Oh, game-related stuff? Why is ss scum? I think haddock has been much scummier.
Scratch that question. Terribly hard to answer while drunk.
Better: list 3 reasons to NOT vote for haddock
(Still, not a question, I know. But lists are easier to do)
Here's my problem. You and Haddock are very similar cases. It's all rhetoric analysis and you're both good enough at rhetoric that it's hard to do, especially on D1. Maybe Haddock is scum, and if he is I hope that by D2 or D3 we can figure that out. But right now I don't see it. So what I've got is this:
Towniest > Scummiest
Me
Hydrad
Joseph
Ashersky
Awaclus
Haddock
e
Witherweaver
silverspawn
where I'm very open to the possibility of anyone from Ashersky up being scum and not super sure about any of them, except that I have a really good feeling about silver.
In a way, e, even your "list 3 reasons" thing is a little scummy. If there is a good chance that Haddock is town, that's a good reason not to lynch him. I don't need any more reasons.