Dominion > Rules Questions

Disciple (TR, KC, etc) Wine Merchant (other Reserve card)

(1/1)

jamfamsam:
Played last night. Had someone Disciple a Wine Merchant. Does Disciple follow Wine Merchant to the Tavern Mat?

My guess is no, but I wasn't sure since those types of cards stay out with Duration cards.

dane-m:

--- Quote from: jamfamsam on May 02, 2015, 12:35:52 pm ---Played last night. Had someone Disciple a Wine Merchant. Does Disciple follow Wine Merchant to the Tavern Mat?

My guess is no, but I wasn't sure since those types of cards stay out with Duration cards.

--- End quote ---
I'm fairly sure that I've seen this question asked elsewhere (but don't ask me where) and the answer is indeed "no", the point being that the called effect can't get doubled so Disciple is finished with once the Reserve card has been resolved.  I'm also fairly sure that the answer elsewhere explained that much better than I have just done!

dane-m:

--- Quote from: dane-m on May 02, 2015, 12:45:52 pm ---I'm fairly sure that I've seen this question asked elsewhere (but don't ask me where)

--- End quote ---
I asked myself and successfully tracked it down.  The following is what Donald X said in a Boardgamegeek forum:

"Throne Room just repeats the above-the-line stuff. If you Throne Room Ratcatcher, for example, you would get +1 Card +1 Action, put Ratcatcher on the Tavern mat, get +1 Card +1 Action again, and fail to put it on the mat since it's already there. It would have no effect on calling the Ratcatcher later; that still just trashes one card. You can't Throne calling a card."

And not surprisingly Donald did indeed explain it much better than I did!

Navigation

[0] Message Index