Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[pingpongsam]

vote: Witherweaver

I got a guilty result on him last night. Also he neighbored me N1 and I got a bad feeling about him then because he was very guarded despite me revealing quite a bit of my role including who I targeted N1 for investigation.

Why is being guarded suspicious?

Why not? I felt like he was hiding something. I thought maybe he was just not very trusting although I was putting a lot out there (note he even says he thinks or thought I am town). I thought this made him a reasonable target for investigation. Right now it looks like my gut was right and I made a superb choice for my target.

[pingpongsam]

vote: Witherweaver

I got a guilty result on him last night. Also he neighbored me N1 and I got a bad feeling about him then because he was very guarded despite me revealing quite a bit of my role including who I targeted N1 for investigation.

Why is being guarded suspicious?

While you are on would you like to explain why I got both guilty and not guilty results on you N1?

[pingpongsam]

Also signing off for the night, be interested to see where this went in the AM.

[Jimmmmm]

vote: Witherweaver

I got a guilty result on him last night. Also he neighbored me N1 and I got a bad feeling about him then because he was very guarded despite me revealing quite a bit of my role including who I targeted N1 for investigation.

Why is being guarded suspicious?

Why not? I felt like he was hiding something. I thought maybe he was just not very trusting although I was putting a lot out there (note he even says he thinks or thought I am town). I thought this made him a reasonable target for investigation. Right now it looks like my gut was right and I made a superb choice for my target.

What was he being guarded about? If he's a Neighbouriser, surely you knew his role (regardless of alignment) already?

[Jimmmmm]

vote: Witherweaver

I got a guilty result on him last night. Also he neighbored me N1 and I got a bad feeling about him then because he was very guarded despite me revealing quite a bit of my role including who I targeted N1 for investigation.

Why is being guarded suspicious?

While you are on would you like to explain why I got both guilty and not guilty results on you N1?

Clearly I have two roles.

How can you get two results on one person in any Night, let alone Night 1?

[Witherweaver]

PPS said he could investigate and that he had chosen Jimmm on Night 1.  He was going to indicate (to me) whether it was guilty or not in his first message.  He, apparently, got both results on you, hence his opening post yesterday.

PPS asked me to share more, basically offering his info for mine.  But, I don't have anything to reciprocate with, which is what I told him.  I think he saw it as being guarded. 

[Witherweaver]

I didn't full claim to him.

[XerxesPraelor]

vote: Witherweaver

I got a guilty result on him last night. Also he neighbored me N1 and I got a bad feeling about him then because he was very guarded despite me revealing quite a bit of my role including who I targeted N1 for investigation.

Nice.

vote: witherweaver

[Jimmmmm]

I'm not sure how we can trust any kind of result any more.

[XerxesPraelor]

vote: Witherweaver

I got a guilty result on him last night. Also he neighbored me N1 and I got a bad feeling about him then because he was very guarded despite me revealing quite a bit of my role including who I targeted N1 for investigation.

Why is being guarded suspicious?

While you are on would you like to explain why I got both guilty and not guilty results on you N1?

This is really weird. I think I believe it - scum wouldn't claim something that strange.

[Jimmmmm]

Has pps claimed his role?

[XerxesPraelor]

I don't think so?

[Witherweaver]

I think the most likely case is that there's some role to mess with results. 

[Hydrad]

Hmm I'm guessing its to early for a full claim kinda thing?

This is mainly motivated by curiosity though...

[faust]

Okay. So there are things I need to do.

Egor, I need you to state the exact nature of your result on me.

[faust]

Also looking at PPS's previously shown reading skills, I'm not sure I can trust the weirdness of his claim without him telling us the kind of result he got.

[faust]

I mean, the fact that he felt it necessary to include some read based on the neighborhood thing along with his "guilty" result indicates to me that the result isn't quite as waterproof as "guilty" makes us think.

[Ampharos]

Up to date on the posts, but at a conference today and tomorrow.  We'll be on laptops (yay tech conferences!) so I'll probably check in every so often. 

Some sort of odd shenanigans happened last night with the lack of kill, but I'll take it however it happened. 

