Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[UmbrageOfSnow]

Also, Mail-mi posted on-site (only a couple times but still) while we were lynching Awaclus conveniently without stopping in here to offer any thoughts or reactions.

[UmbrageOfSnow]

@UoS: why do you think scum would have shot you or Teproc?

Because he, WW, and I were driving the Awaclus lynch and Joe was mostly just sheeping.  No offense to Joseph but he seemed to be lightly going along with whatever theories were pushed.  It seemed to be like he was open to being manipulated by scum, and was semi-lurking.

People at the end of the day were also treating me and Teproc as basically universal town reads, and we might have PRs.

But as I think about it, the UB point is an even better one than I at first thought for that exact reason.

[UmbrageOfSnow]

Oh, and my reasoning on not WW was that WW still had a lot of suspicion on him comparatively.

[UmbrageOfSnow]

Personally, barring a good argument, my lynch pool is down to 2 people:

skip wooznum or Joseph2302.

skip wooznum.

You can't lynch a dead IC.

Who's the other one in your lynch pool?

[skip wooznum]

Haven't finished re-read yet but im thinking adk/pacovf atm

[skip wooznum]

Also, I sort of forgot abput this

Is it just me or does this ww/teproc fight seem a tad scum vs. scum?

The only way to know for sure is to lynch one of them.

how do you know we'll know for sure after lynching only one of them?  Do you know neither is scum?

but I think that's a scumslip from adk

[Hydrad]

woo I'm an IC now also! sweet. hmm now to find scum...

[UmbrageOfSnow]

Skip: Care to explain why that's a scumslip?

[A Drowned Kernel]

I'm comfortable removing Teproc and UoS from my lynch pool today. Probably WW as well.

Seprix I don't see as super scummy but I'll have to go back and read him.

chairs and skip and mail-mi are the scummiest. pacovf was also off-wagon, but I remember finding him towny yesterday for some reason, so I'll go re-examine that.

PPE: I also fail to see how that's supposed to be a scumslip.

[skip wooznum]

Skip: Care to explain why that's a scumslip?

well, how does he know we'll find out after lynching one of them? Maybe we'll lynch one and he'll flip scum and we won't know whether or not it's scum v scum. Unless he knows they're both town. How would he know that?

[chairs]

Personally, barring a good argument, my lynch pool is down to 2 people:

skip wooznum or Joseph2302.

skip wooznum.

Okay, PPE everything from after this post, I'll read it after I advise that I am apparently really REALLY sold that Joseph is Mafia every game, I even made this mistake in my personal QT when musing on who I thought should be D2's lynch.

[UmbrageOfSnow]

well, how does he know we'll find out after lynching one of them? Maybe we'll lynch one and he'll flip scum and we won't know whether or not it's scum v scum. Unless he knows they're both town. How would he know that?

Logic aside, why'd you say this

And im leaning town on adk.

as your followup to that at the time?

[chairs]

Well, my lynch pool is down to 1 for D2 since dead ICs can't melt steel beams.

[skip wooznum]

well, how does he know we'll find out after lynching one of them? Maybe we'll lynch one and he'll flip scum and we won't know whether or not it's scum v scum. Unless he knows they're both town. How would he know that?

Logic aside, why'd you say this

And im leaning town on adk.

as your followup to that at the time?

like I said, I forgot almost immediately afterwards

[skip wooznum]

And that's two days later

[UmbrageOfSnow]

like I said, I forgot almost immediately afterwards

So what was causing you to lean town on ADK?

[skip wooznum]

Sorry, one day. But still

[skip wooznum]

like I said, I forgot almost immediately afterwards

So what was causing you to lean town on ADK?

I think the fact that he found me scummy

[chairs]

like I said, I forgot almost immediately afterwards

So what was causing you to lean town on ADK?

I think the fact that he found me scummy

That's because you are scummy m8m8m8.

[UmbrageOfSnow]

Sorry, one day. But still

29 posts.  But still.

[skip wooznum]

well, how does he know we'll find out after lynching one of them? Maybe we'll lynch one and he'll flip scum and we won't know whether or not it's scum v scum. Unless he knows they're both town. How would he know that?

Logic aside,

so, you agree?

[UmbrageOfSnow]

well, how does he know we'll find out after lynching one of them? Maybe we'll lynch one and he'll flip scum and we won't know whether or not it's scum v scum. Unless he knows they're both town. How would he know that?

Logic aside,

so, you agree?

No, I think your logic makes 0 sense.  But I wanted to know your responses to other stuff more than I wanted to argue with you about your logic being bad.

[skip wooznum]

well, how does he know we'll find out after lynching one of them? Maybe we'll lynch one and he'll flip scum and we won't know whether or not it's scum v scum. Unless he knows they're both town. How would he know that?

Logic aside,

so, you agree?

No, I think your logic makes 0 sense.  But I wanted to know your responses to other stuff more than I wanted to argue with you about your logic being bad.

well are we done with the other stuff?

[UmbrageOfSnow]

well are we done with the other stuff?

I mean that's up to you.  I'm willing to vote for you now if that's what you mean.

[pacovf]

Also, Mail-mi posted on-site (only a couple times but still) while we were lynching Awaclus conveniently without stopping in here to offer any thoughts or reactions.

I think this is unfair and should not be used against players. Mafia is not the only reason people might want to check this forum for, and following the developments of a game of Mafia takes longer than pretty much anything else in here. Just because someone has posted elsewhere at the same time is not proof that they also read the game and chose not to say anything.

That being said, the fact remains that he didn't say anything.

I will answer your accusation and post some thought either later tonight or tomorrow. I am in a rush right now.