So I reread the thread. Hydrad looks towny to me. Tried to make things happen then got a lot of heat for everything he said. Which wasn't really that scummy, IMO.
Axxle looks kind of scummy-ish to me. I don't know if it's how he generally plays, but there's a lot of posts and not much content. Eevee is kind of the same, but it looks so much more like he's trying to get things going.
ADK is between Eevee and Axxle. So slightly scummy-ish-looking.
ashersky usually looks scummy to me. This time he doesn't. But at the same time, he doesn't look a lot like town.
Witherweaver doesn't read either town or scum to me. He had what I thought was a scumslip, but whenever I try to pursue those, it turns out I was wrong.
But you could have said anything and that I was scum and been right.
The rest of you guys, I have too little to go on. Egor stands out a bit as he have done pretty much nothing except aks about the set-up and being linked.
In conclusion I would prefer to lynch Axxle, ADK, Eevee, ashersky or Egor.
Vote: Axxle