Well my point is is that (at least part of) the reason not getting suspicion is generally scummy is because you have scum partners that aren't going to be too enthusiastic about getting you lynched. The dynamics of this game are different, so it's less of a factor here.
He's townie because he's been doing things to move this game along. The case on me came actually helped progress the game, and I think the case on you did as well. On Day 1 it got the game out of theory talk, and the Day 2 one also helped start things happening. It's generally all well and good. Aside from that he's generally been making sense.
Also, he's flipped around on reads, and it's felt somewhat genuine. In particular, scum on me day 1 to town on me day 2, and (town? null?) on you Day 1 to scum on you Day 2. Those things are fakeable, but it's not as easy. Scum has a pretty strong tendency to stay consistent and not change minds a lot. At any rate, it didn't feel faked to me.