Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[faust]

I think this setup would be very challenging but not unreasonably so for scum as long as town doesn't get a cop. The cop just made it entirely impossible.

Cops suck.

[gkrieg13]

Sorry I still need to pick MVP.

[gkrieg13]

I am deciding between Haddock and ashersky for MVP but it is difficult.  Haddock has good PR choices, but he was unable to get a lynch on ash without outing himself as a cop.  Ashersky played well to not be detected, but there was the whole drunk claiming VT thing.  He also wasn't on the winning team.

I think for overall play, I have to give MVP to ashersky

[2.71828.....]

So, am I allowed to disagree. 2 things I think ashersky could have done that might have won the game:

1) not kill hydrad (debatable)
2) Use godfather.

This second one is beyond question. Godfather makes Ash IC and scum probably wins. Well, still maybe not due to PoE.  But a clutch godfather would have been mvp in my opinion. Also, ash hit L-1 before the haddock even claimed. So played well not to be detected is a stretch.

But maybe people disagree with me, plus mod has final say

[gkrieg13]

So, am I allowed to disagree. 2 things I think ashersky could have done that might have won the game:

1) not kill hydrad (debatable)
2) Use godfather.

This second one is beyond question. Godfather makes Ash IC and scum probably wins. Well, still maybe not due to PoE.  But a clutch godfather would have been mvp in my opinion. Also, ash hit L-1 before the haddock even claimed. So played well not to be detected is a stretch.

But maybe people disagree with me, plus mod has final say

Of course you are allowed to disagree!  It was kinda a weird game anyway, so I thought there would be disagreement.  My feeling was that ash wouldn't have been lynched had Haddock not claimed.  I agree that godfather would've made the choice easier for MVP. 

[2.71828.....]

But.....Haddock claimed. So this is a part on the back, good ole try mvp. Not a you helped win the game, congrats mvp

[2.71828.....]

*pat

[iguanaiguana]

Godfather wasn't the best choice statistically?

[ashersky]

Godfather wasn't the best choice statistically?

That's where I ended up.  In the QT, I started off with Godfather, as that was my gut reaction.  I tried being more rational given the possibilities and switched.  Staying with GF would have been the significantly better result, but would have been luck-based, right?

As for the drunk claim, believe what you will, but I did "decide" to claim purposefully.  Besides, that whole sequence, including QT posts, while being embarrassing in retrospect, was pretty hilarious.

Thanks gkrieg.  I think you should run this setup again with a few tweaks.  We could get it to a standard setup I think.

[Awaclus]

I think you should run this setup again with a few tweaks.  We could get it to a standard setup I think.

Just removing Cop from the list of possible town roles would go a long way.

[gkrieg13]

I think you should run this setup again with a few tweaks.  We could get it to a standard setup I think.

Just removing Cop from the list of possible town roles would go a long way.

I agree. I also want to keep the modifiers hidden and make a variable number of PRs