[iguanaiguana]

Oh, and I started the mail-mi wagon! Pretty sure that means Reggie must now think I'm townie.

well, to be fair. i was the first vote

True. But you voted, nothing happened. I voted, a wagon formed. Which isn't your fault really, people just like sheeping me a lot more than sheeping a newbie.

i would assert that people only voted with you because you're scum or something except the first one was igu and well i'm sheeping him (sorta) at the moment

Wagons!

[schadd]

Oh, and I started the mail-mi wagon! Pretty sure that means Reggie must now think I'm townie.

well, to be fair. i was the first vote

True. But you voted, nothing happened. I voted, a wagon formed. Which isn't your fault really, people just like sheeping me a lot more than sheeping a newbie.

i would assert that people only voted with you because you're scum or something except the first one was igu and well i'm sheeping him (sorta) at the moment

Wagons!

yes. there are three of them in fact

[iguanaiguana]

J Reggie is probably a good one of those.

"Beep."

[gkrieg13]

Sorry guys.  Today is really busy and I probably won't get back to this game until tomorrow.

[silverspawn]

faust has been scummy, and him being a prime NK target isn't a reason not to lynch him.

Wrong. Of course that is a reason. Being a prime NK target means scum wants you dead more which means lynching you is worse

And it also means that you are automatically suspicious if you live longer, thus information helps with the case.

[silverspawn]

that last sentence didn't make sense. I meant to say that time automatically helps with the case.

[SpaceAnemone]

Huh, I'm still not understanding the J Reggie wagon at all, even though I think a bunch of strong people are backing it. I'm unlikely to move my vote there unless someone can break the case down into newbie-speak for me.

Faust's tone in his posts from earlier today seems oddly hostile and defensive, which makes me lean a bit more scum-wards on him than my reads yesterday.

@Iguana: what are your reasons for thinking that Mail-mi is a town? I feel like he's at least a bit scummy.

[J Reggie]

By the way, what has SpaceAnemone done in this game?  They have 19 (I think?) posts, most of which are jokes.

Is this ii's way of getting back at me for Fruit Ninja?

[mail-mi]

Faust's tone in his posts from earlier today seems oddly hostile and defensive.

These are the words I was looking for to describe my read on faust. Thanks SA.

[SpaceAnemone]

By the way, what has SpaceAnemone done in this game?  They have 19 (I think?) posts, most of which are jokes.

I'd just used up all of my free time (and several hours of hours of sleep!) trying to prove my innocence to Gkrieg in Haddock's BSG game, where Mail-mi was doing an unfortunately skilled scum job of making people vote for me :-(

Anyway, at least I've posted my reads on everyone, which ate up all of yesterday's free time. I'd find it quite helpful if more people posted complete lists too.

Now I'm reading f.ds an hour after I absolutely had to be asleep today... so that's not so good. More tomorrow :-P

[Roadrunner7671]

I'm getting more towny on J Reggie. Actually let's unvote