Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Axxle]

I didn't find it particularly townie, and I know some players tend to give read lists more often as scum since it's a good way to look like you're doing something while keeping the game state pretty much the same. Gkrieg broght up your reaction to my claim so I went back to go look at it. It definitely read a bit scummy. It seemed like you didn't want to draw attention to yourself with a questionable vote so wanted others to take the first step.

[Hydrad]

I didn't find it particularly townie, and I know some players tend to give read lists more often as scum since it's a good way to look like you're doing something while keeping the game state pretty much the same. Gkrieg broght up your reaction to my claim so I went back to go look at it. It definitely read a bit scummy. It seemed like you didn't want to draw attention to yourself with a questionable vote so wanted others to take the first step.

Hmm ok makes sense.

[silverspawn]

Vote Count 1.9

Haddock (2): Ichimaru Gin, Awaclus
Witherweaver (2): Hydrad, e
gkrieg13 (1): Witherweaver
Hydrad (2): chairs, Axxle
Roadrunner7671 (1): Haddock
chairs (2): Roadrunner7671, gkrieg13

Not Voting (2): pingpongsam, Limetime

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch. Day 1 ends at Mar 12, 6 PM forum time. That is in 5 days and 12+ hours.

[Haddock]

Hmm.  I could maybe go for Hydrad, or MAYBE maybe gkrieg?  I don't think I like any of the other wagons much at all.  Thinking.

[chairs]

I like the hydrad wagon. Can't say I care for any others much. Would also lynch awaclus.

[gkrieg13]

I'm fine with the Hydrad wagon

vote: Hydrad

[Haddock]

The people I would be happy lynching today probably goes something like:

RR=Hydrad > Axxle = PPS >> e.

RR and Hydrad have both done things that are either out of character or seem like forced versions of their character.  Obviously this is weak, but as a Day 1 thing I'm happy with it.

The other three are there mostly because I can't really read them.  I think e is vaguely towny but I'm acutely aware that I can't read e at all, so he has to be a D1 option.

vote: Hydrad

PPE. huh.  OK, I'm alright with that.

[Hydrad]

oh this is unfortunate.

and there isn't much I feel I can defend myself with.

I guess Ill say I'm still okay with the gkrieg lynch because of what axxle said but I'm confused as to why thats so scummy. For me day 1 is a shot in the dark most of the time. So getting something that has a protown benifit plus the chance that gkrieg is scum anyways seems like a good deal to me.

[2.71828.....]

I believe I addressed hydrad earlier today, with the conclusion that while he is ultimately scummy, we should wait until at least D2 to lynch him. He seems more like a solid D3 lynch though.

I think WW is the best target for today though.
1) He had gone far too long without being scum
2) I don't like his vote or reasoning behind gkrieg being scum.
3) lynching people is fun

Basically an airtight case

[pingpongsam]

The other three are there mostly because I can't really read them.

I'm not sure if I can be any more clear than I already have:

Confirmed, I am town aligned.

[Ichimaru Gin]

Here for a sec. Lots of homework right now. Should be back with some stuff to say tonight.
ppe: 1

[Haddock]

The other three are there mostly because I can't really read them.

I'm not sure if I can be any more clear than I already have:

Confirmed, I am town aligned.

If this is supposed to mean something then maybe someone can enlighten me. 
If not, you just end up looking dangerously like Awaclus in Cupcake mafia, who continued insisting through the game that he was an IC, until he got lynched and flipped scum on the final day.

[Haddock]

Also, e, I like your point 2 - maybe.  But 1 and 3, not so much.  And WW just feels right to me.

[pingpongsam]

The other three are there mostly because I can't really read them.

I'm not sure if I can be any more clear than I already have:

Confirmed, I am town aligned.

If this is supposed to mean something then maybe someone can enlighten me. 
If not, you just end up looking dangerously like Awaclus in Cupcake mafia, who continued insisting through the game that he was an IC, until he got lynched and flipped scum on the final day.

95% of what I post is pure good humor. I'm having fun. You, on the other hand have already had a coronary once this game.
The fact is, I've not done anything remotely scummy. I'm actually playing a very protown game there just isn't much to do this day which is as expected for RMM.
I am no Awaclus; he is consistently Awaclus and I am consistently PPS. I am well within my town meta.

