Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[faust]

If BA and WW are not scum, I'm ready to eat my hat and never play mafia again.

(Well, not really... I don't even have a hat... but you get what I mean.)

Let's make some real life bets about it.

I like to keep real life and mafia seperate. Better if you don't go around lynching people.

[Witherweaver]

There should be gobs of evidence by now to convince you that your theory is the least likely scenario.   I can't figure out why you keep going to it.

Okay, admittedly I thought BA was scum, so if someone came to me and said "okay him and I are Masons" I'd be a little suspicious.  But with everything that happened with the bonus for killing the monster, us admitting in the QT right away that we were Masons, BA not even understanding what Masons are, by this point it's a crazy conspiracy theory.

If you really were town, well, you brought my suspicion on yourself. I could have been swayed away from that, but not after I saw how you played this day.

How did I bring any suspicion on myself?

[Witherweaver]

If BA and WW are not scum, I'm ready to eat my hat and never play mafia again.

(Well, not really... I don't even have a hat... but you get what I mean.)

Let's make some real life bets about it.

I like to keep real life and mafia seperate. Better if you don't go around lynching people.

[Beyond Awesome]

There should be gobs of evidence by now to convince you that your theory is the least likely scenario.   I can't figure out why you keep going to it.

Okay, admittedly I thought BA was scum, so if someone came to me and said "okay him and I are Masons" I'd be a little suspicious.  But with everything that happened with the bonus for killing the monster, us admitting in the QT right away that we were Masons, BA not even understanding what Masons are, by this point it's a crazy conspiracy theory.

If you really were town, well, you brought my suspicion on yourself. I could have been swayed away from that, but not after I saw how you played this day.
[/quote

What the hell are you talking about?

[Beyond Awesome]

There should be gobs of evidence by now to convince you that your theory is the least likely scenario.   I can't figure out why you keep going to it.

Okay, admittedly I thought BA was scum, so if someone came to me and said "okay him and I are Masons" I'd be a little suspicious.  But with everything that happened with the bonus for killing the monster, us admitting in the QT right away that we were Masons, BA not even understanding what Masons are, by this point it's a crazy conspiracy theory.

If you really were town, well, you brought my suspicion on yourself. I could have been swayed away from that, but not after I saw how you played this day.

I mean

What the hell are you talking about?

[Witherweaver]

Funny how WW and BA are the only 2 players who are completely on the same page with one another.

I think whether they are scum or town they would be on the same page. If they are scum they both want to myslynch. if they are town they are almost 100% sure that the scum is probably asher/pps/lio. their arn't many other options at this point of the game

PPE:3

No, they would know that any of arch, faust, ash, hydrad, lio were not town. But they are in lockstep with proceeding towards what I know to be a mislynch.

The only thing that pair has over any of the rest of us is that they can remove exactly one other person from the pool of potential scum. Yet magically, they both can laser right into an agreed target while everyone else seems to be wholly undecided.

Hydrad I'm treating as very likely town due to his play today and in the QT.  Lio and Arch I'm not as convinced.  However, their roles have been confirmed.  So they are most surely not *both* scum.  Therefore, there is one in {Faust, PPS, Ash}.

[Beyond Awesome]

Who did Faust claim to steal from yesterday?

[faust]

Who did Faust claim to steal from yesterday?

I stole from WW N2 and from PPS N3.

[faust]

There should be gobs of evidence by now to convince you that your theory is the least likely scenario.   I can't figure out why you keep going to it.

Okay, admittedly I thought BA was scum, so if someone came to me and said "okay him and I are Masons" I'd be a little suspicious.  But with everything that happened with the bonus for killing the monster, us admitting in the QT right away that we were Masons, BA not even understanding what Masons are, by this point it's a crazy conspiracy theory.

If you really were town, well, you brought my suspicion on yourself. I could have been swayed away from that, but not after I saw how you played this day.

How did I bring any suspicion on myself?

Go back and reread yourself. You are acting all bossy and hostile towards everyone who dares to oppose you, together with your scum partner BA you are trying to bring this game into your total control, and you're furious that I won't let you do that.

