Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[faust]

We didn't have to.

You do see that there's no proof to that, right?

Actually, if you didn't have to use pseudonyms, it would have made a lot more sense for you to just post with your real names and NOT talk about your masonry, why didn't you do that?

[Witherweaver]

We didn't have to.

You do see that there's no proof to that, right?

Gobs of evidence available in the Council QT

[Witherweaver]

We didn't have to.

You do see that there's no proof to that, right?

What if tonight they change their psudonyms?

We can't, check what Jimmm said.

[faust]

We didn't have to.

You do see that there's no proof to that, right?

What if tonight they change their psudonyms?

Tonight is likely already too late to confirm anything, should we lynch today (and sadly, also should we no lynch today).

[Witherweaver]

We didn't have to.

You do see that there's no proof to that, right?

Actually, if you didn't have to use pseudonyms, it would have made a lot more sense for you to just post with your real names and NOT talk about your masonry, why didn't you do that?

I couldn't see why it made a lot more sense.

[Witherweaver]

We didn't have to.

You do see that there's no proof to that, right?

What if tonight they change their psudonyms?

Tonight is likely already too late to confirm anything, should we lynch today (and sadly, also should we no lynch today).

Why is this?

[faust]

We didn't have to.

You do see that there's no proof to that, right?

What if tonight they change their psudonyms?

We can't, check what Jimmm said.

What did Jimmmmm say?

[faust]

Why is this?

Reasons I think revealing would be detrimental to town.

[Witherweaver]

We didn't have to.

You do see that there's no proof to that, right?

What if tonight they change their psudonyms?

We can't, check what Jimmm said.

What did Jimmmmm say?

Posting under different names is not allowed unless you have permission from the mod.

[Witherweaver]

Why is this?

Reasons I think revealing would be detrimental to town.

Okay.

[faust]

We didn't have to.

You do see that there's no proof to that, right?

Actually, if you didn't have to use pseudonyms, it would have made a lot more sense for you to just post with your real names and NOT talk about your masonry, why didn't you do that?

I couldn't see why it made a lot more sense.

Because you would look a lot less scummy then.

[faust]

Posting under different names is not allowed unless you have permission from the mod.

But didn't you just claim you do have permission from the mod?

[faust]

Thinking about it, I can just reveal my problem, since scum wants to kill me tonight anyway.

I will be completely VLA starting August 6.

This means I will have to out, which then means I will most likely be modkilled. (Jimmmmm didn't yet respond to my question) So this is why no-lynch is bad: Because I will die, and that will cause problems.

[pingpongsam]

For the purposes of today I believe BA/WW. Faust is town, too. I think arch is likely scum. I think hydrad could be. I think ashersky could be but he is the least likely to be in my mind if those who could be. I still think WW/BA may be getting one over on me but recently I have seen them be far less scummy than they were being. Because of all this I am not opposed to no lynch just to see who comes up dead tomorrow and to see what takes place tonight.

PPE well the dead Faust thing sucks. If he is going to get mod killed isn't lynching him a thing? I mean, I think he is the towniest of them all besides myself but if he has to die...

[Hydrad]

We still have till the 6th. If scum lets him live and he uses his cop ability it should be more then enough for us to win. All we have to do is rush through the game a bit and not wait till the last day to lynch

[Beyond Awesome]

Well, one thing is certain. Scum is within Faust, PPS, and Ash. Sorry Faust for putting you there. But, upon my reread, the Mentalist has visited each of these three people. And, these are the three people without confirmed roles. So, each of these people knew XP was town (I certainly didn't, I found Ichi more townie).

While a lot of people do think Faust is town, he has been pushing a lot of mislynches/tunneling town players. He pushed Ichi hard D1 who was later town. He pushed me hard D2 and then pushed for an e lynch who ended up being town and whom I did vote for. Well, D3 doesn't count. And, now he is tunneling WW and I hard without considering the possibility of anyone else being scum, especially those other two players who were visited by the Mentalist and whose roles cannot be confirmed.

[faust]

I can confirm ash's alignment. And I think he's town based on play.

[Witherweaver]

We didn't have to.

You do see that there's no proof to that, right?

Actually, if you didn't have to use pseudonyms, it would have made a lot more sense for you to just post with your real names and NOT talk about your masonry, why didn't you do that?

I couldn't see why it made a lot more sense.

Because you would look a lot less scummy then.

I don't understand why.  Should we have kept Masonry secret until tomorrow?  What if one of us died?

It's entirely possible I made a mistake.  I'm not so experienced and don't have a handle on all the strategy, and have never even played with masons before.

PPE: 6, boss came in~

[Witherweaver]

Posting under different names is not allowed unless you have permission from the mod.

But didn't you just claim you do have permission from the mod?

We were given permission to use Alice (me) and Bob (BA)

[Witherweaver]

Okay, I guess you don't know that we weren't given permission to use any other names.  Though I'm not sure why that's relevant, or what prompted this particular discussion.

[Hydrad]

Posting under different names is not allowed unless you have permission from the mod.

But didn't you just claim you do have permission from the mod?

Jimm answered this from my question asking if I was able to impersonate Bob.

[Witherweaver]

Maybe we just messesd up, but I don't understand what the best play would be.  Why did we have the option to use pseudonyms if there wasn't a benefit?  Why would it be better to keep Masonry secret?  How would it be any more believable if we came out with it later?  Wouldn't it be less believable?

[faust]

Posting under different names is not allowed unless you have permission from the mod.

But didn't you just claim you do have permission from the mod?

We were given permission to use Alice (me) and Bob (BA)

Then you can change to your real names.

[Witherweaver]

Posting under different names is not allowed unless you have permission from the mod.

But didn't you just claim you do have permission from the mod?

We were given permission to use Alice (me) and Bob (BA)

Then you can change to your real names.

Yes.

[Witherweaver]

Oh.. Duh. That verifies that it isn't obligatory.

Sorry too many things going on.