I don't understand how Petitioner is not supremely overpowered as is. Shouldn't it at least cost 6? Discarding victory cards does not seem like that big of a drawback.Oops, old version.
I really like the munitions art. Awesome stuff, man!Don't thank me, thank Candra. Fun fact: The section is simply a zoomed in version of a larger picture. On the other cropped half of the picture is Bladesmith, from my Civilization.
Hmm, looking at Mad scientist, I like the concept, but not a big fan of the name or art for the card. I know you're reusing the old one. I think I would prefer it if it was renamed (I don't know--Deranged Serf or somethingI'll do an alternate version.and made with new art. The mad scientist art doesn't feel like it fits either medieval or roman theme very well. Oh and by the way, I think your art pics are great, I hope you don't feel I was being too critical. I find your art choices to be excellent, Reimburse and Contest are great examples of amazing art redoes.
I agree with Tristan's thoughts about Arsenal. I think 2 is a fine cost for it. I'm not sure what I think about your changes to Contest. I think I might like the old version better.
Expedition is a terminal Event, i.e. you need to spend a buy for it. Arsenal is a normal terminal card which you can play several times. You can hardly directly compare them.Okay I'll redo Aresnal at
+2 Cards is weaker than Moat so it is weaker than a 2$ (which doesn't really mean much). As Duration or Reserve card Aresenal could be slightly better in some circumstances but this hardly justifies a price increase to 3$. I cannot imagine buying Arsenal over Oracle in many Kingdoms.
. I don't fully agree with your logic, but the end result seems fine. 
and gives you +2 Cards next turn. This costs and when you play it it gives +2 Cards next turn. On second thought it does seem week for and might be better at . But then is it too good for ?
for 
.
, but both cards miss the shuffle. On some boards it's on the weaker end, but can get insane with good trashing and plenty of good s., but her unreliability with your discard pile can be a big drawback, and she will never make any progress through your deck.
Rating: 9/10
Progress: Complete.
Rating: 7/10
Progress: Almost complete.
Hail, weary pilgrim... rest while I tell a dark tale of disaster.... and redemption! On comes Plague, a dangerous new mini-expansion for Dominion. I hope you 'enjoy' Curses as much as I do... mwah ha ha HAAAA!!
... bear in mind, that only 5 of these 13 cards actually give Curses. I also designed them specifically so while they have fun interactions amongst themselves, they could go into any random Dominion game and be fun individually. let me know what you think, but please spend a little time with them. Their dark, risky edge brings something pretty different to the Dominion universe, but that doesn't make them bad or not fun. My whole concept was to make Curses fun after all!
Rating: 5/10
Progress: Complete.
Making a fan expansion (or at least calling your bunch of fan cards a fan expansion) seems the thing to do these days for people who like to make fan cards. So here's my fan expansion, in its current condition.
Flavor themes: Restoration and Inheritance. This is to come in the story timeline next after Dark Ages.
Mechanic themes: durations and mixed-type victory cards along with a bit of a treasure chest of other expansion mechanics.
Rating: 6/10
Progress: Almost complete.
Roots and Renewal has been around for over one and a half years now and although I haven’t posted any news in a while, I’ve constantly developed, tested, reworked, fine-tuned and scratched cards for this set. A huge thanks goes to Asper for countless fun and interesting test games and plenty of feedback. Also thanks to Fragasnap and LastFootnote for their help and everybody else on the forum for commenting.
Roots and Renewal is still some ways afar from being finished so it’s time I cleaned up this thread, rid it of outdated images and uploaded updated versions as well as some new cards. Just to remind everyone, the set’s themes are still the following:
- Interaction with the Supply
- Manipulation of the opening turns
- Powerful and unusual reactions
Rating: 8/10
Progress: Almost complete.
Hey guys! For my first forum post, here are a bunch of card ideas I came up with. I haven’t really playtested any of them, so they might be terribly imbalanced. Tell me what you guys think!
Rating: 7/10
Progress: Complete.
This is my first try at making a fan-expansion and I'm not that experienced with Dominion yet, so any kind of feedback is appreciated a lot.
My goal was to focus on gaining/discarding/trashing Treasure cards and creating interesting interactions and tactics.
Rating: 7/10
Progress: Complete
These are my other cards, many based on cards from other’s expansions. I will refrain from raiting them myself.
The primary goal I had when beginning this expansion was to make the Potion games more fun. They seemed to not be worth it, especially with very few cards that cost a potion in a Kingdom. So there are a few new cards that cost potion, a way to avoid buying Potions sometimes, ways to use the Potion for something after you buy what you need, and Events that cost potion. [Note: Cut for length, click the quote to read the rest]
Rating: 6/10
Progress: Almost complete.
I won’t rate these as a whole, and I can always add more.
Ambush and Hired Help are the sameWeird. Heh.
Free all afternoon guys.
Very easy one.11: Save copper. Alms for Villa, copper x6, Baker, Borrow.
Q11. Gain Platinum on turn 2.
Q12. Attack on turn 1.
(EDIT) I have nothing against modifyng someone else's cards for your use (because I do a lot of that myself).Good points. I mainly felt okay doing this because it's an inactive thread with an (mostly) inactive owner. I'll edit the post.
And it's cool for you to post all these mockups, but I would suggest posting these in your Fan Card Mock-Ups thread, and maybe use some different wording when talking about the cards you did or didn't mock-up. I know if you posted in my Resurgence thread and announced "I've redone the set and scrapped a few cards." I would be offended. It's more understandable to do it in an inactive fan card thread, but still I recommend more tact. For instance, it'd be nicer if you said "I only did mock-ups for my favorite cards," rather than, "I scrapped these cards from [somebody else's] set." Rather than, "I've redone the set," just say "I've mocked up the set my way" or something like that.
