Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[math]

https://dominion-game-logs.s3.amazonaws.com/game_logs/20160505/log.0.1462488154771.txt

I played a game today with Inheritance and Hunting party.  I inherited Ironmonger, and later I played Hunting Party with an Ironmonger in hand, and it skipped over an Estate.  I think this might be a bug, but I wanted to check and make sure first.  Is Estate considered to be a duplicate of the Inherited card?  I would assume not, because it's still called Estate.

[clb]

You are correct - it gains the Types and abilities of the other card, but it doesn't lose its original Type and name. Further, it does not gain the Name of the Inherited card, so it would be a uniquely named card, still.

[Infthitbox]

I was about to say that this happened today to me as well, then I clicked the log...

[werothegreat]

Go yell at MF

I should make a meme to just copy-paste

Posting bugs here doesn't do anything

[Davio]

Yep, Inheritance adds extra types and abilities, not names.
An Estate is still an Estate, not an actual Ironmonger.

I wonder if this bug also occurs on things like HoP, Menagerie, etc, basically anything that's interested in a card's name.
Maybe Wishing Well/Mystic also, hmm. Harvest also comes to mind.

Can anyone test?

[aladdinstardust]

It's also worth noting that Inheritance doesn't copy price. So if you manage to get Peddler down to $4 or less, Inherit it, then trash your Estate/Peddler to Bishop, you'll only get 1 VP; trash to Apprentice, you'll draw two cards; trash to Salvager, you'll get $2; etc.

[drsteelhammer]

Yep, Inheritance adds extra types and abilities, not names.
An Estate is still an Estate, not an actual Ironmonger.

I wonder if this bug also occurs on things like HoP, Menagerie, etc, basically anything that's interested in a card's name.
Maybe Wishing Well/Mystic also, hmm. Harvest also comes to mind.

Can anyone test?

I did: HoP works fine, so does Mystic and Pilgrimage (can gain both inherited card and an estate)

Menagerie does not work, though. Probably same problem as HP. I didn't test Harvest, but it is probably the same.

[Chris is me]

Go yell at MF

I should make a meme to just copy-paste

Posting bugs here doesn't do anything

It does verify that they are actually bugs and not just weird rules quirks, which I'm less confident would happen on MF. So that's something.