Dominion Strategy Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - Galzria

Filter to certain boards:

Pages: 1 ... 550 551 [552] 553 554 ... 643
13776
Mafia Game Threads / Re: Mafia IX: Major Arcana Mafia
« on: August 09, 2012, 11:52:41 pm »
Frisk, I need to know up front, are you scum?

Shraeye, are you a Serial Killer?

Volt, are you a Werewolf?

Axxle, are you Mafia?

They were all serious. I haven't heard from Volt or CF yet.

eHunt, want to answer for your Mafia buddy?
Eevee, what about you? Who are you planning on NK'ing for your faction kill?


YOU'RE NOT SUBTLE. WHY CAN'T YOU BE SUBTLE FOR ONE GODDAMN GAME IN YOUR LIFE

RAGEVOTE: GALZRIA

*yawn*

13777
Mafia Game Threads / Re: Mafia IX: Major Arcana Mafia
« on: August 09, 2012, 11:52:09 pm »
Galzria, I can't tell if that's a real question, but I'll bite that bait anyway.  No, I'm not a Serial Killer.

Voltgloss, these are real questions for you.  What do you think would be gained by suitclaiming?  Why did you forget about the Major Arcana in your first query?

They were all serious. I haven't heard from Volt or CF yet.

eHunt, want to answer for your Mafia buddy?
Eevee, what about you? Who are you planning on NK'ing for your faction kill?

Well that's a shame.  There's a difference between probing questions and arbitrary questions.  One type helps us find scum, the other type fills up forum space.  Here's a probing question.

Why not just claim to be Major Arcana? Of course, doing that sure would attract a whole lot of attention to yourself.
Sparky can you explain your reasoning behind why you said that Major Arcana should just claim as such?

I don't think they're arbitrary at all, responses often vary.

13778
Was that conditional even in the vote counts before?

By the way, I resent being called a Sheep. The only animal in Dominion is the Rat. And I'm not a Rat either.

False. Trusty Steed. Lynch All Liars.

He's not part of the Kingdom.

13779
What the hell did I crumb?

13780
Was that conditional even in the vote counts before?

Not that I recall, no.

13781
Was that conditional even in the vote counts before?

By the way, I resent being called a Sheep. The only animal in Dominion is the Rat. And I'm not a Rat either.

13782
8 or 9 human beings, depending on which side you're on

Wha.

Galzria is sheeping.  Sheep are not human.  Vote: Galz.

I am not a good vote, but Robz is.

13783
Non-Mafia Game Threads / Re: Diplomacy
« on: August 09, 2012, 11:39:28 pm »
I am playing IRL this weekend!! <3

Comets/Moons/Lucre/Double-Powers?

13784
When I saw it, I also thought he was crumbing. I thought it was actually pretty well-crumbed, although on the flip side I am unlikely to take breadcrumbing seriously this game as mafia has picked at least one and in all probability two roles they can plan on fakeclaiming. I thought it was super weird of you to call it out, didn't make sense as town or as scum.

The funny thing is, I read his comment that I breadcrumbed.... And I have no clue what it refers to.

13785
Non-Mafia Game Threads / Re: Diplomacy
« on: August 09, 2012, 11:35:06 pm »
I love Cosmic Encounter. I LOVE it. So much. All of the swingy, chaotic action, all of the ganging-up? I love it all. It's just wonderful. We play with 2 aliens each and with 110 aliens in all the expansions, it's just endless and completely different and crazy each time. It's definitely better with a good, fun group, though.

I play dominion way more than any other game right now but I think I still have to give Cosmic the nod as my favorite game. It's just so good EVERY time.
I've been playing a few Cosmic Encounter games on the BGG forums, Play-by-Forum actually works quite well.

We need to get Axxle in here to tell us more.

Wow, great pull. Man, I still have all the original cards from way back... I never let anyone bend them so they're still all nice and flat and new looking. I *so* don't get to play often enough. I would absolutely love to try it out in forum format.

13786
Mafia Game Threads / Re: Mafia IX: Major Arcana Mafia
« on: August 09, 2012, 11:12:32 pm »
Galzria, I can't tell if that's a real question, but I'll bite that bait anyway.  No, I'm not a Serial Killer.

Voltgloss, these are real questions for you.  What do you think would be gained by suitclaiming?  Why did you forget about the Major Arcana in your first query?

They were all serious. I haven't heard from Volt or CF yet.

eHunt, want to answer for your Mafia buddy?
Eevee, what about you? Who are you planning on NK'ing for your faction kill?

13787
Non-Mafia Game Threads / Re: Diplomacy
« on: August 09, 2012, 10:54:12 pm »
Maybe we could play other Boardgame too, like aGoT and whatnot.

I heard someone somewhere say that forum Cosmic Encounter was a thing, and if it really works, I'd be all over that.

Oh dear... Yum! Yes please!

13788
Man it's great to be voting for Robz. I feel refreshed having reread where my vote is at in this game. At least I know I'm voting for one scum somewhere!


13789
Mafia Game Threads / Re: Mafia IX: Major Arcana Mafia
« on: August 09, 2012, 10:19:49 pm »
And yes, I get an obligatory Ace of Swords claim. I'm him.

...

Just not this game.

13790
Mafia Game Threads / Re: Mafia IX: Major Arcana Mafia
« on: August 09, 2012, 10:18:06 pm »
Shraeye, are you a Serial Killer?

13791
Mafia Game Threads / Re: Mafia IX: Major Arcana Mafia
« on: August 09, 2012, 10:17:14 pm »
Axxle, are you Mafia?

13792
Mafia Game Threads / Re: Mafia IX: Major Arcana Mafia
« on: August 09, 2012, 10:16:51 pm »
Volt, are you a Werewolf?

