You know I appreciate that you say this, and I appreciate that in the OP you say how it's all your opinion.
But when you cast how much you like a card as how well-designed it is, well it's pretty insulting to me. The epitome of good game design is not maximizing how much fun silverspawn has. It's probably more annoying on the low end, but I don't imagine I will like it on the high end either.
I don't mind people singling out hated/loved cards, and I've chimed in on some of those threads. I don't mind you talking about how well-designed you think things are, and I will try to stay out of such discussions. But pretending one is the other, well, yuck. I mean imagine we all discussed how much we liked you, yikes, but wait, we're going to pretend that what we're talking about is, how smart you are, objectively.
yikes. I think I need to take a step back. I had no idea this thread would bother you, or that you would even care, and it's the last thing I want.
So, if I'm reading this right, you agree that the difference of naming it "design ratings" as supposed to "favorites" is that the former claims to be objective, which is wrong because I'm not being objective. Well, I didn't think this through when I made it. I just thought, I have a lot to say about a lot of cards, so why not make a thread and say all of it, maybe some people will care. It's not bothering anyone else, but we are talking about something you created, so it's understandable that it bothers you. Even though this threads is clearly going to be mostly praise, I mean I'm only through 13 of 206 cards, and I'm barely negative anymore.
But that's not relevant, you got a point. If you want, I will edit the thread name and/or the OP. How about "silverspawn's card list" as the name, and
I will rate all official Kingdom cards by their design.
to
I will rate all official Kingdom cards by how much I like their design.
would that be okay? Or, if there's anything else you want me to change, say it. I mean, I already admitted in the thread that I'm not purely objective, specifically about Masquerade, so that's really the the only thing left to do. And, I'm really sorry if it was insulting, it wasn't on purpose. I'll also say that I used to have my doubts about this thread, but then jsh did his, and I really thought I was doing the exact same thing, only talking about mechanics instead of art.