ok... well imma thinking vote: egorK
Was your trigger "If he makes one more useful post, I swear to God !" ?
@silver : what was scummy about his first post ?
Nope. And I don't consider the post he just posted useful...
My thought was...
"hmmm he started out pretty active but once it was mentioned and some of his posts were questioned he clammed up and disappeared."
As I had that thought I saw that he was online and that he had stated he was going to do a reread of stuff over the weekend, so I thought I would give him a chance to see if he was posting and what he was going to post, hence my post stating I was thinking about moving my vote.
And when he posted it looked like a filler post to keep from being prodded but nothing more than that and so I felt he was continuing his keeping quiet schtick, which isn't unusual for EgorK, I will admit, but I did think that his being active early was. What struck me was how he changed once called out on it. If he had posted more and of more substance then I might have seen that as just him wanting to be more active and the blip in activity that I noticed an aberration. But right now I think he started out 1. as mafia 2. wanting to be more active so he wouldn't be a day1 or day2 lurker lynch 3. got called out for it 4. panicked a bit and went back into lurker mode.
So I am voting him. You should too!