Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Beyond Awesome]

Did you even read what I posted before?  It said that the other two Neighbors were chosen randomly from everyone else.

But why would you say it that way?  Why were you and BA NOT randomly chosen from all town?  Explain that for me.

That's why I think you scumslipped.

Who says we weren't chosen randomly?

[Witherweaver]

Did you even read what I posted before?  It said that the other two Neighbors were chosen randomly from everyone else.

But why would you say it that way?  Why were you and BA NOT randomly chosen from all town?  Explain that for me.

That's why I think you scumslipped.

We were chosen to be Masons. THEN 2 neighbors were chosen.

[ashersky]

Did you even read what I posted before?  It said that the other two Neighbors were chosen randomly from everyone else.

But why would you say it that way?  Why were you and BA NOT randomly chosen from all town?  Explain that for me.

That's why I think you scumslipped.

Look, here's how it could have happened:

1)  All 4 players are randomly chosen from those alive, mod randomly chooses two of them who are town to mod-confirm alignment to each other; or
2)  2 town players are randomly chosen from those alive and mod-confirmed town to each other, then 2 more players are randomly chosen from those alive.

There are probably variations, but you get the gist.

Your post made it sound like WW/BA were specific, then two players were randomly chosen to join you.

[ashersky]

Did you even read what I posted before?  It said that the other two Neighbors were chosen randomly from everyone else.

But why would you say it that way?  Why were you and BA NOT randomly chosen from all town?  Explain that for me.

That's why I think you scumslipped.

We were chosen to be Masons. THEN 2 neighbors were chosen.

How do you know that?  That wasn't part of your explanation.  You are just making that up.

[ashersky]

Did you even read what I posted before?  It said that the other two Neighbors were chosen randomly from everyone else.

But why would you say it that way?  Why were you and BA NOT randomly chosen from all town?  Explain that for me.

That's why I think you scumslipped.

Who says we weren't chosen randomly?

WW did.

By explicitly saying "the other two" were chosen randomly, he is implicitly saying "the first two" were not chosen randomly.  Otherwise, he would say "we" were chosen randomly or "all" were chosen randomly or "first we and then the other two" were chosen randomly.

[Witherweaver]

Them being random from all other players is relevant as there is no alignment information in the fact that they were selected.

[Witherweaver]

IT IS IN MY QT

[ashersky]

IT IS IN MY QT

Your QT says "hi, you and BA were randomly selected to be masons, then I randomly selected two other players to be nieghbors with you."  (Paraphrased, of course.)

[Beyond Awesome]

IT IS IN MY QT

Your QT says "hi, you and BA were randomly selected to be masons, then I randomly selected two other players to be nieghbors with you."  (Paraphrased, of course.)

Yes.

[Witherweaver]

It says the selection is random from all other players.

We must exist first for "other" to make sense.

[Witherweaver]

It didn't say we were selected randomly, but I assume we were

[ashersky]

It says the selection is random from all other players.

We must exist first for "other" to make sense.

Right.  As scum partners.

[ashersky]

IT IS IN MY QT

Your QT says "hi, you and BA were randomly selected to be masons, then I randomly selected two other players to be nieghbors with you."  (Paraphrased, of course.)

Yes.

It didn't say we were selected randomly, but I assume we were

Which one is lying?

[Hydrad]

IT IS IN MY QT

Your QT says "hi, you and BA were randomly selected to be masons, then I randomly selected two other players to be nieghbors with you."  (Paraphrased, of course.)

Yes.

It didn't say we were selected randomly, but I assume we were

Which one is lying?

I was just about to say that I think you call scumslip way to much. and then this happens and theres a chance there is a scumslip

[Hydrad]

unvote again as this is interesting.

[Beyond Awesome]

IT IS IN MY QT

Your QT says "hi, you and BA were randomly selected to be masons, then I randomly selected two other players to be nieghbors with you."  (Paraphrased, of course.)

Yes.

It didn't say we were selected randomly, but I assume we were

Which one is lying?

Sorry, Ash. I went back and reread my QT. What WW says is correct. I thought it said WW and I were chosen randomly, but it says WW is my fellow mason and our two neighbors were chosen at random. It does not say WW and I were chosen randomly, but I assumed we were.

[liopoil]

Is the council room QT open? Will it be this night? Has this been answered already and I should be reading more carefully?

[Hydrad]

Is the council room QT open? Will it be this night? Has this been answered already and I should be reading more carefully?

council is open for us every night it seems.

[liopoil]

This is ridiculous. Not a scumslip.

Now there are 3 people willing to vote for WW (faust, ash, pps). pps and ash are also possibly the scumteam, interesting.

Well, I'm not willing to vote for WW, and neither is WW or BA. So for this to go through, both hydrad and arch need to be convinced. Please tell me this won't happen, guys.

Arch may be scum though, and I actually think he is more likely to be scum than ash now.

So hydrad, DON'T DO IT

[Hydrad]

This is ridiculous. Not a scumslip.

Now there are 3 people willing to vote for WW (faust, ash, pps). pps and ash are also possibly the scumteam, interesting.

Well, I'm not willing to vote for WW, and neither is WW or BA. So for this to go through, both hydrad and arch need to be convinced. Please tell me this won't happen, guys.

Arch may be scum though, and I actually think he is more likely to be scum than ash now.

So hydrad, DON'T DO IT

Don't worry. I'm one of the ones who really believes WW/BA. Its going to take me a decent amount to swap it today.

[ashersky]

This is ridiculous. Not a scumslip.

Now there are 3 people willing to vote for WW (faust, ash, pps). pps and ash are also possibly the scumteam, interesting.

Well, I'm not willing to vote for WW, and neither is WW or BA. So for this to go through, both hydrad and arch need to be convinced. Please tell me this won't happen, guys.

Arch may be scum though, and I actually think he is more likely to be scum than ash now.

So hydrad, DON'T DO IT

Would you vote for BA?

[ashersky]

The problem is, if one is scum, both are scum, right?  Willing to lynch one has to be willing to lynch the other.

[Archetype]

This is ridiculous. Not a scumslip.

Now there are 3 people willing to vote for WW (faust, ash, pps). pps and ash are also possibly the scumteam, interesting.

Well, I'm not willing to vote for WW, and neither is WW or BA. So for this to go through, both hydrad and arch need to be convinced. Please tell me this won't happen, guys.

Arch may be scum though, and I actually think he is more likely to be scum than ash now.

So hydrad, DON'T DO IT

liopoil, who do you think the scum team is?

[ashersky]

This is ridiculous. Not a scumslip.

Can you explain the inconsistencies?

[liopoil]

This is ridiculous. Not a scumslip.

Now there are 3 people willing to vote for WW (faust, ash, pps). pps and ash are also possibly the scumteam, interesting.

Well, I'm not willing to vote for WW, and neither is WW or BA. So for this to go through, both hydrad and arch need to be convinced. Please tell me this won't happen, guys.

Arch may be scum though, and I actually think he is more likely to be scum than ash now.

So hydrad, DON'T DO IT

liopoil, who do you think the scum team is?

either pps-ashersky or pps-archetype.