"who there have been actual cases against" = particularly scummy, since plenty of actual cases had been made against O.
I've been reading history - it looks like the best "zing" against O was that he had "forgotten" that SFS had cleared Tables.
What other parts of this case do you find compelling?
Note: you didn't vote for him either!
If O comes up Mafia, then C.F. Needs to be the next target.
I am online - but I will not be hammering O. I hope that he is Mafia, and I generally agree with Robz's theory that there is mafia among the set of
Jo
GalzriaO
GloobleCaptain_Frisk
Pops
I don't understand why the logic for why O is in here. He's the first member of the non Axxlewagon to jump on the Grujah wagon?
I'm removing myself because I know I'm not mafia. That leaves me with Jo, Galz, Glooble, Pops.
As I've stated before, I prefer J to Glooble, and Pops to Galz. J for legit suspicions reasons, and Pops over Galz for personality - since I don't really have a strong read for one or the other. I am willing to let the twinclaim thing ride for a bit, hence my vote for pops, but I lynch J or Galz if need be.
Willing to lynch (in order of preference): Popsofctown, Jotheonah, Glooble, Grujah, Robz
Strong-unwilling: Tables, SFS, DSell (due to V/LA)
Still-pretty-damn-unwilling: Captain Frisk, Axxle, Galzria
Well - I like that this wagon is different than my grujah wagon, but seriously... Glooble, is there any lynch you don't get behind?
Can someone explain why we are lynching O and not Jonah? Table's magic list said so? He tallied it up, eliminated the top guy, and then got to make his choice of the next 2 and now we're all voting for him?
Why can't we lynch Jonah or Pops - who there have been actual cases against?
Pops started this up, and has repeatedly dodged questions of "how are we going to pick the lynch target" - and when called out on his cagey responses, he says "because it rhymes".
If it was anyone other than Tables or SFS driving the selection, I'd be really angry... now I'm just confused.
Anyway, the discussion is distracting at this point, and it's not surprising at all that Frisk and Jo want that distraction.
The discussion is a distraction that you started with what I considered to bad reasoning - so I called it out.
However - agreed with everyone that we should be hunting mafia - not SK - at least until at least 1 more mafia goes down. We do have confirmed mafia in the game (there is at least 1 remaining), and we don't even know if there is SK.
-- back on target --
So there are 4 of us (myself, DSell, Jonah, and Pops) of which we expect at least 1 to be mafia. 3 of us false lynched Axxle1.
RobZ has cleared pops for some reason I don't understand.
J is J - Pops thinks he's town - Glooble thinks he's town.
I am not mafia - nobody suspected me in the Tables hunt - and then I failed to vote for O and now I look scummy as hell.
DSell - nobody suspects him as far as I know.
Does that summarize our likely suspects?
The scum choice is to hammer the sucker. We're talking about the textbook busing situation. And saying that CF and I are scum because we were hanging around not hammering is just silly.
J - please don't put me in the same sentence with you. I see you either trying to get me in trouble when you flip Mafia - or clear yourself when I flip town.
3). His playstyle does not suggest mafia to me. He was too irritating, and indeed, it got him into some trouble. We have killed irritants for less. I can't see him deciding to play that way as mafia.
[sarcasm] The mafia team is me, pops, and O. Our master plan was to all three play crazy, irritate everyone, and get ourselves lynched ASAP. We're really good at this game. [/sacrasm]
But like you said in 919, "you can't argue with results".
3). His playstyle does not suggest mafia to me. He was too irritating, and indeed, it got him into some trouble. We have killed irritants for less. I can't see him deciding to play that way as mafia.
