Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Teproc]

And yeah, thanks faust for organizing, obviously the flavour was great, sorry for the WW thing, I do think my argments were sound (since they weren't based on him getting the same flavour as me, but on his reaction to that).

PPE : 2

[pacovf]

- I think things would have been more tense if only one House move was allowed.

I think a better condition would have been to allow only one move per house per phase. Only the first PM asking to move counts. Something like that, more dynamic.

What was Lannister's empowered power, by the way?

[Teproc]

Pretty happy we won before I felt the need to reread, that would have been painful.

[faust]

- I think things would have been more tense if only one House move was allowed.

I think a better condition would have been to allow only one move per house per phase. Only the first PM asking to move counts. Something like that, more dynamic.

What was Lannister's empowered power, by the way?

Self-Voyeur.

[pacovf]

Pretty happy we won before I felt the need to reread, that would have been painful.

I did a targeted reread of EgorK and Hydrad during D3 and it was painful already...

[Teproc]

Huh, Robz really thought I was scum apparently ?

[Witherweaver]

Thing was, I really don't see Silverspawn choosing to lynch his partner XP over his partner PPS.  That and I've played quite a few times with town XP pretty much convinced me he was town, or at the very least not Mafia.

[Witherweaver]

Huh, Robz really thought I was scum apparently ?

Yeah.. well, we did Roleblock you the same night Ash was successfully doctored.  That made you look bad.   We only went for the Roleblock to cover an unlikely event, because we figured the Cop/Tracker would cover the likely targets.  You had acted funny when Silverspawn confessed, so there was some reasonable suspicion.

[Witherweaver]

So XP/Danaerys could have been scum?  That role seems a little swingy.

In case it wasn't clear (we didn't actually announce it here I think), only XP could use our House power.  We had to vote for whether or not he was able to use it, but only he had the ability.  If he died, we would have lost the Roleblock/Rolestop.  I'm not sure if the House would be dissolved or not.

[Witherweaver]

We decided to keep that part secret (because scum could kill him to get rid of the PR).

[Teproc]

To be fair, we'll see how you act when someone says you're their scumpartner after they've been lynched. It's a strange feeling.

PPE : I actually thought you claimed that. Well I thought you had to vote for him, I didn't think you'd get to choose if he could use the power.

[Witherweaver]

Sweet, I get the final chapter !

First time to the end of a game?

[Witherweaver]

To be fair, we'll see how you act when someone says you're their scumpartner after they've been lynched. It's a strange feeling.

PPE : I actually thought you claimed that. Well I thought you had to vote for him, I didn't think you'd get to choose if he could use the power.

Hm, maybe we said he automatically becomes Hand if we're the leading house, but I don't think that implies the role thing.

[Teproc]

And the Lannister empowerement wasn't great. Better than Baratheon, but definitely much worse than Stark.

PPE : Nah, it must be the fourth time I think ? I lost at lylo as town in GoT (first game), survived all the way to the end of Chocolate Factory (second game), and then kept dying until Legend of Zelda Mafia where I got it wrong at lylo as town, again.

[Witherweaver]

And the Lannister empowerement wasn't great. Better than Baratheon, but definitely much worse than Stark.

PPE : Nah, it must be the fourth time I think ? I lost at lylo as town in GoT (first game), survived all the way to the end of Chocolate Factory (second game), and then kept dying until Legend of Zelda Mafia where I got it wrong at lylo as town, again.

Oh yeah, Legend of Zelda... that's why we don't let you live until LyLo!

[silverspawn]

I think you did really well in Zelda. Hydrad was super scummy.

[Hydrad]

I think you did really well in Zelda. Hydrad was super scummy.

Not my fault

[pacovf]

...I still don't understand the Azadin kill...

[Witherweaver]

On Day 1 I didn't know XP was town (I was leaning more town than not, but was still a little null).. but I knew I didn't want him lynched because I didn't want to lose the potential Roleblock power (plus whatever empowerment was.. we didn't know what it would be during Day 1).  So I insisted he didn't get lynched without given reasons, and without being that confident in his towniness.

I think it was just pure unluckiness for scum that it ended up XP or PPS. 

[Witherweaver]

It was said town had a lot of PRs many times, but really there were only two town PRs and two scum PRs:

Town Cop
Town Tracker
Scum Jailkeeper
Scum One-Shot Ninja

The House powers could have ended up controlled by Scum or Town, but they all ended up Town controlled.  But I guess Town controlling the House power is more likely since Town outnumber Scum.

[pacovf]

Even if scum had gotten the powers, they had to face accountability issues if they did weird things with them. Plus, town could empty houses.

[Witherweaver]

Even if scum had gotten the powers, they had to face accountability issues if they did weird things with them. Plus, town could empty houses.

Right, but as you saw emptying houses was an issue.  We had to protect against the chance that scum stayed or moved back into a house.. if we have a public plan, scum can exploit it.. if we let people make their own choice, we question their alignment.  You got suspected for testing if Baratheon was really gone.

[faust]

It was said town had a lot of PRs many times, but really there were only two town PRs and two scum PRs:

Town Cop
Town Tracker
Scum Jailkeeper
Scum One-Shot Ninja

The House powers could have ended up controlled by Scum or Town, but they all ended up Town controlled.  But I guess Town controlling the House power is more likely since Town outnumber Scum.

Well, Xerxes had a power role as well.

[Witherweaver]

It was said town had a lot of PRs many times, but really there were only two town PRs and two scum PRs:

Town Cop
Town Tracker
Scum Jailkeeper
Scum One-Shot Ninja

The House powers could have ended up controlled by Scum or Town, but they all ended up Town controlled.  But I guess Town controlling the House power is more likely since Town outnumber Scum.

Well, Xerxes had a power role as well.

But he could have rolled scum, right?  Or that was a guaranteed town role?

[faust]

It was said town had a lot of PRs many times, but really there were only two town PRs and two scum PRs:

Town Cop
Town Tracker
Scum Jailkeeper
Scum One-Shot Ninja

The House powers could have ended up controlled by Scum or Town, but they all ended up Town controlled.  But I guess Town controlling the House power is more likely since Town outnumber Scum.

Well, Xerxes had a power role as well.

But he could have rolled scum, right?  Or that was a guaranteed town role?

If scum got that role, they would not have had a Jailkeeper.