[Haddock]

The other three are there mostly because I can't really read them.

I'm not sure if I can be any more clear than I already have:

Confirmed, I am town aligned.

If this is supposed to mean something then maybe someone can enlighten me. 
If not, you just end up looking dangerously like Awaclus in Cupcake mafia, who continued insisting through the game that he was an IC, until he got lynched and flipped scum on the final day.

95% of what I post is pure good humor. I'm having fun. You, on the other hand have already had a coronary once this game.
The fact is, I've not done anything remotely scummy. I'm actually playing a very protown game there just isn't much to do this day which is as expected for RMM.
I am no Awaclus; he is consistently Awaclus and I am consistently PPS. I am well within my town meta.

I love the implication that I'm somehow the most wiredup player on the forums or something.  I think I'm probably on the laid back end when it comes to mafia, but maybe people can correct me about that.  But noone likes being put to L-1 on D1.

My point is that I don't know if your last sentence is true - I'm not sufficiently familiar with your meta to judge.  That fact alone means that I wouldn't be massively opposed to your lynch, which is all I'm saying by including you on a would-lynch list.

[pingpongsam]

The other three are there mostly because I can't really read them.

I'm not sure if I can be any more clear than I already have:

Confirmed, I am town aligned.

If this is supposed to mean something then maybe someone can enlighten me. 
If not, you just end up looking dangerously like Awaclus in Cupcake mafia, who continued insisting through the game that he was an IC, until he got lynched and flipped scum on the final day.

95% of what I post is pure good humor. I'm having fun. You, on the other hand have already had a coronary once this game.
The fact is, I've not done anything remotely scummy. I'm actually playing a very protown game there just isn't much to do this day which is as expected for RMM.
I am no Awaclus; he is consistently Awaclus and I am consistently PPS. I am well within my town meta.

I love the implication that I'm somehow the most wiredup player on the forums or something.  I think I'm probably on the laid back end when it comes to mafia, but maybe people can correct me about that.  But noone likes being put to L-1 on D1.

My point is that I don't know if your last sentence is true - I'm not sufficiently familiar with your meta to judge.  That fact alone means that I wouldn't be massively opposed to your lynch, which is all I'm saying by including you on a would-lynch list.

If you are town and I am scum why did I not hammer you when you went L-1? You should know I love a hammer. You could argue that you weren't at L-1 long enough but I can assure you I was present for the entirety of that episode.

[Hydrad]

Oh one thing I can do is show you that I've done this read list in other games. Maybe that will help. I'm at work for a while but when I get home I'll try to link some games.

[Witherweaver]

If you are town and I am scum why did I not hammer you when you went L-1? You should know I love a hammer. You could argue that you weren't at L-1 long enough but I can assure you I was present for the entirety of that episode.

"If I was scum why would I do X?" is a very uncompelling argument.  Like, the uncompellingest. 

[pingpongsam]

If you are town and I am scum why did I not hammer you when you went L-1? You should know I love a hammer. You could argue that you weren't at L-1 long enough but I can assure you I was present for the entirety of that episode.

"If I was scum why would I do X?" is a very uncompelling argument.  Like, the uncompellingest.

But the argument being made is about why I didn't do something which is moderately more compelling in my view.

[Witherweaver]

If you are town and I am scum why did I not hammer you when you went L-1? You should know I love a hammer. You could argue that you weren't at L-1 long enough but I can assure you I was present for the entirety of that episode.

"If I was scum why would I do X?" is a very uncompelling argument.  Like, the uncompellingest.

But the argument being made is about why I didn't do something which is moderately more compelling in my view.

Those are equivalent by X <-> not X

[Axxle]

There's plenty of reasons why scum wouldn't want to hammer a wagon like haddocks

[pingpongsam]

There's plenty of reasons why scum wouldn't want to hammer a wagon like haddocks

Not for scum!PPS, there isn't.

[Witherweaver]

There's plenty of reasons why scum wouldn't want to hammer a wagon like haddocks

Not for scum!PPS, there isn't.

But then this provides at least one.

[Roadrunner7671]

Am I the ONLY one who understands PPS?

[2.71828.....]

Am I the ONLY one who understands PPS?

Uh, if you are saying everyone else other than you thinks he is scum check the vote count