Dominion Strategy Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - Galzria

Filter to certain boards:

Pages: 1 ... 554 555 [556] 557 558 ... 643
13876
Robz, is it possible your "character" is just holding a grudge against Joth for what happened 3 years ago? I mean, he obviously went to prison for it, but that doesn't mean you've forgiven him. He obviously recognized you as well... I don't really think he's scum. I think you're either reading too much into your PM, or your PM is misleading you based on past events.

13877
Frisk, Galz must vote same as Volt. Sigh.
Why are you wagoning so easily and fast?

Need to eat, will comment on other raised issues when my tummy stops hurting.  :'(

Why not wagon on scum?

13878
Signing up to replace.  ;D
Of course you are.

After preview #3, that was absolutely the most awesome thing I've read this morning. :P

13879
Obvscum.

13880
Vote: Glooble

13881
Mafia Game Threads / Re: Mafia IX Signups
« on: August 08, 2012, 12:42:13 am »
Are you saying I won't get something good, or that I won't like it? I think we've done that one too already.

i have no idea what role you'll get :)

out of curiosity, what type of role do you like best?

Only role I've ever had was WOSV, so I dunno. This game sounds like it'll have lots of good stuff in it, so my hopes are high for my first non-bastard role. :)

13882
Happy birthday guy who invents stuff from soap bars!

lolololol

13883
Mafia Game Threads / Re: Mafia IX Signups
« on: August 08, 2012, 12:37:47 am »
yknow, tonight would be a particularly convenient night for this game to hit 16 /ins for me!

Me too. I hope I get something and that I like it.

sorry, that only happens in bastard mod games

Are you saying I won't get something good, or that I won't like it? I think we've done that one too already.

13884
Surely metagame scum play is nearly as good a policy lynch as lynch all liars

Is it though? He had the same odds as everyone else at gamestart to roll scum, so a policy lynch is exactly equal to the odds of a random lynch - which is shooting ourselves in the foot of the one thing that town can use to outweigh the advantages Mafia have: information.

That said, our f.DS D1 lynches have been woefully below average...

13885
Mafia Game Threads / Re: Mafia IX Signups
« on: August 08, 2012, 12:31:28 am »
yknow, tonight would be a particularly convenient night for this game to hit 16 /ins for me!

Me too. I hope I get something and that I like it.

13886
Also, apologies for the bad spelling, using accept in place of except, etc. It's my birthday just now, by the way! :)

So it is! Happy birthday first-scum-win buddy!

13887
Well, I DID try to warn y'all about how Pops plays. ;D I'm not suggesting you cut him some slack, but I also know that pressuring him won't get you anywhere. He played a lot on Mafia scum and he's used to their conventions. Unfortunately, those conventions appear like random, baseless accusations here.

The problem is that it intentionally forms a style of meta-game that ultimately is designed to hide scum play. That's not to say he IS scum, but that he will play the same way each time so that when he DOES roll scum there's no discernible difference and a precedence has been set for this style equating to town.

I think in the end it's anti-town play because what he's really playing for is to benefit his next scum role (be it in this game or a future one). Whether that merits a lynch is an entirely different question...

For my money it's a good deadline compromise, but not in and of itself a scum tell... So unless he does something scummy outside his meta-game, it's hard for me to pin him as scum.

13888
Thank you, Galz. Really.

I wish I could say the same about you.

No hard feelings mate. I understand the reasons to lynch me.

13889
Well, not much I can say. I think we should kill ftl one way or the other, but then my lynch will still leave two mafia running amok. For what it's worth, I don't think Joth is scum, I think Robz is wrong or misleading... I just don't know why. He COULD be scum, but that doesn't really make sense since he's signing his death warrant if Joth flips town... So I dunno. But Joth is, I believe, sincere.

13890
This is role madness, not bastard.  eHalc is town.  Galz just seems like he's trolling, so what bothers me more are the other people who are half listening to Galz, like Eevee.
Well, in a normal game I think an innocent child is 99.9% to be town. Here, with morgrim modding, this being a role madness (would be a mad role, wouldnt it?) and with it being announced in the start of the game rather than when eHalc chooses, I'd drop that probability down to 90%. So yeah, eHalc is easily the towniest of you bunch but I'm willing to accept the possibility of Morg playing a prank on us. I do not think it's likely at all though.

Actually, Morgrim is the only person who's done it right. IC is confirmed at game start, not at the request of the player. We're been using a variation.

13891
.... Yeah...

Tim, you should vote for me. It's the only fair way I can think to deal with this lunacy.

13892
Phone posting now. Galz floated the disguise theory to me too - also pushing suspicion on Jonah and Grujah.

I think that robz should shoot galz.  If he flips town - then lynch me and then rage quit the game when you see my role. If he flips scum, then lynch FTl again and be proud

Galz. Why didn't you give me bulletproof?  I mean - I was kinsof out in the open and the mod all but confirmed that FTl is scum scum scum.

A) If ftl were indeed a Mafiosi, it seemed to me that you would be their primary target that night. The wording in my PM made me wary that I could fail, and you didn't seem as safe a target as Sharkie.

