What game I referenced u not a gameIn the game I played with McG he did not play like that and he was town so his defense was false
Um, we are not allowed to reference that game.In the game I played with McG
That game is ongoing, so we can't reference it.
Before I say something, I should ask: What are the rules about referencing other specific games? Are finished games ok, while in progress ones are obviously off limits? Or should that just not happen in general?
You got it. If the game is done, you can reference, quote, link, etc.
If the game hasn't finished, don't say anything about it.
Just read everything but didn't find anything essential, though.
Jake is just playing like his usual self which is alignment-unindicative and anti-town.
My initial impression of McGarnacle got a little enhanced though, his "I have played like that before and was town" seemed quite self-aware.
Rest absolute null.
doing what again i'm not lurking or act-lurking
Actually, rather than do one big post, I'll just say things as I see them to make it easier to keep track of stuff while I write.
The long interaction between Jake and RR struck me as genuine. Either both are town, one but not both of them are scum. Unless they are better than I am giving them credit for (possible given RR's scum play in my last game), I don't think they would have faked that if both were scum.
Jake and RR are close IRL and in every game I've played with them so far they just talk at each other constantly, and don't read each other particularly well.
Very much this. There's nothing the rest of us can really gain from it.
Hey everyone. Sorry I missed all the initial "excited for this flavor" posts, but this looks like it's already shaping up to be a good one. To those of you I met in RMM37, hey! and everyone else, good to meet you. Hopefully this week isn't as busy as this weekend was.Hello, and nice to meet you!
Any impressions or thoughts on what anyone has said this far?
Each player has a special ability that is connected to the setup. These abilities are distributed independent of alignment.
If we don't lynch scum here, D2 we'll only need 2 town votes to lynch.
This assumes someone dies in the night. Which could be unlikely
No it doesn't.
Good point. I actually don't like this statement. Well only need two votes. Sounds slightly like you are talking like we as in the mafia. Anyway, I doubt that scum would all get on the same wagon together.
He's also been reverse tunneling Ghacob, ergo calling him town over and over. He's posted things about how Ghacob is so towny 3 times in a row, and he only stopped to point out fluff then vote for me. And I don't like reverse tunneling. It's too much like white knighting. So vote: mail-mi. My mini-case is strong enough for me.
unvote I like this from RR too.
Everyone is scumreading them and I think people are wrong. What else should I do about it?
Back to vote: schadd
I started typing a post, but then mail posted this and I had to go back and do some reading. I don't remember and in my skimming didn't see any people scumread RR at all. Unless ctrl + f failed me, mail was the only person that voted for them at all so far too. RR actually seems like one of the more consistent town reads by the people who have posted their reads, so mail's claim that "Everyone is scumreading them" looks really scummy to me. The thought being that if someone agrees that RR looks towny and then believes the claim other people were scumreading RR, that person will be more likely to give mail more town-cred for townreading RR. I know he (please correct me if I'm wrong) unvoted, but what choice did he have?
That post is enough to make me vote: mail-mi.
I sense a misunderstanding. "Them" in this case was Ghacob, not RR. RR is a "he," btw.
He's also been reverse tunneling Ghacob, ergo calling him town over and over. He's posted things about how Ghacob is so towny 3 times in a row, and he only stopped to point out fluff then vote for me. And I don't like reverse tunneling. It's too much like white knighting. So vote: mail-mi. My mini-case is strong enough for me.
unvote I like this from RR too.
Everyone is scumreading them and I think people are wrong. What else should I do about it?
Back to vote: schadd
I guess bidding is just extreme WIFOM. And it still looks like J Reggie is just slinging votes around
JR has voted for five different people already. I've seen several people say they read him as town. Could someone explain what it is that makes you read town, because irl, in any game I've ever played, accusing that many people first round would almost for sure get the accuser lynched.
It's not pro-town to tunnel the same person all of D1.
I guess bidding is just extreme WIFOM. And it still looks like J Reggie is just slinging votes around
