Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Voltaire]

I think this game has been relatively stagnant, and my only real hope is that a reduction in the player-count and some concrete information will help move the game along.

Yeah, this to me is just big game D1 syndrome.

There are tons of people I would lynch at this point.

[Robz888]

vote: voltaire

^^I was expecting that. I do have a big townread on yuma, for what it's worth.

You were expecting him to return to me, you mean?

No, I was expecting him to unvote me after thinking about it

[ashersky]

Ok... but really we have gotten off topic.

To reiterate... I think teproc is scummy because:

1. he attempted to use a "policy vote" (yes I am going to continue calling it that despite our conversation about it... which I don't think anyone wants to get into again) against me and then sought out ways to later justify it
2. has gone out of his way to defend voltaire in a situation where I don't think he should have had such a strong townread on him
3. accusing me of OMGUS and attempting to discredit him when I believe that was apparently not the case.
4. has used a "meta" to justify this--really that I one thing that keeps me coming back to Teproc. Everything he has done this game has been based off meta-reads. Policy voting, townread on Voltaire, not liking claiming. Nothing seems new or original to this game. It is like he is sticking to what he is and not deviating from it in an attempt to seem authentic where I think true authenticity goes with the ebbs and flow and can deviate as the shape of the game adapts...

I think Voltaire is scummy because:
1. of the way he "well egged I guess I can't use" but flamed (is that ok) the fire of suspicion on me during my exchange with Teproc, again on something that was solely meta based--but this time certainly not true... my supposed tendency to only be frustrated as scum.
2. his sheeping and defending of teproc, again at a very early stage where I think it perhaps a bit unlikely that such a strong townread could be formed
3. also I found the quick to state ash as town, then backing off that as time went by to be a bit scummy
4. the fake irony thing joth pointed out


Add in that I feel that my argument with Teproc felt similar--if the content wasn't exactly the same--as my argument with Robz in Diffusion of Power--in regard to how everyone else responded to it... basically "meh, yuma is arguing again"

This is the post you wanted me to comment on?

I think you sound an awful lot like town!ash here.

[ashersky]

Vote Count[/color]

XerxesPraelor (1): sudgy
A Drowned Kernel (6): Teproc, AndrewisFTTW, Voltaire, scott_pilgrim, joth, Axxle
Voltaire (2): A Drowned Kernel, yuma
scott_pilgrim (5): mail-mi, ashersky, theorel, XerxesPraelor, mcmc
mail-mi (1): Robz888

Not voting (0)

With 15 alive, it takes 8 to lynch

Day 1 ends at 10:00 a.m. on April 8, 2014

We're at under 12 hours to go, and here's the latest.  ADK at L-2, SP at L-3.

[Voltaire]

Less than 12 hours to go? I may not be around at deadline, um, I'd move my vote but it appears to be doing a good job where it is right now.

[ashersky]

vote: Teproc

Anyone?  I actually think he comes out scummiest from the yuma vs. Voltaire stuff.  Voltaire egging on is more town!Voltaire misreading the situation than anything else (I mean that non-offensively).

[Robz888]

Not a single person commented on my vote for mail-mi, except mail-mi.

[Robz888]

Everyone should desert the Scotty and ADK wagons and rush lynch mail-mi.

[ashersky]

Not a single person commented on my vote for mail-mi, except mail-mi.

There really wasn't much to say.  Dude lurks.  He strikes me as a "overactive as scum because he's pumped" type.  If he's town, we get nothing of substance from the lynch info-wise, or wagon-wise.  I'm not a big fan.

[AndrewisFTTW]

I'm set on an ADK lynch, especially since there are a lot of people not posting and thus it'd be tough to get a wagon on anybody else.

[Voltaire]

Not a single person commented on my vote for mail-mi, except mail-mi.

There really wasn't much to say.  Dude lurks.  He strikes me as a "overactive as scum because he's pumped" type.  If he's town, we get nothing of substance from the lynch info-wise, or wagon-wise.  I'm not a big fan.

This.

[ashersky]

ADK is lynchable, sure.  I've got a fairly null read on the dude.  SP is scummier from the two big wagons.

[AndrewisFTTW]

Why do you think he's scummier? He's more active and so he has more posts for people to point to as scummy but I don't see his self vote thing as scummy. That's just me though.

[Voltaire]

Why do you think he's scummier? He's more active and so he has more posts for people to point to as scummy but I don't see his self vote thing as scummy. That's just me though.

Not just you.

[ashersky]

Why do you think he's scummier? He's more active and so he has more posts for people to point to as scummy but I don't see his self vote thing as scummy. That's just me though.

His posts have felt forced/contrived to me.  It's more gut than anything else, though.  ADK has literally done nothing of substance that I can recall.  If you can point me in that direction, that'd help.

All that said, I prefer lynching Teproc.

[A Drowned Kernel]

I haven't been posting recently because of VLA, and I wasn't posting much before that because this is a game with a ton of people and not much content, so I'm having a hard time reading people. What's happened so far? Yuma and teproc got in a fight, and then "lynch lurkers" wagons formed on me and Scott? Exciting stuff.

I don't like the scott lynch because he feels like his normal self. I don't like the ADK lynch for obvious reasons. I still like my vote for Voltaire. If I had to pick someone from yuma/teproc I would probably pick teproc but that would require a reread of their fight, which I don't remember all that well at this point.

Robz's "rush lynch a semi-random person" gives me a slight town read on him, he did on day one in Adventure Time too.

[Robz888]

A mail-mi lynch is strictly superior to an ADK or Scotty lynch. We've already wagoned ADK and Scotty and the way that went it looks like they are town. Therefore, it's better to lynch any other lurker.

Mail-mi is a lurker.

Therefore, we should lynch mail-mi.

[jotheonah]

the way that went it looks like they are town.

explain plz

[sudgy]

A mail-mi lynch is strictly superior to an ADK or Scotty lynch. We've already wagoned ADK and Scotty and the way that went it looks like they are town. Therefore, it's better to lynch any other lurker.

Mail-mi is a lurker.

Therefore, we should lynch mail-mi.

Hey, I'm a lurker too! 


Anyway, I, uh, got...distracted, and probably don't have enough time to do all rereads.  I'll reread scott and ADK and maybe others if I see the need to.

After every big game, I think, "I'm never joining a big game again."

Then I do...

[AndrewisFTTW]

^suriously.

I'd like to hear proper defenses from ADK and Scott but st the end of the day my ADK vote is more a gut feeling than anything else, so I guess I can be flexible in order to get a lynch through.

[A Drowned Kernel]

^suriously.

I'd like to hear proper defenses from ADK and Scott but st the end of the day my ADK vote is more a gut feeling than anything else, so I guess I can be flexible in order to get a lynch through.

I haven't been posting recently because of VLA, and I wasn't posting much before that because this is a game with a ton of people and not much content, so I'm having a hard time reading people. What's happened so far? Yuma and teproc got in a fight, and then "lynch lurkers" wagons formed on me and Scott? Exciting stuff.

[Axxle]

Vote: scott pilgrim

I was a bit hesitant because of the mcmc vote, but he seemed kinda townie when he explained it. (basically just all over the place, I think scum would have been more collected)

[sudgy]

I don't see anything against ADK or scott other than lurking.  Is that really what it is?

(man, this is a horrible D1)

[AndrewisFTTW]

ADK, that's your defense? It doesn't look like a defense.

[Axxle]

I would NOT vote Teproc/Voltaire today.

I would settle on a mail-mi lynch, but meh.

I would settle on a ADK lynch.

I'd much prefer a scott lynch.

No one else is worth mentioning at this point.