[Witherweaver]

There should be gobs of evidence by now to convince you that your theory is the least likely scenario.   I can't figure out why you keep going to it.

Okay, admittedly I thought BA was scum, so if someone came to me and said "okay him and I are Masons" I'd be a little suspicious.  But with everything that happened with the bonus for killing the monster, us admitting in the QT right away that we were Masons, BA not even understanding what Masons are, by this point it's a crazy conspiracy theory.

If you really were town, well, you brought my suspicion on yourself. I could have been swayed away from that, but not after I saw how you played this day.

How did I bring any suspicion on myself?

Go back and reread yourself. You are acting all bossy and hostile towards everyone who dares to oppose you, together with your scum partner BA you are trying to bring this game into your total control, and you're furious that I won't let you do that.

I've been trying and trying and trying and trying and trying to have actual discussions with you on who is actually scum, but you insist on just sitting and accusing the only two players in the game who I know are town.  So yeah it's frustrating.

[faust]

I did consider other scum pairings.

[faust]

If PPS is scum, and the dice destroyer, how do his D1 actions make sense?

[Beyond Awesome]

If PPS is scum, and the dice destroyer, how do his D1 actions make sense?

Maybe he became permanently loved on N0 and decided to save his ability for N1?

[pingpongsam]

There should be gobs of evidence by now to convince you that your theory is the least likely scenario.   I can't figure out why you keep going to it.

Okay, admittedly I thought BA was scum, so if someone came to me and said "okay him and I are Masons" I'd be a little suspicious.  But with everything that happened with the bonus for killing the monster, us admitting in the QT right away that we were Masons, BA not even understanding what Masons are, by this point it's a crazy conspiracy theory.

If you really were town, well, you brought my suspicion on yourself. I could have been swayed away from that, but not after I saw how you played this day.

How did I bring any suspicion on myself?

Go back and reread yourself. You are acting all bossy and hostile towards everyone who dares to oppose you, together with your scum partner BA you are trying to bring this game into your total control, and you're furious that I won't let you do that.

I've been trying and trying and trying and trying and trying to have actual discussions with you on who is actually scum, but you insist on just sitting and accusing the only two players in the game who I know are town.  So yeah it's frustrating.

The frustrating part is you seem sure who is scum when the reality is, if you are town, you can't be so sure. Additionally, from my vantage point, I know for a fact you are wrong and so it lends a huge cloud of scumminess to your certainty.

[Witherweaver]

There should be gobs of evidence by now to convince you that your theory is the least likely scenario.   I can't figure out why you keep going to it.

Okay, admittedly I thought BA was scum, so if someone came to me and said "okay him and I are Masons" I'd be a little suspicious.  But with everything that happened with the bonus for killing the monster, us admitting in the QT right away that we were Masons, BA not even understanding what Masons are, by this point it's a crazy conspiracy theory.

If you really were town, well, you brought my suspicion on yourself. I could have been swayed away from that, but not after I saw how you played this day.

How did I bring any suspicion on myself?

Go back and reread yourself. You are acting all bossy and hostile towards everyone who dares to oppose you, together with your scum partner BA you are trying to bring this game into your total control, and you're furious that I won't let you do that.

I've been trying and trying and trying and trying and trying to have actual discussions with you on who is actually scum, but you insist on just sitting and accusing the only two players in the game who I know are town.  So yeah it's frustrating.

The frustrating part is you seem sure who is scum when the reality is, if you are town, you can't be so sure. Additionally, from my vantage point, I know for a fact you are wrong and so it lends a huge cloud of scumminess to your certainty.

You're not listening.  I'm not certain. 

[pingpongsam]

If PPS is scum, and the dice destroyer, how do his D1 actions make sense?

Maybe he became permanently loved on N0 and decided to save his ability for N1?

Having not received the Love Doctor I can't say for sure but I suspect you have to use stored dice to buy anything from the guy so I'd like to hear your explanation of how I managed to store dice when I haven't had the opportunity to roll them.

[faust]

If PPS is scum, and the dice destroyer, how do his D1 actions make sense?

