Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[mail-mi]

WW, Lalight: townie.
[...]
I'm okay with keeping my vote on ww for now.

?

The first part was from impressions from the beginning of the game. it was a train of thoughts post, writing stuff as I read.

So you think that WW is scummy because he suggested a flavor claim? Why?

Because all VTs have the same flavor name. It immediately outs all PRs.

[mail-mi]

WW, Lalight: townie.

J Reggie: slightly scummy, though he seems like the type of guy that gets scumread as town every game.

schadd seems very schadd-y. Is this his first game?

J Reggie is bad for suggesting a claim. WW is baaaaad for suggesting a flavor claim.

Joseph was RVSing too far into day 1. slightly scummy.

J Reggie/faust exchange seems like one of them could very well be scum. doesn't seem like town v town to me. Could even be scum v scum. Will look at more if one of them flips scum.

I'm okay with keeping my vote on ww for now.

I'm gonna do a line by line.

agree with LaLight being townie, but it scares me that he is pretty universally a town read.  Not so sure about WW.  He is pretty null to me

Yes it is his first game

I don't think suggesting claims is all that bad.  It wasn't very clear that all the VTs had the same flavor name.

Again, this is just Joseph being Joseph

What in their exchange makes you think it isn't town/town?

It's not all that bad, but it's still bad. Could have been town!WW or scum!WW not reading the set up, or scum!WW banking on lots of us not reading the set up. Both are about equally likely, so then it's more likely that he's scum in my mind right now.

It seems more likely that it's scum v scum than town v town. An early D1 bus that will never go anywhere except to maybe get some town credit, and faust's response seems wrong. Not sure about town v scum yet.

actually, i've just talked myself into it. JR also suggested a D1 claim. vote: J Reggie

[faust]

WW, Lalight: townie.
[...]
I'm okay with keeping my vote on ww for now.

?

The first part was from impressions from the beginning of the game. it was a train of thoughts post, writing stuff as I read.

So you think that WW is scummy because he suggested a flavor claim? Why?

Because all VTs have the same flavor name. It immediately outs all PRs.

I know why it's bad, but I asked why it is scummy.

[mail-mi]

WW, Lalight: townie.
[...]
I'm okay with keeping my vote on ww for now.

?

The first part was from impressions from the beginning of the game. it was a train of thoughts post, writing stuff as I read.

So you think that WW is scummy because he suggested a flavor claim? Why?

Because all VTs have the same flavor name. It immediately outs all PRs.

I know why it's bad, but I asked why it is scummy.

explained in the post above yours.

[schadd]

i'm still on the boat of voting mail-mi. it seems as though his approach is to brush me off as a dope rather than address the thing that i said and i kinda fancy myself not a dope


i don't have any other stances

[faust]

In my opinion scum does not approach D1 from a "how can I make the towns out all their PRs" angle. Scum is much more focused on keeping a low profile, appearing townie and generally helpful or whatever their meta is. It's probably overdone; I do think scum generally could get away with doing more rolefishing moves. But you really have to step out of your comfort zone for that, and in my experience, that's just not happening usually.

[gkrieg13]

In my opinion scum does not approach D1 from a "how can I make the towns out all their PRs" angle. Scum is much more focused on keeping a low profile, appearing townie and generally helpful or whatever their meta is. It's probably overdone; I do think scum generally could get away with doing more rolefishing moves. But you really have to step out of your comfort zone for that, and in my experience, that's just not happening usually.

Maybe this is true for most scum, but is it true of WW?

[faust]

Yes.

[mail-mi]

i'm still on the boat of voting mail-mi. it seems as though his approach is to brush me off as a dope rather than address the thing that i said and i kinda fancy myself not a dope


i don't have any other stances

uh nope not trying to brush you off as a dope.

since you'd like me to respond...

everyone is giving me ok vibes but i don't like that mail-mi was the 4th person to vote for me (though that might have just been an Out Of Character Joke) and then said a bunch mercurial stuff


so, uh, vote: mail-mi


also, how bad is it to say things like i also want to not be voting faust because we are scumfriends that were roommates in mafia school and also mail-mi told me to vote for him in our mason thing? asking for a friend

I voted for you to mess with the capitalization thing. It was RVS.

yeah because i've been busy with my other games and stuff. now i'm here tho.

[SpaceAnemone]

schadd seems very schadd-y. Is this his first game?

Yes it is his first game

Hurrah! I'm happier with the existence of more newbies... I was worried Schadd would turn out to be an oldie who'd just been away for long enough that I didn't recognise the name.

