To be fair, survivor will pretty much always side with mafia if we mislynch today
No. That depends on the survivor. Some survivors don't just have winning as a goal, but would rather win with town.So has everyone reached the "lynch outside the hood" scenario?
No no no. We lynch DatSwan or ash
Are you high? Even if you want to lynch inside the hood there is wayyyyyy more of a skum narrative for EFHW than either Ash or myself
I did read it, and I thought not mentioning what the second person (ash) thought of joth meant it was joth.
I don't think the neighbors a good pick (although the fact they are neighbors is helpful in a reread).
Are you a VT?
MiX seems towny today, mostly due to SS. That's...so strange.
I was scumreading from D1 into N1.
Maybe it's the overt sheeping/lack of self-confidence in the MiX posts recently?
I need to get a Glooble case ASAP.
You misread. The second paragraph was all hypothetical and counter-factual.
The benefit for town is that given the scummy vibes I got, I think the neighborhood could be a good place to look for scum.
The sooner you out them, the faster we can start considering them.
Joth's one of them, and I suspect the other's pubby? Maaaaaybe ss/pps. So if I can figure this out surely scum can, I don't see why you would scumread them and not out them.
I'm not saying names yet because I want to hear from town about whether they think scum was there.
I had a really great theory that didn't pan out. I thought if there was a survivor in the neighborhood they could claim and if there was scum, too, they would claim. The two of them would vig me and then survivor would ally with mafia.
One thing I've noticed this town in particular loves doing is saying "I think this person is scum" and then not laying down any kind of a case to back that up. We had pubby and joth, Eddie and e, and now MiX and me.
Wait, who do you think is scum?
Tracker reporter seemed like the obvious choice to me, just because power roles tend to die before the game ends anyway.
But then I realized you still would have to survive a lot of lynches and a lot of nightkills, which can be a tricky balance (if you're towny enough not to get lynched, you're towny enough for scum to kill you.) So probably better to take neighbor survivor, where at least you have a buffer against half of the equation.
Anyway, what exactly is the point of this line of questioning?
Is it bothering you?
ugh @flips
so, is there any reason why we shouldn't have a neighborhood claim?
Any reason we should?
um... yeah. if there's just one neighbor, they're an IC. if there's just two neighbors and one of them flips scum, the other is an IC. etc. We get a set of players with at most one scum in it. That's big.
I think I asked Glooble about joth, but what does joth think about Glooble this game?
I think he's towny. Or I did until the post he just made.
Eddy is a weird kill choice, given his role in the debatepro lynch. I would have kept him around as a good mislynch. Did he have any strong scumreads? We should look closely at them...
I think we should take a serious look at joth tomorrow
