951
Mafia Game Threads / Re: M89: Best Dominion Card Mafia (Day 2)
« on: November 28, 2016, 02:25:06 pm »
Okay, so I've been going through the thread making sure I didn't miss too much over Thanksgiving (I tried to keep up to date even if I couldn't post). My reads and thoughts:
GKrieg13:
Nothing seemed super scummy although he didn't get on the Jake wagon until the very end. While this could very much be a town thing, I could see scum predicting that the Jake wagon would go through and therefore staying off of it as long as possible to avoid seeming suspicious when he flips town. I don't know how likely that is, but I want to put it out there. Leaning town.
Roadrunner7671:
Lots and lots of posts. The vast majority of them have been one line and almost all about Jake. He doesn't seem to have done anything useful other than getting our Cop lynched. Not convinced, but I could see this being scum acti-lurking. Leaning scum.
SpaceAnemone:
No read to speak of.
McGarnacle:
Not sure what to make of the Doctor claim, especially after I was convinced that Jake was lying and he wasn't. In D1, when accused of being scum, his defense was along the lines of inexperience, having played this way as town in previous games, and never having been scum. In post #598, McGarnacle once again plays up the newness. Then there's choosing RR as his Doctor choice. I'd say scum, but I'm worried because of the Doctor claim. Unsure.
Lekkit:
Initially focused on McGarnacle but switched after the Doctor claim. Didn't really see much else to go on. Leaning town.
Dylan32:
Called for Jake to claim. Other than that, has seemed pretty sensible and moderated. Leaning town.
PingPongSam:
I haven't had a chance to read through all the posts. One thing I found interesting is that Eevee was left off his read list. PPS, what are your thoughts on Eevee?
Running out of time before work so I'm going to have to cut this short. I'll try to finish it by tonight, starting with my read of PPS.
PPE: 1
GKrieg13:
Nothing seemed super scummy although he didn't get on the Jake wagon until the very end. While this could very much be a town thing, I could see scum predicting that the Jake wagon would go through and therefore staying off of it as long as possible to avoid seeming suspicious when he flips town. I don't know how likely that is, but I want to put it out there. Leaning town.
Roadrunner7671:
Lots and lots of posts. The vast majority of them have been one line and almost all about Jake. He doesn't seem to have done anything useful other than getting our Cop lynched. Not convinced, but I could see this being scum acti-lurking. Leaning scum.
SpaceAnemone:
No read to speak of.
McGarnacle:
Not sure what to make of the Doctor claim, especially after I was convinced that Jake was lying and he wasn't. In D1, when accused of being scum, his defense was along the lines of inexperience, having played this way as town in previous games, and never having been scum. In post #598, McGarnacle once again plays up the newness. Then there's choosing RR as his Doctor choice. I'd say scum, but I'm worried because of the Doctor claim. Unsure.
Lekkit:
Initially focused on McGarnacle but switched after the Doctor claim. Didn't really see much else to go on. Leaning town.
Dylan32:
Called for Jake to claim. Other than that, has seemed pretty sensible and moderated. Leaning town.
PingPongSam:
I haven't had a chance to read through all the posts. One thing I found interesting is that Eevee was left off his read list. PPS, what are your thoughts on Eevee?
Running out of time before work so I'm going to have to cut this short. I'll try to finish it by tonight, starting with my read of PPS.
PPE: 1