[LaLight]

I think town on mail-mi, he seems more reasonable than that time he was scum in Olympics. D1 claim as I remember is nonsense, I was once told this is not a good idea. I think on WW again. And I don't like that II posts little and the last was (I don't know how to quote in the middle of the sentence but I'll try):

What, we need wagons??? Never fear, Iguana is here!

Vote: Joseph

nevertheless vote: WW again. I just feel his play is wrong.

PPE

[J Reggie]

actually, i've just talked myself into it. JR also suggested a D1 claim. vote: J Reggie

Except I never did. I said all kinds of claims were probably bad and then suggested claiming or favorite ice cream flavors. The worst thing you can say about that is it's off topic.

[Roadrunner7671]

I just caught up and everything went in one ear and out the other.

The fact that I have less time means I'm going to form my own opinions and probably stop voting sheeping.

[Witherweaver]

WW, Lalight: townie.
[...]
I'm okay with keeping my vote on ww for now.

?

The first part was from impressions from the beginning of the game. it was a train of thoughts post, writing stuff as I read.

So you think that WW is scummy because he suggested a flavor claim? Why?

Because all VTs have the same flavor name. It immediately outs all PRs.

You think that I would, as scum, realize this and think that no one else would?

[Roadrunner7671]

Ugh. I can't believe WW is towny in my book because of that.

[schadd]

i'm still on the boat of voting mail-mi. it seems as though his approach is to brush me off as a dope rather than address the thing that i said and i kinda fancy myself not a dope


i don't have any other stances

uh nope not trying to brush you off as a dope.

since you'd like me to respond...

everyone is giving me ok vibes but i don't like that mail-mi was the 4th person to vote for me (though that might have just been an Out Of Character Joke) and then said a bunch mercurial stuff


so, uh, vote: mail-mi


also, how bad is it to say things like i also want to not be voting faust because we are scumfriends that were roommates in mafia school and also mail-mi told me to vote for him in our mason thing? asking for a friend

I voted for you to mess with the capitalization thing. It was RVS.

yeah because i've been busy with my other games and stuff. now i'm here tho.

o

[mail-mi]

WW, Lalight: townie.
[...]
I'm okay with keeping my vote on ww for now.

?

The first part was from impressions from the beginning of the game. it was a train of thoughts post, writing stuff as I read.

So you think that WW is scummy because he suggested a flavor claim? Why?

Because all VTs have the same flavor name. It immediately outs all PRs.

You think that I would, as scum, realize this and think that no one else would?

I explained this in my post 176. though, now that I've had some time to think about it, you're probably right. It's a very small chance that that would happen. like 2% compared to 49% town you didn't read the set up and 49% scum you didn't read the set up. So very, very minorly scummy.

and same goes for j reggie. But he has other stuff, so I'll keep my vote on him.

[J Reggie]

WW, Lalight: townie.
[...]
I'm okay with keeping my vote on ww for now.

?

The first part was from impressions from the beginning of the game. it was a train of thoughts post, writing stuff as I read.

So you think that WW is scummy because he suggested a flavor claim? Why?

Because all VTs have the same flavor name. It immediately outs all PRs.

You think that I would, as scum, realize this and think that no one else would?

I explained this in my post 176. though, now that I've had some time to think about it, you're probably right. It's a very small chance that that would happen. like 2% compared to 49% town you didn't read the set up and 49% scum you didn't read the set up. So very, very minorly scummy.

and same goes for j reggie. But he has other stuff, so I'll keep my vote on him.

What's my other stuff?

[schadd]

What's my other stuff?

you know, like, your screwdriver and pet hamster and stuff

[J Reggie]

What's my other stuff?

you know, like, your screwdriver and pet hamster and stuff

I have a screwdriver, not a pet hamster though. I don't see why that makes me scummy though.

[mail-mi]

I'll answer that when my sister decides that the Thundermans actually is a stupid show and gets off the computer.

[Roadrunner7671]

I'll answer that when my sister decides that the Thundermans actually is a stupid show and gets off the computer.

Get her to join Forum Mafia!

[schadd]

I'll answer that when my sister decides that the Thundermans actually is a stupid show and gets off the computer.

Get her to join Forum Mafia!

that would be unhelpful to the end of freeing the computer

[mail-mi]

What's my other stuff?

Mostly the interaction with faust. If it's town/scum, I think you're most likely to be the scum one.

and if it's scum/scum, well then both of you are the scum ones.

[Joseph2302]

Yay the forum is back.
Vote: fds for trying to hold up this game and inhibit discussion. Obvious scum tell.