Game-based Categories:
Best "Normal" Game: M51: Wool Mafia by yuma
Best "Non-Normal/Non-BM" Game: RMM16: Dice Mafia by Jimmmmm
Best "Bastard/Drunk" Game: BM17: Artist's Mafia by Archetype
Best In-Game Moment: Beyond Awesome and witherweaver claim "Masons" in RMM16
Best claim: Jimmmmm as Goon Cop in M35 (Mafia and the Chocolate Factory)
Player-based Categories:
Best Town Performance in a Single Game: Voltaire in M50 (A Song of Ice and Fire Mafia)
Best Scum Performance in a Single Game: Axxle in M40 (Philosophers Mafia)
Best Townie: witherweaver
Best Scum: TIE: ashersky and witherweaver
Best Newbie Performance: TIE: Awaclus in M39, Azadin in M46, and Delirious Deleuze in M43
Player of the Year: TIE: ashersky and witherweaver
Best Use of a Power Role: Robz888's Role Copping in M43
Mod-based Categories:
Best Original Set-Up: asher9++ by ashersky
Best Original Role: TIE: The Doctor by Voltaire and The Rolestealing Gladiator by yuma
Best Flavor: Dune by ashersky
Mod of the Year: ashersky
Best Mod Performance in a Single Game: ashersky in Dune Mafia