I would like to hear from EgorK as well.  Faust is very town for me and I'd like to stamp #confirmed on that if possible, mostly clearing EgorK as well.  I already trust you two but always appreciate a little more knowledge.

[pingpongsam]

Up to date on the posts, but at a conference today and tomorrow.  We'll be on laptops (yay tech conferences!) so I'll probably check in every so often. 

Some sort of odd shenanigans happened last night with the lack of kill, but I'll take it however it happened. 

I would like to hear from EgorK as well.  Faust is very town for me and I'd like to stamp #confirmed on that if possible, mostly clearing EgorK as well.  I already trust you two but always appreciate a little more knowledge.

Seriously? Known town ash got a result on Faust yesterday. Faust is not conftown to me at all. The only issues I am having at the moment are A) results may be faulty and B) it looks like there are quite a bit of scum in the game but night kills are thin.

[pingpongsam]

vote: Witherweaver

I got a guilty result on him last night. Also he neighbored me N1 and I got a bad feeling about him then because he was very guarded despite me revealing quite a bit of my role including who I targeted N1 for investigation.

Why is being guarded suspicious?

While you are on would you like to explain why I got both guilty and not guilty results on you N1?

Clearly I have two roles.

How can you get two results on one person in any Night, let alone Night 1?

 I thought I asked you for the explanation, here... I am telling you on N1 when I investigated you I got a result of Guilty and Not Guilty.

[Roadrunner7671]

vote: Witherweaver

I got a guilty result on him last night. Also he neighbored me N1 and I got a bad feeling about him then because he was very guarded despite me revealing quite a bit of my role including who I targeted N1 for investigation.

Why is being guarded suspicious?

While you are on would you like to explain why I got both guilty and not guilty results on you N1?

Clearly I have two roles.

How can you get two results on one person in any Night, let alone Night 1?

 I thought I asked you for the explanation, here... I am telling you on N1 when I investigated you I got a result of Guilty and Not Guilty.

Cause he's the Survivor.

[faust]

Up to date on the posts, but at a conference today and tomorrow.  We'll be on laptops (yay tech conferences!) so I'll probably check in every so often. 

Some sort of odd shenanigans happened last night with the lack of kill, but I'll take it however it happened. 

I would like to hear from EgorK as well.  Faust is very town for me and I'd like to stamp #confirmed on that if possible, mostly clearing EgorK as well.  I already trust you two but always appreciate a little more knowledge.

Seriously? Known town ash got a result on Faust yesterday. Faust is not conftown to me at all. The only issues I am having at the moment are A) results may be faulty and B) it looks like there are quite a bit of scum in the game but night kills are thin.

You mean the Delayed Ninja Jailkeeper got a result on me? What exactly do you think this result could be? It is clear that ash has been lying. Plus ash stated that I am his top town read before dying.

[yuma]

Vote Count 3.2

witherweaver (3): pps, Hydrad, xerxes

Not Voting: (7) EgorK, Ampharos, faust, WW, Jimmmmm, RR, iguanaiguana

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch

[iguanaiguana]

Does anyone else think they can explain the lack of a nightkill? If no one else can, I may be able to and I would also have a reasonable lynch target for us.

[pingpongsam]

Up to date on the posts, but at a conference today and tomorrow.  We'll be on laptops (yay tech conferences!) so I'll probably check in every so often. 

Some sort of odd shenanigans happened last night with the lack of kill, but I'll take it however it happened. 

I would like to hear from EgorK as well.  Faust is very town for me and I'd like to stamp #confirmed on that if possible, mostly clearing EgorK as well.  I already trust you two but always appreciate a little more knowledge.

Seriously? Known town ash got a result on Faust yesterday. Faust is not conftown to me at all. The only issues I am having at the moment are A) results may be faulty and B) it looks like there are quite a bit of scum in the game but night kills are thin.

You mean the Delayed Ninja Jailkeeper got a result on me? What exactly do you think this result could be? It is clear that ash has been lying. Plus ash stated that I am his top town read before dying.

Yeah good point.