Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[faust]

Okay... what is the scum narrative for yuma then?

Well almost everyone treats him as confirmed town. That's a pretty good thing for anyone, including scum.

Except we're going to make sure that he dies before D3. That does not seem optimal for scum.

well... isn't that kinda ok still for scum? like we basically lose a lynch?

I don't follow.

[Hydrad]

Okay... what is the scum narrative for yuma then?

Well almost everyone treats him as confirmed town. That's a pretty good thing for anyone, including scum.

Except we're going to make sure that he dies before D3. That does not seem optimal for scum.

well... isn't that kinda ok still for scum? like we basically lose a lynch?

I don't follow.

oh nevermind. your saying its not optimal if he fake claimed this as scum.

[A Drowned Kernel]

uhhhhh. someone tell me whos scum.

chairs and ADK.

chairs yes, ADK no.

[yuma]

posty posty

[yuma]

Got super townie vibes from haddock's post. Hasn't mentioned that before. But yeah. Throwing that out there

ah, here is something to actually comment on. I agree! those stream of conscious posts are relatively hard to fake.

[yuma]

Okay... what is the scum narrative for yuma then?

Well almost everyone treats him as confirmed town. That's a pretty good thing for anyone, including scum.

Except we're going to make sure that he dies before D3. That does not seem optimal for scum.

I don't think there is a scum narrative for me doing this. But that said, I don't necessarily think that lynching me is a bad thing. I do worry about the potential for my infection to spread to my new role before I am able to switch to it... I would like to stay town and stay alive (as in continue to be able to vote/post/use roles) in this game, truth be told... And frankly dying in this case ironically helps me do that.

[2.71828.....]

So, I am pretty sure I get your role, but to put it in mafia terms you are 1-shot death proof. Because that what it sounds like to me.

[chairs]

uhhhhh. someone tell me whos scum.

chairs and ADK.

chairs yes, ADK no.

chairs no, kthxbai.

[SirMartin]

So I don't have long, but I'll point out that chsirs didn't talk very much when we were on patrol.

[2.71828.....]

So a lynch+bite would be two "deaths"

Just bite is one death.

Except this isn't normal mafia. I don't know, I think keeping yuma around to see if he will be able to come back healthy child seems like a good idea. Whereas lynching might trigger a "second death"

Although action resolution seems tricky here

[2.71828.....]

So I don't have long, but I'll point out that chsirs didn't talk very much when we were on patrol.

It was in a qt. Plus it is chairs. Not a scum tell

[chairs]

I didn't feel like anybody talked much in the patrol QT, honestly.

[yuma]

So, I am pretty sure I get your role, but to put it in mafia terms you are 1-shot death proof. Because that what it sounds like to me.

Except I get a new role/flavor/etc after using up the deathproof.

[Roadrunner7671]

Duane broke a rule and it cost him.  I tried to stop it.  I tried to help him.  It's...it's my fault.  It was my job to keep him safe.

I thought this was a little strange in the flavor. Duane's death wasn't his own fault, as Faust explained, Duane got killed by his zombiefied mom cause Mirgan couldn't pop her.

Morgan's weakness lead to Duane's death, but he's not taking responsibility. Well, he is, he thinks it's his fault. But he also thinks Duane broke a rule, which really isn't true. We know Ashersky thinks about the flavor for a while, so this could be something intentional. I do think we should analye the flavor though.

[faust]

Duane broke a rule and it cost him.  I tried to stop it.  I tried to help him.  It's...it's my fault.  It was my job to keep him safe.

I thought this was a little strange in the flavor. Duane's death wasn't his own fault, as Faust explained, Duane got killed by his zombiefied mom cause Mirgan couldn't pop her.

Morgan's weakness lead to Duane's death, but he's not taking responsibility. Well, he is, he thinks it's his fault. But he also thinks Duane broke a rule, which really isn't true. We know Ashersky thinks about the flavor for a while, so this could be something intentional. I do think we should analye the flavor though.

