faust: He claims he has a condition in due time he wishes to reveal. My thoughts: tells us this condition or don't tease us. I don't quite see yet what faust is doing here. I think this might be him trying to get others to state what their special abilities are. He seems to be trying to get information out in the open. I find it fishy that he seems to be trying to force town to reveal info this early. He's on my scum radar for sure.
So, you have a scum read on me. Well, be my guest. But what's really fishy here is your argumentation:
1. You accuse me of "trying to get others to state what their special abilities are". Which, first, I have never done, and second, you are doing in the very same post.
2. How do I seem to try to get information out in the open? Can you back this accusation up? I doubt it.
Ultimately, your case boils down to taking a random post of mine and twisting it around until I look scummy, by accusing my of things that are supposedly implied by that post, but in fact aren't, and ignoring everything else I did so far. Now who is scummy?
How is me putting reads on people trying to get special abilities or flavor names out in the open?
Anyway, from reading your posts, I felt like you were tying to be a bit sly trying to get us to reveal info by starting off with the whole I have this interesting role you guys should know about. What happens is that we have one player who says this and then other players start saying, I also have a cool role and let me tell you what it is. Then, we have people saying their roles and mass claiming which is not good for town D1. Now, maybe I'm wrong, but that is what I felt you were trying to cause with your very early post there.
I also did not like when you say that anyone who thinks they should be mislynched should bid on the governor. As mcmc pointed out, it is better to protect a really good power role from getting NK'd rather than protecting a town player who played scummy so as to get mislynched. And, your response is that everyone has a power role. While this is true, not all PRs are created equal. Now, maybe you posted without fully thinking the plan through. But, it is still a bit fishy in my book. I guess I hold your actions to a high standard because I see you as a very good mafia player.
Another thing that strikes me as odd is that from the Dice Mafia game I played with you, you were almost always on the offensive trying to find out who scum is. This game (so far) I feel like you are more on the defensive rather than the offensive. And, I find that strange because I remember just how gung ho you would get in Dice Mafia. Honestly, even though you were annoying at times that game and sometimes went a bit too far with the tunneling, I do feel your actions helped town (except that day WW and I claimed masons and actually were masons).
PPE: 7
Author
Topic: RMM18 - Guilds Mafia (Town Wins!) (Read 203860 times)