Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Voltaire]

And I'll have you know I thought WW was town in pretty much all of his scum games (I spectated most of them).

He's not obv!scum, but there's no way he gets IC status here.

[Eevee]

Why is lio obvtown but WW is not?

What was the joth wagon? Wasn't everyone on it? Bussing is a given, and lio's playstyle after replacing in screams town!sub based on everything I've seen before.

Everyone but you and Kingzog were on it, but it was me and WW who drove it.

[Eevee]

The lynch was going to be XP without our efforts.

[Voltaire]

Then we do have people like Voltaire and Kingzog who conveniently didn't participate in lynching the godfather. Uh oh.

Unless someone unvotes it doesn't matter, you're going to kill the cop. Congrats! Eevee is one of the scum, everyone else. Remember that.

[Eevee]

This doesn't feel productive. I'm hammering in 5 minutes.

[silverspawn]

Wait, silver used his shot N1 on XP?

yes

This is insanely suspicious though for someone who claims he didn't realize XP was an IC to him until today.

actually no. i didn't realize he was an IC - which by the way is terrible play from me - but he claimed cop. it seemed like the most logical target for scum, and therefore the most logical target to doctor.

[Voltaire]

The lynch was going to be XP without our efforts.

And then you lynched someone I had a town result on. Also I missed the deadline, so, y'know.

Guys, I've had like 10 minutes to think this through since the claims btw.

[Voltaire]

This doesn't feel productive. I'm hammering in 5 minutes.

That's fine. We win either way.

[silverspawn]

Then we do have people like Voltaire and Kingzog who conveniently didn't participate in lynching the godfather. Uh oh.

Unless someone unvotes it doesn't matter, you're going to kill the cop. Congrats! Eevee is one of the scum, everyone else. Remember that.

I will, if he is. But I think it's about 90% that you will flip scum.

and again:

the problem with that theory is, that it only works for a 0T setup (correct me if I'm wrong). that's a chance of 1/128. Do you really claim that this is the case?

you haven't answered that. It's not impossible that I'll unvote if you describe a plausible scenario.

[Witherweaver]

Wait, silver used his shot N1 on XP?

yes

This is insanely suspicious though for someone who claims he didn't realize XP was an IC to him until today.

But XP did claim doctor.

[Voltaire]

Wait, silver used his shot N1 on XP?

yes

This is insanely suspicious though for someone who claims he didn't realize XP was an IC to him until today.

actually no. i didn't realize he was an IC - which by the way is terrible play from me - but he claimed cop. it seemed like the most logical target for scum, and therefore the most logical target to doctor.

I'm the cop...

[silverspawn]

Guys, I've had like 10 minutes to think this through since the claims btw.

in that case I'll

unvote

so you have time to look at the setup

[Witherweaver]

He meant doctor there.

[silverspawn]

I'm the cop...

*doctor. He claimed doctor. It made a lot of sense to doctor the other doctor.

[Voltaire]

and again:

the problem with that theory is, that it only works for a 0T setup (correct me if I'm wrong). that's a chance of 1/128. Do you really claim that this is the case?

you haven't answered that. It's not impossible that I'll unvote if you describe a plausible scenario.

I haven't answered it because I worked today and this is the first time I've been to the thread since the claiming finished! If you want an answer unvote because Eevee is about to kill me.

[Eevee]

Of course I'm not cutting any conversation short, no worries.

[Voltaire]

I'm the cop...

*doctor. He claimed doctor. It made a lot of sense to doctor the other doctor.

Yes, it does, and it also works in a universe where you realize you need to claim 1-shot to confirm him. Which gets less and less plausible the more I think through this game.

[Voltaire]

Is lynching me actually the fastest way to solve this? I'm dying tonight anyway, I can't be allowed to live for WIFOM, can I?

[Witherweaver]

I'm the cop...

*doctor. He claimed doctor. It made a lot of sense to doctor the other doctor.

Yes, it does, and it also works in a universe where you realize you need to claim 1-shot to confirm him. Which gets less and less plausible the more I think through this game.

Yes, but if Silver and XP planned this, I think Silver would have pointed out earlier that XP had to be telling the truth, and not been surprised by it when I pointed it out.

[silverspawn]

Yes, it does, and it also works in a universe where you realize you need to claim 1-shot to confirm him. Which gets less and less plausible the more I think through this game.

again: XP and me are the same alignment. that much is certain. and that means that no situation exists in which it's good play to lynch us today, because if you want to risk it, you can lynch us tomorrow -> in 2 days and still win 100%

and therefore, it's not useful in any way to discuss this possibility. we can discuss it tomorrow - if you don't flip scum.

[Eevee]

Yes, it does, and it also works in a universe where you realize you need to claim 1-shot to confirm him. Which gets less and less plausible the more I think through this game.

again: XP and me are the same alignment. that much is certain. and that means that no situation exists in which it's good play to lynch us today, because if you want to risk it, you can lynch us tomorrow -> in 2 days and still win 100%

and therefore, it's not useful in any way to discuss this possibility. we can discuss it tomorrow - if you don't flip scum.

This.

[Voltaire]

I'm the cop...

*doctor. He claimed doctor. It made a lot of sense to doctor the other doctor.

Yes, it does, and it also works in a universe where you realize you need to claim 1-shot to confirm him. Which gets less and less plausible the more I think through this game.

Yes, but if Silver and XP planned this, I think Silver would have pointed out earlier that XP had to be telling the truth, and not been surprised by it when I pointed it out.

That makes sense.

[silverspawn]

now, go and look at the setup :)

[Voltaire]

Wait.

Who were XP's targets again?

[Voltaire]

now, go and look at the setup :)

This is not the time for cryptography.