13793
Mafia Game Threads / Re: Mafia IX: Major Arcana Mafia
« on: August 09, 2012, 10:15:57 pm »
Well, 16 players in a non-BM game! Not bad... Hope you're up for the work Cayvie. You've got a 4000 post behemoth coming your way!

Frisk, I need to know up front, are you scum?

13794
Galz: two point I want to make to you.

1. Please explain why you only wanted to discuss with me these "logical questions" ~3 days after I have been accusing you being self-contradictory.

2. I am willing to concede that my read on you might be more from that you are illogical rather than that you are scum. The only catch is that you really only start to show how illogical you are today.

p.s.

3. I am not saying now I think you are town. But I am at this point not interested in knowing the answer to that question any more. You still control my vote. So make good use of it. And to the rest of town: if you are afraid of Galz's such power, you have to lynch him today.

I haven't waited until today... I've been arguing with you almost nonstop for the past 2 days (felt like 2 weeks, lol)

13795
That is, ok, I read your post about manda. In my thoughts:

1. Are you a stupid cop? WTF...
2. Ok, if not, are you then a scum fakeclaiming? (you stopped here and say yes, but I will continue as below)
3. If you were, then you are just drawing attention onto yourself with no benefit (as nobody will really think you are a cop because it is stupid for a cop to claim)
4. So you are probably not a scum fakeclaiming. Then what are you doing? And then I will ask. It is so obvious it shouldn't hurt to ask right?

And that is in my eyes what happened in my instance. And I explained what I said is just that. And later I speak out of what I kept secret and why. But then you are attacking me without reason.

There was no reason to take it further. A cop does not have a reason to make that claim. Scum does. End of story. Are you stupid cop or scum? I figured scum. Now it's neither. Now the claim was just stupid.

I never attacked you without reason. Not once. My case was laid out prior to yours, and every response I made after was in response to false accusations you made against me.

Scum has no reason either as I outlined above. Can you not read that?

I don't just believe that you're wrong, I know that you are, because I've seen scum do it. Just because you don't think something can happen doesn't mean that it can not.
As I said if scum does that it is stupid scum. Not disapproving my point.

The whole point is that scum CANNOT do that to their advantage. Therefore, you cannot judge that they are scum by the fact they are doing that. Just like what I have done in this game.

And yet Robz breadcrumbed doctor D2 in M-II, full claimed it D3, and that remains to this point the only perfect Mafia win.

13796
PPS: Do you have a town read, null read, or scum read on Eevee?

Initially Town for a long time. Recent play could be interpreted as scummy. I'd have to call it null at this point.

Position smell says all of his play is ultimately pro-town.

Logic says he is scummy for insisting manda to be Town and voting against Galzria.

I could support an Eevee lynch if a case could be made which I believe I asked for previously to no avail (correct me if I'm wrong). I'm really trying to avoid the case building business since I got burned so bad with Frisk. My M6 play was about smells and I'm running with that formula here.

Questions back to Galz;
Do you really, actually want us to lynch you to progress the game or would you prefer we wait and try to smoke out some real scum?

If you think someone else is high prob scum do you have any angles on that?

Pah. It's a difficult question. If we lynch someone else and are wrong, it's gameover - there is no lylo. With Timchen voting for me tomorrow, scum win because all they need is one misplaced vote, and he'll be providing it.

In that sense, if we look for scum elsewhere, we must treat today as lylo... And there are simply more targets to choose from (although one miscast vote doesn't ruin us). So it's tough.

With Timchen willing to hand the scum their wincon tomorrow by voting me, it does almost feel better to lynch me and remove that situation. The problem is, I don't want to be a Vig here... That is, I really don't want to say "lynch me then sheep my reads" because while I DO think I'm right on Eevee, it's not my game to win or lose. It's a team game, and I'm not willing to stake the entire team win on my read.

That said, there is probably a pretty good chance that if you lynch me now, Timchen gets NK'd for being essentially an Innocent Child (how I view him at least). This leaves Eevee/YN/PPS/Manda/SB... This thread will get so quiet, lol! No, really, outside my own, personal beliefs on Eevee, any of those 5 could be scum. So I would ask that Eevee is certainly considered, but that each person makes their own decision based on their own reads.

13797
Non-Mafia Game Threads / Re: Diplomacy
« on: August 09, 2012, 09:24:28 pm »
I have to say, I really enjoy Diplomacy, and I hope that after this one ends we'll see more played out here at f.DS. Definitely more my cup of tea compared to Mafia. :P

13798
PPS: Do you have a town read, null read, or scum read on Eevee?

13799
Galz/Cayvie scumbuddies.

 
Plus galz is tracker and we don't want to lynch a PR day 1, wait till at least D2 to do that.

Yep, you're right. I'm a tracker scum and Yuma is my IC.

I think all of those exotic games are getting to your head dude.  This one is pretty vanilla.

I think you missed the point. By the way, having killed the old Captain, are you appointing yourself head of this Vessel?

13800
Oh I agree with your analysis I was just relishing the irony of the pot noting the particular shade of gray sported by kettle.

We still have time and we still haven't heard from some of those I suspect most but I find the lack of a hammer on Galzria an indicator that he may well be scum.

Do you really think scum would come along and say "Oh lookie! Goodie goodie! L-1! How delicious! HAMMMMMMMMMER!"?

Pages: 1 ... 550 551 [552] 553 554 ... 643

Page created in 0.138 seconds with 18 queries.