Currently it’s 15 cards, that mostly revolve around the theme of discarding for benefit and cycling cards that either like or can create small hand-sizes. Since these are my first cards, I kept them simple—no durations, tokens, reserves, debt, potions, travellers and such—just 13 Actions (2 Attacks), 1 Treasure-Reaction, and 1 Victory. All have gone through some playtesting, but I'm continuing to playtest and modify as I go.
Rating: 7/10
Progress: Partly complete.
This is a set that aims to be a standalone expansion. It does not use any tokens or rely on any cards from other expansions. I tried to encompass all the essential aspects of Dominion, and I'll be adding more cards later. The theme is adversity and the unfair nature of life.
Rating: 7/10
Progress: Complete
This is my first attempt at creating a fan expansion. There are 24 cards. I did my best to try to include various card types with a good deal of interactions.
Rating: 6/10
Progress: Several cards might get balancing changes, but otherwise the set is complete.
Over the past few months, I've been working on making some of my own Dominion cards. Mostly they're just random ideas, but there are a couple themes lurking that may get organized enough to turn into a fan expansion someday:
a
1) Cards that get treasures into play during the action phase (a la Black Market and Storyteller) and action cards that benefit from having treasures in play.
2) Cards that would best be online only (Elixir and Quintessence - since they really should only be in the game if there are other Potion cards). I've been working on my own online Dominion interface and am planning to implement them there.
I'm sure some of these ideas have probably been done before, but I'd love to know what you guys think about them.
Rating: 7/10
Progress: Complete.
Greetings forum,
A while ago Roadrunner and I started working on an expansion together, we were stuck a bit, until Theta joined us and then everything went pretty quickly. So today I have the honor to present to you the beta version of a new fan expansion called 'civilization'. Most of the cards have seen sufficient playtesting to warrant 'probably ok' label, but some could use some more.
Rating: 5/10
Progress: Complete.
My cards aspire to be the sequel to Intrigue. Lots of choices and duality. I call it Dominion: Conspiracy.
Rating: 5/10
Progress: Almost complete. Some cards will be changed as Kru5h changes them.
Dominion: Greed is a fan expansion that has been in the making since the release of Dominion: Guilds in 2013 between myself and Lamestar, a friend of mine.
This expansion for Dominion consists of 21 Kingdom cards, with more pending testing. The set has two mechanical themes: Cards which harm the user (providing negative effects) and "in games using this" effects.
Rating: 8/10
Progress: Complete. Some cards will be changed as Fragsnap changes them.
I've been playing Dominion for a while, but haven't really spent any time on this part of the forum. Anyways, I made a small expansion (12 cards). They're mountain themed. I'll let you guys figure out the play theme (if there is one).
Rating: 6/10
Progress: Complete.
This post has been updated to reflect the current state of the cards. The following are more or less stable right now.
Rating: 6/10
Progress: Almost complete.
Rating: 7/10
Progress: Alsmot complete.
"Asper's Cards" were created with the main goal to make original but relatively easy to understand cards by using existing game mechanics. As most mechanics of Dominion are visited, the collection also works as a Treasure Chest, with each official set up to Empires having at least 2 cards dedicated to it (let's call this 25-card subset "Dominion - Legacy"). The "set" currently has: A card you can spend more than one action on, a VP card that attacks to become worth more, a card that starts out in the trash, a $2 curser, a card that will cost you VP when you gain it, a Potion Event and at least one horrible pun.
Rating: 9/10
Progress: Complete, though Asper changes his cards often.
Hi all! This is my first shot at making cards and I'd love any and all input I can get before I print them out. I only own the base set (1st and 2nd edition), Intrigue (1st and 2nd), Seaside, and Prosperity but I am familiar with most of the other cards. If a card of mine is very similar to a card in a later expansion me know. I only play 2 player and usually colony/platinum games so cards that work for those games are my priority but I want them balanced for all games if possible. I prefer cards that are simple, don't slow down the game, and are unique.
Rating: 7/10
Progress: Almost complete.
Using Violet CLM's fantastic Dominion Card Image Generator (Note: It's great but I didn't use it), I've made some Fan Cards I would like your opinions on. They are supposed to work with Alchemy and Cornucopia specifically (2 of my fav expansions), using some ideas I've seen previously like the +mechanic, which is awesome.
Rating: 5/10
Progress: Incomplete.
because it's cool, and helps differentiate it from Scrying Pool and University.
and new art. I like the older art better, but I couldn't track it down.
, and draws before it plays a treasure. It also got a rename and re-art because of Asper's Investor. And I hated the old art. It may get out of hand though, playtesting will tell. Possibly it needs a cap on drawing.
coin drop once 4 are in the trash. I'm hoping this will be a cool mid-game change. It could turn out to be too dominating still, or too shuffle luck inherent. 
cost is a possibility.
. No playtesting yet, but It's cool so I hope to later.
Yes, it wouldn't.or that playing IGG wouldn't give out a curseValyria could potentially lead to rules issues with Horn of Plenty and Villa.As the game is over you cannot gain anything if you play Horn of Plenty. And as the game is over you cannot buy Villa.
Not that it is likely that it will appear (who would buy expensive Treasures in the presence of Dragon?) but the other stuff can simply be houseruled. I'd simply forbid any hand/deck interaction with those other Treasure cards, you simply count the Coins.
What's far more crucial is the correct VP value. I have a hard time judging that.
@Theta- I recognize the art from Exchange, I just can't place it. Were is it from?
Looks good as always
@Theta- The art forYes.Brick RoadExchange is from Settlers of Catan, right?