Maybe he became permanently loved on N0 and decided to save his ability for N1?

Now you're just making random stuff up.

[pingpongsam]

There should be gobs of evidence by now to convince you that your theory is the least likely scenario.   I can't figure out why you keep going to it.

Okay, admittedly I thought BA was scum, so if someone came to me and said "okay him and I are Masons" I'd be a little suspicious.  But with everything that happened with the bonus for killing the monster, us admitting in the QT right away that we were Masons, BA not even understanding what Masons are, by this point it's a crazy conspiracy theory.

If you really were town, well, you brought my suspicion on yourself. I could have been swayed away from that, but not after I saw how you played this day.

How did I bring any suspicion on myself?

Go back and reread yourself. You are acting all bossy and hostile towards everyone who dares to oppose you, together with your scum partner BA you are trying to bring this game into your total control, and you're furious that I won't let you do that.

I've been trying and trying and trying and trying and trying to have actual discussions with you on who is actually scum, but you insist on just sitting and accusing the only two players in the game who I know are town.  So yeah it's frustrating.

The frustrating part is you seem sure who is scum when the reality is, if you are town, you can't be so sure. Additionally, from my vantage point, I know for a fact you are wrong and so it lends a huge cloud of scumminess to your certainty.

You're not listening.  I'm not certain.

Oh, so who are you willing to vote for besides me?

[Witherweaver]

If PPS is scum, and the dice destroyer, how do his D1 actions make sense?

To make it look like he was targeted by scum to get town cred.

[Witherweaver]

There should be gobs of evidence by now to convince you that your theory is the least likely scenario.   I can't figure out why you keep going to it.

Okay, admittedly I thought BA was scum, so if someone came to me and said "okay him and I are Masons" I'd be a little suspicious.  But with everything that happened with the bonus for killing the monster, us admitting in the QT right away that we were Masons, BA not even understanding what Masons are, by this point it's a crazy conspiracy theory.

If you really were town, well, you brought my suspicion on yourself. I could have been swayed away from that, but not after I saw how you played this day.

How did I bring any suspicion on myself?

Go back and reread yourself. You are acting all bossy and hostile towards everyone who dares to oppose you, together with your scum partner BA you are trying to bring this game into your total control, and you're furious that I won't let you do that.

I've been trying and trying and trying and trying and trying to have actual discussions with you on who is actually scum, but you insist on just sitting and accusing the only two players in the game who I know are town.  So yeah it's frustrating.

The frustrating part is you seem sure who is scum when the reality is, if you are town, you can't be so sure. Additionally, from my vantage point, I know for a fact you are wrong and so it lends a huge cloud of scumminess to your certainty.

You're not listening.  I'm not certain.

Oh, so who are you willing to vote for besides me?

Ash and Faust.

[Beyond Awesome]

If PPS is scum, and the dice destroyer, how do his D1 actions make sense?

Maybe he became permanently loved on N0 and decided to save his ability for N1?

Now you're just making random stuff up.

You asked for a possible explanation, and I offered one.

[pingpongsam]

Sorry, but I can't say there has been a single action I've taken all game that has amounted to town cred.

[Witherweaver]

If PPS is scum, and the dice destroyer, how do his D1 actions make sense?

Maybe he became permanently loved on N0 and decided to save his ability for N1?

Having not received the Love Doctor I can't say for sure but I suspect you have to use stored dice to buy anything from the guy so I'd like to hear your explanation of how I managed to store dice when I haven't had the opportunity to roll them.

You don't store dice, you store a role value.  Love Doctor spends dice from supply or receives dice to supply (as I understand it).

[faust]

If PPS is scum, and the dice destroyer, how do his D1 actions make sense?

To make it look like he was targeted by scum to get town cred.

And claim a fake negative utility role when it was clear that sooner or later, we'd find out? Genius.

[Witherweaver]

Sorry, but I can't say there has been a single action I've taken all game that has amounted to town cred.

Not true, you were basically taken out of consideration Day 1 and have an argument against being scum now (that Faust is presenting).