Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[A Drowned Kernel]

What did people think of the setup? Interesting? Boring? Unbalanced? Is the PGO power pointless? I think scum got pretty lucky with their spread, they knew the whole setup from the start.

MVP is tough, Hydrad and scott both played very solid games. I'm leaning Hydrad but would be interested in hearing the scum team's thoughts.

[scott_pilgrim]

I'm really glad this is over because I was getting really stressed.  I really didn't want to bus Hydrad, but I was pretty much going to have to because of PoE...I was already fairly committed to a town read on EgorK, and I don't think I could have possibly argued for a faust/Teproc scum team, which would leave Hydrad on any other possible scum team.

I started feeling bad for Teproc later on...a lot of my frustration was legitimate.  I think we both just saw everything in this game very differently.  Sorry if I said anything insulting or condescending.

I think this is a really cool set-up.  There are a lot of powers that all have the potential to be amazing, but are extremely difficult to use.  Like early on, I was terrified of the roleblockers, because I thought if we get blocked, not only does that catch scum, but all three RB's are then cleared as town.  That's sort of an exaggeration, but it was still scary.

[A Drowned Kernel]

I definitely thought that as the only all-town neighborhood the Roleblockers were going to have a much larger effect on this game but they ended up pretty neutered.

[A Drowned Kernel]

Oh, and to answer the question at the end of the scum QT, no I would not consider attempting a kill and being blocked as a "no-kill". My ruling was to prevent the possibility of a stalemate, which the Roleblocker situation would not be.

[Hydrad]

I feel like for me at first I thought the PR's were weak for town.

But the closer to the end of the game you get the stronger the PR's seem to become. As scum can never really get rid of powers and town will always be left with some at the end of the game. So in a way its like all we did for kills and lynches was hit VT's every day unless we killed a whole neighborhood.

[yuma]

Well... that wasn't what I expected at all.

[iguanaiguana]

Yay!  Go team!

Didn't you win either way?

[gkrieg13]

Yay!  Go team!

Didn't you win either way?

ADK said only a scum win would count for me at this point

[Witherweaver]

I should have pushed Limetime more D2.  But, well stuff.

[iguanaiguana]

Yay!  Go team!

Didn't you win either way?

ADK said only a scum win would count for me at this point

Fair enough, you were a pretty scummy IC

[gkrieg13]

Yay!  Go team!

Didn't you win either way?

ADK said only a scum win would count for me at this point

Fair enough, you were a pretty scummy IC

ya I don't really like being IC

[faust]

I guess I really cannot read Teproc.

[Witherweaver]

I think the Hydrad-not-getting-quickhammered-point should have made a bigger impact, though.

[Witherweaver]

Or maybe not, since it only holds if Faust is town.

[Hydrad]

I think the Hydrad-not-getting-quickhammered-point should have made a bigger impact, though.

Right. But I didn't want to point it out to much because then it would turn into me vs faust pretty much. And I was hoping faust might turn onto teproc at somepoint still.

[faust]

I wonder where things would have gone if Teproc hadn't voted... scott would have had to take a stance at some point, and arguing against Hydrad didn't really make sense for him.

But I don't know if I could have convinced myself to not lynch Teproc D4, even if he successfully blocked.

[faust]

Oh, and to answer the question at the end of the scum QT, no I would not consider attempting a kill and being blocked as a "no-kill". My ruling was to prevent the possibility of a stalemate, which the Roleblocker situation would not be.

But that would have been a stalemate too if Teproc was scum: he could just always block his partner.

[faust]

Going by the speccy, I really feel like I'm playing mafia with a built-in timer: I have to lynch scum quickly enough or everyone automatically assumes that I am scum.

[Witherweaver]

Toss a Hydrad in there, so

{Limtetime/Gkrieg, SS, SP, Hydrad}

no ordering there.

Why don't I listen to myself!  Or, why didn't I think this earlier.

[Witherweaver]

Going by the speccy, I really feel like I'm playing mafia with a built-in timer: I have to lynch scum quickly enough or everyone automatically assumes that I am scum.

Athletes at the top of their profession have the same problem.  Have to do amazing things, have to keep winning, or else they're just one-trick ponies. 

[A Drowned Kernel]

Mafia 78 (Mar. 7, – Apr. 19, 2016)
Insomnia Mafia by A Drowned Kernel (MVP:)

Player list (post count): Roadrunner 7671 (127), gkrieg13- Innocent Child (72), faust (392), silverspawn (198), yuma (206), 2,71828... (94), Hydrad- Mafia Goon (75), EgorK (51), Joseph2302 (47), Limetime- Mafia Goon (14), replaced by gkrieg13 (72), Teproc (320), Witherweaver (222), scott_pilgrim- Mafia Goon (87)
Total posts: 2011 (154.69 per player)

D1 Mislynch: Joseph2302 (VT) by faust, EgorK, silverspawn, 2.71828, scott_piglrim, Hydrad, Teproc
N1 Kill: gkrieg13 (Innocent Child)
D2 Mislynch: Roadrunner7671 (VT) by silverspawn, EgorK, gkrieg13, 2.71828, Teproc, Hydrad
N2 Kill: yuma (VT)
D3 Correct Lynch: gkrieg13 (Mafia Goon) by faust, EgorK, Hydrad, Teproc, Witherweaver
N3 Kill: 2.71828...
D4 Mislynch: silverspawn (VT) by faust, Hydrad, Witherweaver, Teproc 
N4 Kill: Witherweaver (VT)
D5 Mislynch: faust (VT) by Teproc, Hydrad, scott_pilgrim

[iguanaiguana]

Going by the speccy, I really feel like I'm playing mafia with a built-in timer: I have to lynch scum quickly enough or everyone automatically assumes that I am scum.

Lose a few more games like this one and you may not have that problem anymore!

[faust]

Going by the speccy, I really feel like I'm playing mafia with a built-in timer: I have to lynch scum quickly enough or everyone automatically assumes that I am scum.

Lose a few more games like this one and you may not have that problem anymore!

Well, now I'll just be gone until everyone has forgotten about me!

[Teproc]

Going by the speccy, I really feel like I'm playing mafia with a built-in timer: I have to lynch scum quickly enough or everyone automatically assumes that I am scum.

Or maybe, just maybe it's because you played insanely scummy this game. But you know, you can keep on thinking it's just the evil fds meta.

[silverspawn]

At least Teproc was town.