Thinking about it more, I actually see what you're getting at yuma I think. You're saying he's trying to replicate his precedent town game and betrays himself by actually being illogical ?
I disagree, because I think there's nothing more scummy than logic, unfortunately.
I think that is the opposite of what I am saying.
I am saying here he is finding iguana scummy for creating a reads list. There, when he was town, he gave RR obv!town points for it. I realized it because of WW's post from RMM28. That is an inconsistency. Inconsistency in and of itself isn't scummy, but trying to push a case based completely off that premise, which I frankly disagree with, is a bit more scummy.
And it isn't that he is being illogical. It is that he is being logical, but still not completely making sense. Do you remember how TA felt about me in GOP? That is how I feel about ss right now. He just feels off. Now, as I mentioned before part of that is that this might be the first time I have been town playing a game with him, but he still just feels different and isn't speaking the sense that I typically expect him to speak.