OK:
Day1 Catch-up time, just making notes as things stand out. If you didn't have anything it is cause stuff didn't stand out, not that you weren't posting
Player list:
1. Gkrieg13 - 140 agree that his catch up post was scummy
2. Awaclus - absolutely nothing worthwhile to read him by. He will disagree. He always does. Far superior lynch option to EgorK (confirmation bias working here as I know EgorK was town). oh, now i have something scummy to read him on, his move to 2.7. Town!Awaclus wouldn't move a vote here I don't think. Too useful to town. Same with move to EgorK (oh that came after the softclaim.... so nevermind on that second part).
3. Haddock - 218 townie post from haddock; haddock is doing some huge posts. Reads town, at least for now.
4. Pingpongsam - 265 see below - 400 is a good enough post; 438 made me throw up in my mouth; 452 is provably false
5. Silverspawn - 114 first scummy post of game; 160 felt like posts he made in Treehugger mafia; 267 see below; 349 scummy vote moving from ss to iguana; pitting themselves more against each other; scummy vote on haddock 505
6. Joseph
7. Iguanaiguana - 245 - why want to play like awaclus? 285 - good post from iguana, going back and pulling research to prevent a lynch is generally more of a town play. Only way this makes sense as mafia is if Joseph/ii are partners together. This that he is town + his case (290) on townie 2.7 make me more suspicious of those that sheeped him. Vote Counts are scarce, will have to manually figure out who those people are but looks like most people voted before he made his case... hmmmm.... super townie tunneling. I mean not townie to tunnel, but he has got to be town the way he is doing it. And then you had to go an self vote and ruin it all... Boo
8. ADK - I get the others sticking hard and fast to Joseph, but not ADK. I didn't see anything else to make me think he was scummy except for this.
9. 2.7 - hasn't been counter claimed so rereading with assumption he is town?
10. Chairs: had town reads on: had scum reads on: Joseph
11. EgorK
12. J Reggie
13. Seprix - 189 see below; 253 see below; another scummy post (336) saying he would be fine lynching but doesn't actually want to. same as 382; 499 - lurker lynches in later days make no sense to me - bad vote on haddock; scummy vote moving back to joseph late.
Thoughts on major wagons:
Joseph (6): Gkrieg13, 2.7, Awaclus, Iguanaiguana, ADK, Reggie
seemed like a lazy wagon, but maybe not scummy. I didn't get scum reads on anything that Joseph said; felt like his reaction to being hammered was nullish to townish; don't like Seprix's vote (189) on Reggie for putting him at L-1. Why focus on only the L-1 vote when any unvote could have moved him back to L-2. Don't get scum reads from gkrieg/awaclus wanting hammers. Fake hammers are mildly annoying and generally not actually trying to be fake but accidental, but don't think they are scummy. Seprix comes off as super scummy in general in regard to Joseph. His 253 in particular. So is PPS coming in late (265) on the parade (same as ss, 267). Oh man! So did chairs (272)! Well if he did it and is town then everyone else who did it must be town right? Right? Nah.
2.7 voters: Joseph early, ss (230), iguana (243), gkrieg (247), reggie (249), seprix (250) (don't know if there were any unvotes in this process) iguana makes his case here (haddock 290)
By time vote count came around was at:
(328) 2.7 (5): silverspawn, Iguanaiguana, gkrieg13, Seprix, Haddock
EgorK: 2.7 starts; ss jump starts, iguana joins-leaves; joseph joins; J Reggie joins; gkrieg joins after the Joseph wagon; ADK joins
Egork (7): 2.7, silverspawn, J Reggie, Joseph2302, A Drowned Kernel, Haddock, Awaclus
Joseph2302 second wagon (6): A Drowned Kernel, Awaclus, pingpongsam, chairs, iguanaiguana, Seprix (second go round) I think here that if Joseph is scum another scum partner buss hammers him. Second time getting to L-1, lynch looks eminent (EgorK known to be town says he will hammer). So I don't think he is scum.
2.7 second wagon: gkrieg13, Haddock, Seprix, Iguganaiguana, EgorK
tl:dr
Town reads on: iguanaiguana, Joseph, Haddock
Null on: Reggie (lots of people reading him town, I am not so certain but probably the towniest of the null players), gkrieg
Scummy on: ss, seprix, ADK - mostly on ss, somewhat on seprix, kinda on ADK
scummy at least partially due to a bias: Awaclus, pps more on Awaclus than pps, but also just can't read
vote: ss
it is late, but I'll formalize the posts and why they stuck out to me more tomorrow.