Told you.
Joseph(Town): Nothing that we don't already know. I guess depending on who the counter-wagon is it may be possible to draw some conclusions.
I believe that puts shraeye's vote puts joseph at L1: Joseph2302 (4): silverspawn, debatepro, raerae, shraeye,Shraeye unvoted though, right?
@ari - Don't do it right now bc it's the hammer, but I want to you consider voting for Joseph. If it's a mislynch and he flips town we can trust faust. If he is scum, well the answer is obvious.wait, is deadline now, or in 1 hour?
unvote
People have played before: What happens if an unvote come through before the lynch is confirmed?Lynch is irrevocable.
I believe that puts shraeye's vote puts joseph at L1: Joseph2302 (4): silverspawn, debatepro, raerae, shraeye,Shraeye unvoted though, right?
@ari - Don't do it right now bc it's the hammer, but I want to you consider voting for Joseph. If it's a mislynch and he flips town we can trust faust. If he is scum, well the answer is obvious.
I think Eddie is my next choice, but there's no votes on him and a bunch on silver.Not that I see in my count.
Vote: Joseph
I'm risk averse, I think a mislynch here is the most informative.
MORE INFORMATIVE THAN HITTING SCUM? WHHHHHHHHAAAAAAAAATTTTT??
Think about our scumreads earlier! EVERYBODY had Ari as their top read, in what world do you think he survives tomorrow??An easy one is faust isn't the nk.
It's frustrating, I mean I've explained that the result absolutely must lower the chance of me being scum from EFHW's PoV. I don't quite get it, her only reason was that faust is more active than me.@SS: What do you think about this fact?Why are you voting for silver? You got the same result on him as you did on Eddie.EFHW, what are your thoughts on UncleEurope?Towny
Why are you voting for silver? You got the same result on him as you did on Eddie.EFHW, what are your thoughts on UncleEurope?Towny
Vote EFHW with me then, if she flips scum you're safe tomorrow. If you vote faust you're absolutely tomorrow's lunch.So if one votes for faust and EFHW flips town, then they targeted in d4. I don't understand, wouldn't one have been at least correct that they believed she was town?
DS is a decent player. SS was skeptical of DS's case against EFHW and he even voted for DS. I don't think scum would push people to lynch a "lesser player", especially sense he already had plenty of cover to vote for DS.So silver is townie for reading DatSwan correctly, and he is also townie for misreading him? Great. silver didn't push anyone, it was clear that DatSwan would be lynch, he just did not want to take heat for that lynch.
I get a question now. For both Ari, Joseph, and EFHW what do we learn if we lynch them and the end up town or scum? What conclusions should we draw about them and their partners? Ill make you a worksheet for your answers.
Ari (Scum): EFHW is town. You are probably town. Most likely partners, in that order: Eddie, silver, you, Joseph.
Ari (Town): EFHW looks worse. silver looks even worse. Eddie seems townie. Scum team: you, silver, EFHW with an outside chance of Eddie replacing EFHW.
Joseph(Scum): Would require an evaluation of that wagon. ari is probably townier. silver seems like a good partner option. Partner in order of likelihood: silver, Eddie, you, EFHW, ari. Also I will probably be lynched next.
Joseph(Town): Nothing that we don't already know. I guess depending on who the counter-wagon is it may be possible to draw some conclusions.
EFHW(Scum): ari is town. If EFHW flips scum Motion Detector, then Eddie is town. silver seems townier. Most likely partners: you, Eddie (if EFHW does not flip MD), Joseph, silver, Eddie (if EFHW flips MD)
EFHW(Town): Noone except me and raerae really suspected EFHW today, so I would have to see how this lynch happened. Scum team is silver, you, Eddie.
You know who has a good chance of being right about people because they know everyone's alignment?I don't think ari is the best shot, but he's a liability as town and his flip gives additional setup info to figure out the EFHW situation, so it's not the worst thing ever and much better than me or Joseph.Because he's been right about reads on the town people who have been lynched? Read on Mix (#449) && pleading with people to jump off DS (1496) and join him on Ari wagon.
I still don't know why people do not want to vote silver.
He is also right about me! So as a new player, these are probably the most convincing pieces of evidence that one can go off of in a game without a single scum lynched.
I don't think ari is the best shot, but he's a liability as town and his flip gives additional setup info to figure out the EFHW situation, so it's not the worst thing ever and much better than me or Joseph.Because he's been right about reads on the town people who have been lynched? Read on Mix (#449) && pleading with people to jump off DS (1496) and join him on Ari wagon.
I still don't know why people do not want to vote silver.
Nice. He want born yet, he won’t get the reference.I’m going to be for realSorry Ms. Jackson, he is for real!!
Faust hammer 45 minutes ahead of inteades after a cop claim could be skummy. Weird at the minimum.I said I will hammer then if you don't show up. You did show up.
You know, this really really rubbed me the wrong way. I get faust sussed out that ds had a fakeclaim, but I feel like if some other player did this, people would immediately give them a billion scumpoints. I mean replace faust's name with debatepro's in that exchange above. I'd be toast. I consider this a kind of dark magic and I don't like it. I'm probably not moving my vote sans a super compelling case or directive from on high.
I'll be around a bit tomorrow, just to make sure I don't miss a directive or compelling case.
I would have done the same thing as faust. That claim smelled REAL bad, I don't fault him for that and wouldn't fault anybody else either.
Faust hammer 45 minutes ahead of inteades after a cop claim could be skummy. Weird at the minimum.I said I will hammer then if you don't show up. You did show up.
2) Pretty sure that's shraeye (you know, the other IC) but good try. And yes, I'm giving myself IC status if that hasn't been made clear already.Touché , you’re both on opposite sides of the Faust vote.
Because it draws attention to why I wouldn't vote for mail-mi which makes it more likely other town would see which makes his mislynch impossible. I mean, I could have pushed mail-mi to claim, mail-mi could have claimed on his own, scum!faust pushing mail-mi was dangerous, town!faust pushing mail-mi was tunneling town. faust had ZERO reason as scum to push me to vote for mail-mi if he knew mail-mi was the cop because if he knew mail-mi was cop he knew I was his target N1.
I don't know how I can make this clearer and your insistence that I'm wrong is interesting.I'm proving a point on two levels. It's not helpful right? You don't have to feint, I am your biggest ally, which could be a double dunce hat for me if I am wrong.
If you're saying faust should have caught on then EFHW should have as well. Only she wasn't already tunneling the hell out of him.
She's in my top 3/4 list, the problem is he isn't on yours and was explicitly taken off.
Which I explained. And, like I said, I firmly believe he had his blinders on re: mail-mi. He went so far as to attack me for not voting for him, if his whole ploy was to lynch the cop he wouldn't have bothered pushing me because he would have seen that mail-mi copped me overnight.
