A kinda note taking post for me to get caught up. I'll try to do a tl;dr at the end or put stuff in bold that is essential for others to read, the rest you can read if you want but will mostly be thought process stuff...
still think claiming has potential to help us, but I'll concede to the majority and let it wait for a day or two... not sure why suggesting claiming is scummy
not interested in a mail-mi lynch but don't think he is town either. Agree with liopoil that at worst we can try to make sure that he uses his power in a pro-town way (which still doesn't mean he is town) on a later day when we are more comfortable with him full-claiming... or letting mafia decide to potentially take him out for us if he is town.
I see BA getting heat for not having his dice rerolled. I see that logic, but dismiss it as too one dimensional in a game that has many dimensions. If he is doing other stuff, then maybe he could be a lynch... I think he had a summary post at one point that I found scummy, but can't remember if that was him or not.
I still think low rollers shouldn't be punished for rolling low... this is part of the reason I Think a mass claim would help. Have people say how many dice started with, how many dice rolled, list all numbers rolled and saved, etc, etc and eliminate this aspect of questioning roles cause I think just about everyone is going to play high for fear of being lynched for playing low. If anything people will play a 9 or 10 and save a 12/11 if they get lucky to have two high roles. So not suspicious of volt or ichi for that.
That said ichi and volt have responded pretty aggressively. Id on't think aggression is suspicious, especially in the face of unwarranted, or perceived unwarranted, suspicion. I think I am most suspicious of the people who pressed them the most.
Something happened with xerxes and faust? They probably don't want to say exactly what but can you two confirm that it was the two of you and not other players or another game I am thinking of? Probably don't want to lynch either of these two then.
I am always willing to lynch Box. 10 flurried posts do not make up for missing the start of the game and being absent sense. PPS could be a decent lynch I think. Liopoil also responded aggressively--again not scummy--but was... well less crazed I think and more calm and controlled (and thus scummier to me), but I think I have made this argument improperly about liopoil in the past... Toy story was it? Liopoil might remember better than me.
Ash has been strangly a non-factor for me. Ash? you there? I know you want to lynch mail-mi but don't remember much else.
Hydra gettinga day1 newbie pass.
who else... probably willing to lynch anyone else that I can't remember here: WW, (ash, I just remember cause I know when I am playing with ash) and chairs and PPS! voting for him...
Chairs could be a good lynch, can't remember much.
tl;dr...
Won't lynch hydra, mail-mi, faust/xerxes (pending confirmation that something happened between the two of them)
nullish: ichi, voltaire
willing to lynch: ash, box
probably won't to lynch: pps, liopoil or chairs.
Author
Topic: RMM16: Dice Mafia (Town wins!) (Read 545954 times)