Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Beyond Awesome]

This is interesting. So, it is kind of like D&D meets Mafia.

[Beyond Awesome]

Hmm...So, I am quite curious about this Loyalty Stone

[mail-mi]

So WW is there anything special about having the loyalty stone?

[Witherweaver]

I thought that Jimmm had written up something about stones in the description somewhere, but now I can't find it.  Did I imagine that?

[liopoil]

So WW is there anything special about having the loyalty stone?

Maybe we shouldn't ask him about it? He already made a post without mentioning anything about it, so I'm not sure he has anything helpful to tell us. Unless it means he's IC of course, which would make sense with loyalty being announced at the start of D1 and all.

[Beyond Awesome]

Play: 12

Vote: BoxofDog I honestly have no clue who this is.

[chairs]

So was there another game like this before?  With the combat mechanic, I mean?  Is there anything that should be gained from that?

There was an RMM game for this that you might review.  One thing to gain from it is that Mafia (I was Mafia that game) have to balance "look Towny" with their rolls, with "don't defeat the monster" (since winning monsters hurt Town/help Mafia).

[liopoil]

I thought that Jimmm had written up something about stones in the description somewhere, but now I can't find it.  Did I imagine that?

I think you did. I ctrl+F'ed "stone" and got nothing.

[Witherweaver]

So was there another game like this before?  With the combat mechanic, I mean?  Is there anything that should be gained from that?

There was an RMM game for this that you might review.  One thing to gain from it is that Mafia (I was Mafia that game) have to balance "look Towny" with their rolls, with "don't defeat the monster" (since winning monsters hurt Town/help Mafia).

Can they lie about their roll?  I think the rules said that isn't allowed.  So in that case would you roll and store multiple rolls and give one that doesn't help too much (but makes it appear like you're trying to)?

[Jimmmmm]

Sorry.

Witherweaver has the Legacy Stone, not the Loyalty Stone.

[Jimmmmm]

Beyond Awesome plays a 12.
Score: 225

[chairs]

So was there another game like this before?  With the combat mechanic, I mean?  Is there anything that should be gained from that?

There was an RMM game for this that you might review.  One thing to gain from it is that Mafia (I was Mafia that game) have to balance "look Towny" with their rolls, with "don't defeat the monster" (since winning monsters hurt Town/help Mafia).

Can they lie about their roll?  I think the rules said that isn't allowed.  So in that case would you roll and store multiple rolls and give one that doesn't help too much (but makes it appear like you're trying to)?

Exactly.  For example, as Mafia I rolled a 5 and a 2 and tried to play off the two as a single-die roll.

I thought that Jimmm had written up something about stones in the description somewhere, but now I can't find it.  Did I imagine that?

I think you did. I ctrl+F'ed "stone" and got nothing.

Check your role PMs, everybody.  Mine mentions Legacy and Loyalty stones...

[Witherweaver]

No those sound way too familiar... there was something about Legacy Stone and Loyalty Stone before.  Maybe some mechanics were changed and Jimmm removed it?


PPE: Oh, it's in my PM, duh.

[mail-mi]

So was there another game like this before?  With the combat mechanic, I mean?  Is there anything that should be gained from that?

There was an RMM game for this that you might review.  One thing to gain from it is that Mafia (I was Mafia that game) have to balance "look Towny" with their rolls, with "don't defeat the monster" (since winning monsters hurt Town/help Mafia).

Can they lie about their roll?  I think the rules said that isn't allowed.  So in that case would you roll and store multiple rolls and give one that doesn't help too much (but makes it appear like you're trying to)?

Exactly.  For example, as Mafia I rolled a 5 and a 2 and tried to play off the two as a single-die roll.

I thought that Jimmm had written up something about stones in the description somewhere, but now I can't find it.  Did I imagine that?

I think you did. I ctrl+F'ed "stone" and got nothing.

Check your role PMs, everybody.  Mine mentions Legacy and Loyalty stones...

Yeah, so did mine.

[liopoil]

So was there another game like this before?  With the combat mechanic, I mean?  Is there anything that should be gained from that?

There was an RMM game for this that you might review.  One thing to gain from it is that Mafia (I was Mafia that game) have to balance "look Towny" with their rolls, with "don't defeat the monster" (since winning monsters hurt Town/help Mafia).

Can they lie about their roll?  I think the rules said that isn't allowed.  So in that case would you roll and store multiple rolls and give one that doesn't help too much (but makes it appear like you're trying to)?

Exactly.  For example, as Mafia I rolled a 5 and a 2 and tried to play off the two as a single-die roll.

I thought that Jimmm had written up something about stones in the description somewhere, but now I can't find it.  Did I imagine that?

I think you did. I ctrl+F'ed "stone" and got nothing.

Check your role PMs, everybody.  Mine mentions Legacy and Loyalty stones...

Yeah, so did mine.

uhh, chairs, IIRC, you played a one

what? I'm expected to read the flavor?!? but Jimmmmm said the flavor is meaningless!

[Witherweaver]

Okay so, I think I can just admit this.  My QT says that I hold the Legacy Stone and it has no effect on the game. 

The thing in the PM is all italic, so all flavor, so it shouldn't matter.  I'm guessing the Legacy Stone is just flavor.

The only thing that makes me wonder is that the actual announcement that I have the stone in the first message of the game starting was in regular bold text.

[Beyond Awesome]

Okay so, I think I can just admit this.  My QT says that I hold the Legacy Stone and it has no effect on the game. 

The thing in the PM is all italic, so all flavor, so it shouldn't matter.  I'm guessing the Legacy Stone is just flavor.

The only thing that makes me wonder is that the actual announcement that I have the stone in the first message of the game starting was in regular bold text.

Maybe it does something later on, or grant its holder special abilities later on. I have no clue though.

[liopoil]

Based on the flavor text, the legacy stone gives us our flips, and the loyalty stone finds us some scums. Neither actually matter in terms of playing the game though.

[chairs]

So was there another game like this before?  With the combat mechanic, I mean?  Is there anything that should be gained from that?

There was an RMM game for this that you might review.  One thing to gain from it is that Mafia (I was Mafia that game) have to balance "look Towny" with their rolls, with "don't defeat the monster" (since winning monsters hurt Town/help Mafia).

Can they lie about their roll?  I think the rules said that isn't allowed.  So in that case would you roll and store multiple rolls and give one that doesn't help too much (but makes it appear like you're trying to)?

Exactly.  For example, as Mafia I rolled a 5 and a 2 and tried to play off the two as a single-die roll.

I thought that Jimmm had written up something about stones in the description somewhere, but now I can't find it.  Did I imagine that?

I think you did. I ctrl+F'ed "stone" and got nothing.

Check your role PMs, everybody.  Mine mentions Legacy and Loyalty stones...

Yeah, so did mine.

uhh, chairs, IIRC, you played a one

what? I'm expected to read the flavor?!? but Jimmmmm said the flavor is meaningless!

One, two, the point was that it was a bad roll that I was trying to play off as bad luck.

[liopoil]

Play: 8

[Jimmmmm]

liopoil plays an 8.
Score: 289

[Ichimaru Gin]

play: 6

[Jimmmmm]

Ichimaru Gin plays a 6.
Score: 325

[yuma]

Sorry guys. I haven't read the rules. I will catch up once I get to my destination and will put forward a role soon. I kinda get the mechanics cause I spectated the first game but don't want to do anything stupid by trying to do something before I do understand it.

[Witherweaver]

Are we supposed to get the results of the roll in the QT?  Like we <b>Roll:</b> and Jimm does it and tells us the result?