okay, general reread. I'll do more single person rereads tomorrow or something
sudgy is scummy. I usually don't do quote compilations anymore, but this one is super short
Vote: silverspawn
I agree that his first post seems like it's pushing aside suspicion when there isn't any, and it could be planned in a QT. I usually do RVS but I actually found a legitimate reason to vote someone right away.
sudgy, have you played with silverspawn before ?
Once, but I was NKed N1 so I wasn't there long.
sudgy, have you played with silverspawn before ?
Once, but I was NKed N1 so I wasn't there long.
What do you remember about his play ?
Not much weird.
Teproc, sudgy, XP, do have any thoughts on why scum might have picked me?
(I have stuff to say about the other stuff that's going on, btw, but my strategy as IC here is to hang back at the start)
Not really. I haven't been playing much recently so I don't really know half of the people here well enough to make a good guess.
I don't think scum would care about someone's reads when choosing who gets the gun; we decided we would do majorities and with a four-man scum team, I'm sure they realized that's what we would do.
Actually, I like Axxle2. Vote: Axxle2
Actually, I like Axxle2. Vote: Axxle2
As a lynch, or as a shooter? If you think he has good reads, then just vote for whoever he finds scummy - that way ADK doesn't die for nothing. I could see a case that he's hard to read and so a good target, though. Is that what you mean?
Both, I guess? I'm having a hard time getting into this game for some reason.
I think overdefending is a valid scumtell. I haven't seen e do it too much, I'll have to re-look at things.
Sorry I haven't been able to get into the game as much. Maybe I should do a reads post soon or something.
I could probably go for WW or Eevee. I can see the cases in both of them, but I'm not too excited about it. I don't really see e. If I have time, I will reread and such.
Also, I don't see why you guys say overdefending isn't a scumtell. I myself was caught by it once.
So sudgy had some posts at the start of the game, around 9-11th, and then couple of posts at 15th-16th. His posts strikes me as disinterested. 2 votes - first on silver, then on Axxle. I don't know. Anyone knows his meta?
I have two ways I start games, depending on various real life factors: One, I'm really active and get lynched for it (every time, almost), or two, I don't manage to get into the game that well and it turns into what happened here.
I've been really busy recently, but have been reading. I just haven't found anything that's been big enough for me to post about.
Because, I was at "shoot-1" which seems like it would be big enough to merit a comment.
When they aren't actual votes, it makes it less huge...
Sudgy voting Axxle strikes me as odd..
That was an old vote, I thought of maybe switching to Eevee but I still wasn't too sure.
We should do some reads analysis in relation to Eevee. I would think scum would be perfectly fine bussing with four scum, so I actually think the people who were the strongest on his case are the ones who would be the most scummy. I don't think all scum did so, but I think at least one did.
scummy things
-> first post is a vote. from what I understand, being afraid to commit to votes is scummy. so, throwing around some votes is a pretty good idea as scum, right? of course WIFOM can be applied here, but right now, I'm pretty sure voting without showing fear will make you look towny overall. and his second vote was on the axxle wagon. why? "He'd be good as a gumbearer" is such a lame excuse. sure, that's only 2 votes, it's also only 11 posts. and I'm mostly taking about the lack of reasoning here.
-> no vote on Eevee. coincidence?
-> the last post. I disagree so much with that, I have a hard time believing that town!sudgy says this. at this point, we already have >50% winrate by shooting randomly. In fact, if you think it's true that scum planed to lynch a partner in order to get town credit, I'll be all for shooting randomly.
-> the fact that he's lurking at all
-> he apologizes too much for lurking. I have been about to do that several times, but stopped each time, because I'm self conscious about that suff, and thought it'd look really bad as town. I don't think other players have these kinds of problems. I green'd all the parts where he apologized. well 3 times, but that's a lot considering his post count.
-> I still support a lurker lynch here. that's kind of random+ plan.
okay I guess that was a specific reread, but I really read most things.
XP said Axxle2's playstyle is easy to copy. what? I don't know if there's a style I'd find harder to copy.
XP is blending in. is that normal for him?
WW is
not blending in. I think he's one of the more experienced players, and he's pretty good I think, so I'm much less confident with any reads here. But he's always blending in. I also don't like what he did. If I recall correctly, all self-voters lately have been town, right?..... actually, PPS self voted in GoT mafia. I only remember that now. So, maybe that point is less good.
Still, he seems different. I really remember him as this annoying, but active town player, who is pretty aggressive overall, but does nothing crazy. what is this laughing about? and the self-vote? it seems out of character.
Axxle2 I can't read. No idea if that kind of play is normal for him or not. I just think he looks really good, but he can be good as scum. He's not the worst target, but I rather shoot a lurker.
Hydrad is, as I said, town. I think. That might change though. Not going into reasons here.
Teproc is another hard one. I've never seen teproc as scum, so, not a good judge here. I think he received zero suspicion so far. But he didn't try to blend in, he was tunneling WW pretty hard.
I've also never seen scum!e. man, I need to play more. But he strikes me as very pro town, and he was pushing the Eevee lynch, so definitely not voting for him.
oh, and
I really think scum doesn't want to buzz in this setup, at all, much less than in any other setup. so,
vote count says Teproc, WW, and e are on the wagon before I "hammer". town cred for everyone there.
Author
Topic: M52: Death Note Mafia (Town wins!) (Read 142026 times)