Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[silverspawn]

okay, let me see.

[J Reggie]

I mean, is it possible for the same name to show up more than once?

It is not.

[silverspawn]

You mean that he wasn't around? His last post is this:

It honestly kinda seems like J Reggie's "neighborhood" is just "The Mafia."

That would be so stupid, but they are just playing like it is true.

Which is towny.

[iguanaiguana]

I pushed the Jan lynch hard, not even knowing whether it was going to work out or blow up in my face. I egged Roadrunner on toward the end of the day to stick to his commitment and lynch Jan. I've offered good analysis whenever I've had time, and when I haven't I've been prompt about letting people know that I can't give any feedback.

I have not been scummy. Read my periods of activity and look for scum tells. They are not there.

[gkrieg13]

Vote Count 3.2


J Reggie (2): Cellovix, Haddock
iguanaiguana (1): faust
Haddock (3): iguanaiguana, J Reggie, silverspawn

Not Voting (2): teamlyle, EFHW

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.  Day 3 ends Tuesday August 9, 12PM

[Haddock]

J Reggie (1): Cellovix, Haddock

is this an error?

[gkrieg13]

J Reggie (1): Cellovix, Haddock

is this an error?

What error?  What are you talking about...

Yes, I fixed it

[faust]

You mean that he wasn't around? His last post is this:

It honestly kinda seems like J Reggie's "neighborhood" is just "The Mafia."

That would be so stupid, but they are just playing like it is true.

Which is towny.

I mean that he didn't get lynched.

[faust]

It doesn't look good for Haddock that he disappeared today. He said we shouldn't lynch him while he sleeps, but so far he didn't give us any reason why we shouldn't have. Or maybe he's still asleep... but I doubt it.

[faust]

Thinking things over, now that I am less convinced that Haddock is town, we may want a claim after all.

[Haddock]

It doesn't look good for Haddock that he disappeared today. He said we shouldn't lynch him while he sleeps, but so far he didn't give us any reason why we shouldn't have. Or maybe he's still asleep... but I doubt it.

Nothing much going on and Ive been at work all day

What do you want me to say? You shouldnt lynch me, I'm town.  I can provide a full blown defense of myself if that would help, but I thought my play pretty much spoke for itself.  The Jan lynch which I contributed a lot to, as much as anything else.

There are reasons for me to want not to miss twilight, which will become clear.  That's why I want lynches to happen when I'm awake.

[Haddock]

Thinking things over, now that I am less convinced that Haddock is town, we may want a claim after all.

I'm not claiming.  You're really desperate aren't you? If reggie weren't confscum I'd be voting faust right now.

Faust was really towny for ages. My guess is he's an SK, since noone has claimed responsibility for the extra kill yesterday. His play makes a ton of sense for an SK when you think about it.

[faust]

You're really desperate aren't you?

That's a weird thing to say about me, considering I have been the only person defending you throughout the day.

[Haddock]

You're really desperate aren't you?

That's a weird thing to say about me, considering I have been the only person defending you throughout the day.

Hey, I'm grateful for it. But you do seem to be struggling to make anything stick. Fair to say? 
That's not really surprising when you're the only one trying to lynch outside of me/reggie.

I stand by what I said also. I don't think you make sense as reggie's partner, but you could very well be an SK. And that would explain how your outlook today is very different to everyone else's.

[faust]

Hey, I'm grateful for it. But you do seem to be struggling to make anything stick. Fair to say? 
That's not really surprising when you're the only one trying to lynch outside of me/reggie.

I stand by what I said also. I don't think you make sense as reggie's partner, but you could very well be an SK. And that would explain how your outlook today is very different to everyone else's.

I'm not quite sure what you mean. How would SK!me prefer to not get two people lynched in a row who both aren't me?

[EFHW]

Oh, hey, forum is back up.

My vote is still on Chairs in spirit, but I'm going to take a different route for now and

Vote: Jan.

She has too much focus on flavor and trying to appear helpful, not enough content and trying to find scum.  Talking about the flavor source for the game is fine in RVS, but we've long since left it behind, and it doesn't sit right with me.  There was also the thing where she soft attacked RoadRunner for being defensive of vote(s) on him, but left her vote on her RVS target.

So, talk to me, Jan, oh lover of flavor.  What are three non-flavor related things that you've seen that you think come from a scum mindset?  What are three non-flavor related things you think come from a town mindset?

If you could kill two people right now, who would they be? (And vote one of those two, if you could!)

This case on Jan is what solidified my townread on Cellovix. I've made stronger cases against scum teammates, but I'm thinking this isn't Jan's partner.

Of course, an SK will scumhunt like the best of them, so can't rule that out.

[EFHW]

RR could have used Jan's ability to protect himself, but he died anyway, so I think scum must have a roleblocker.

Whoops, his power didn't work on factional abilities, like the nk.

If Sylar killed RR, would he have Jan's power now, if RR chose to use it? 

I'm trying to figure out if J Reggie could have been redirected last night, but it's super complicated.  He took two actions with 3 targets, targeting me twice (once to neighborize, once to track), Haddock and teamlyle each once.  Clearly both actions were not redirected b/c chairs didn't target Seprix, RR and cron.  If scum could redirect one action, maybe they tried to get into the neighborhood by redirecting to one of themselves, and got tracked instead.

[EFHW]

Convoluted theories aside, I still think we should lynch Haddock today.

[EFHW]

vote: Haddock  That's L-1.

[teamlyle]

vote: Haddock  That's L-1.

I think that haddock is probably scum, but should I?

[Haddock]

vote: Haddock  That's L-1.

I think that haddock is probably scum, but should I?

You shouldn't.

Please people, I know it's hard to ignore Reggie's cwazy claim, and try to look at the game without that. Ever since I got back from vla I've been contributing as well as I possibly can and being generally helpful. It sucks that my reads have been so poor, but I'm doing my utmost here.

Noone has presented a case beyond Reggie's claim, so it comes down to this: who is townier, me or reggie?  I'd been townreading reggie, so I get that it's a tough decision - but where did all the people who were scumreading reggie go when he pulled out this claim? It's not like it clears him - quite the opposite!

[gkrieg13]

Vote Count 3.3


J Reggie (2): Cellovix, Haddock
iguanaiguana (1): faust
Haddock (4): iguanaiguana, J Reggie, silverspawn, EFHW {L-1}

Not Voting (1): teamlyle

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.  Day 3 ends Tuesday August 9, 12PM

[silverspawn]

vote: Haddock  That's L-1.

I think that haddock is probably scum, but should I?

You shouldn't.

Please people, I know it's hard to ignore Reggie's cwazy claim, and try to look at the game without that. Ever since I got back from vla I've been contributing as well as I possibly can and being generally helpful. It sucks that my reads have been so poor, but I'm doing my utmost here.

Noone has presented a case beyond Reggie's claim, so it comes down to this: who is townier, me or reggie?  I'd been townreading reggie, so I get that it's a tough decision - but where did all the people who were scumreading reggie go when he pulled out this claim? It's not like it clears him - quite the opposite!

I think there are a lot of reasons why you are more likely scum than him. I posted them before.

[teamlyle]

Last time the forum went down, Haddock asked if J Reggie needed any backup because J Reggie got a couple of votes. (This discussion happened in the neighborhood.) If Haddock was scum then he probably wouldn't have asked.

Vote: J Reggie

[silverspawn]

Last time the forum went down, Haddock asked if J Reggie needed any backup because J Reggie got a couple of votes. (This discussion happened in the neighborhood.) If Haddock was scum then he probably wouldn't have asked.

Vote: J Reggie

that seems like a mild scum tell if anything. why would you give town cred for that?