B) Yes, you had apparently tracked one scummy, but ultimately a cop was more valuable, as your role could lead to confusing results (like now).

C) What oh what is with this terrible epidemic sweeping f.DS Mafia that has people saying "kill him, and if he flips town then kill me"? If you're town, play to your wincon. This is a really frustrating thing to see... Especially because in this instance I believe CF to indeed be town as well. If I die, you absolutely should not kill Frisk... And he bloody well better not lie down and let you!

D) If I'm a scummy liar, I'm one who has played to a town wincon: Not voting Yuma, and voting ftl (early on too - not some lame late-bus attempt).... - Yeah, I don't expect my voting history to convince you, but I hope you'll consider it when debating the merits of my lynch.

E) Vote: ftl (again)

13893
Apparently there is something more going on between Eevee and Galz that needs addressing before we resolve CF's claim about Galz, so I will wait for that before weighing in.

Robz, I echo jo's inquiry about your Base Set hint.

Okay, well, yeah. I definitely won't shoot Jo. He gave me the gun and nobody contradicted him. I repeat, are there any other Base people still around?

You, Joth, and Insomniac I believe.

I am Prosperity, not Base.

Sorry, my mistake. Just Insomniac and Joth then.

13894
Apparently there is something more going on between Eevee and Galz that needs addressing before we resolve CF's claim about Galz, so I will wait for that before weighing in.

Robz, I echo jo's inquiry about your Base Set hint.

Okay, well, yeah. I definitely won't shoot Jo. He gave me the gun and nobody contradicted him. I repeat, are there any other Base people still around?

You, Joth, and Insomniac I believe.

13895
You gave sharky bulletproof but he was already dead? either that part of your role was useless or your lying.

I TRIED to, but the killers got there first.

13896
Fascinating. Just got back from lunch (CF, I was only following QT's on my phone at the time of posting there). Seems I must come clean fully. Well, this isn't terrible for the town if you end up lynching me. I'm just Vanilla at this point. Here's my role PM and the results of ladt nights misadventures:

You are the Farming Village (Vanilla Town) - Town Aligned      
You are in Seat 12      

      
You had been trying for years to get Ozle to pay for the insurance after he killed your son and left you with the bill (in Ozle’s defence, it was an accident, anybody could have been passing that window when he jumped out to escape a returning Husband….). With the invitation to the party, you had the perfect opportunity to pressure him in a public seeing.
      
However, before you had the chance to bring the issue up, somebody went and murdered him! Ohh boy were you mad! Now you would never get to live like a king... I mean get what was owed you!      

Due to the nature of the party, you do not know who the other people at the table are.
      
You came here on a coach with some others from the village, and are smooth enough to convince them that they should spill all their secrets, maybe giving you some leverage.   
You can talk to them here: Redacted
      
But you’re a cunning one, you have been subtly buttering up both the people either side of you, so you can talk to them here:      
Seats 11 and 12: Redacted
Seats 12 and 13: Redacted
      
One more thing, you also had a bit of a groupie, he saw how popular you were and was hanging around you for ages. Perhaps he could be useful!      
The hanger on: Redacted
      
You were pretty sure that nobody to either side of you moved when the lights went out. You were talking to seat 11, and you could smell 13’s breath!   

Oh, and one last thing. You liked to consider yourself something of a smooth talker. Maybe if you could get a confession out of one of the people interested in you, you could pass along a warning! Well, that was the hope anyway...

Abilities   
Your own cunning tongue.
Once during the game you may attempt to warn another player, giving them 1-shot bulletproof.

Victory Conditions
Redacted.   


PLEASE CONFIRM RECEIPT OF THIS PM IN THE SIGN UP THREAD

And so last night I tried to warn Sharky. Eevee's case made sense to me, and I figured who better to be bulletproof? Upon arriving though, I found I was too late, as Sharkie was dead already.

 
You knew that time was of the essence! With each passing day another innocent villager was murdered. Having made your choice, you rushed off to warn Shark_Bait to keep his doors locked at night... But alas! When you arrived it was obvious that you had come too late, for there was blood everywhere. With tears streaming down your cheeks you raced back to your room, heart pounding. Tomorrow would bring more ill-tidings.

Yes, obviously I lied in the QT's about who I could speak to and the extent of my powers. I certainly didn't know if - or who - was completely trust worthy. I think you'll find that each of you would've done the same (I hope!?).

13897
Does Ozle's flavor suggest we need a unanimous vote today to lynch?

 http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/12_Angry_Men_(1957_film)

13898
Quick, let's go for the trifecta! Let's kill Shark_bait!

(this post is not serious and is made in response to events in other mafia games)

13899
New theory! eHal really is IC - but only because we're all town aligned, and this is essentially a FFA melee.

13900
Volt, do us a solid and OMGUS vote me so Galzria can too. ;)

Yes please. It's just not Mafia unless Joth and I are voting for each other.

Pages: 1 ... 554 555 [556] 557 558 ... 643

Page created in 1.741 seconds with 18 queries.