This is a good observation. I can't really tell what this means with respect to the game, but these are definitely the things we should look out for going forward.

[yuma]

Duane broke a rule and it cost him.  I tried to stop it.  I tried to help him.  It's...it's my fault.  It was my job to keep him safe.

I thought this was a little strange in the flavor. Duane's death wasn't his own fault, as Faust explained, Duane got killed by his zombiefied mom cause Mirgan couldn't pop her.

Morgan's weakness lead to Duane's death, but he's not taking responsibility. Well, he is, he thinks it's his fault. But he also thinks Duane broke a rule, which really isn't true. We know Ashersky thinks about the flavor for a while, so this could be something intentional. I do think we should analye the flavor though.

I don't know anything about the show, but since this was written at the time of ash putting the rules in place I interpreted as him saying that if you break rules you will pay a price. And we have already seen that happen twice in this game with hated modifiers being applied...

[Ampharos]

I didn't feel like anybody talked much in the patrol QT, honestly.

Pretty much.  It was bones quiet.

[EFHW]

I didn't feel like anybody talked much in the patrol QT, honestly.

Pretty much.  It was bones quiet.

So why is sir Martin singling out chairs?

[Haddock]

If it's true that not much was going on in the qt, it does feel like a pretty transparent attempt by SirMartin to paint chairs as scummy.
But surely that's too obvious a move for a scum play.

[2.71828.....]

I didn't feel like anybody talked much in the patrol QT, honestly.

Pretty much.  It was bones quiet.

So why is sir Martin singling out chairs?

Yeah. At first I thought it was just normal low activity (I can't say that I would be especially active and talkative in a patrol qt either), but this is singling out chairs.

Scum trying to push a chairs case over the brink to a lynch?

[2.71828.....]

If it's true that not much was going on in the qt, it does feel like a pretty transparent attempt by SirMartin to paint chairs as scummy.
But surely that's too obvious a move for a scum play.

Ah, the classic "too scummy to be scum" case. How I love you

[2.71828.....]

I do appreciate the "bones quiet" from ampharos

[Haddock]

If it's true that not much was going on in the qt, it does feel like a pretty transparent attempt by SirMartin to paint chairs as scummy.
But surely that's too obvious a move for a scum play.

Ah, the classic "too scummy to be scum" case. How I love you

I wasn't really making a case either way.

Given that it's the only thing I can remember SirMartin doing this game (and yes I'm aware that's quite unfair,  he's been on patrol), I could easily see it as either alignment, a player becoming aware that they need to contribute a case or a read.
That's something people do as either alignment. But I'd say SirMartin is a somewhat lurky player anyway, so perhaps this move indicates some scummy self-awareness?
I'm reaching a bit here.

[faust]

Well, we need to go somewhere. How about some good old PoE?

Witherweaver - he's been gone for a while, but I like what he posted since.
yuma - probably town, plus it will be helpful to know how infections work.
2.7 - what has e done this game? I have no idea. That's not a good sign.
gkrieg13 - not very present, but I get a generally genuine vibe.
faust - no way.
EFHW - she's been talking a lot about the setup and very little about reads. Suspicious.
Roadrunner7671 - he reads very townie to me in this game.
A Drowned Kernel - well he's scummy, as already pointed out.
Haddock - I'm willing to sheep yuma and whoever else that was on this one.
silverspawn - anyone else think his stance on yuma is weird? I don't like how he uses it as an excuse to not scumhunt.
Hydrad, Limetime, Ampharos - all the same lurkish category.
chairs - also lurky, but additionally was scummy early on.
SirMartin - there was some post at game start that made me think he's town. Something about knowing another townie?

[gkrieg13]

I feel like of the people on your PoE list, EFHW and ADK stand out the most to me.

EFHW is normally way more present at the beginning of a game, and when she has been present, she hasn't really added much to the conversation.