Dominion Strategy Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length

Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Messages - Captain_Frisk

Filter to certain boards:

Pages: 1 ... 40 41 [42] 43 44 ... 218
1026
I'm not sure I believe robz, but there is a scout in the discard pile.  It had to get there somewhere, right?

1027
Hedging comment was obviously a joke. Boo at me not being funny!


I did think that if I ever had to "prove my Hand," it would be believed that Robz888 has two Scouts.
Heh. This looks so much like a scum slip, I think scum-Robz would actually be more likely to self-censure it away. Town-Robz's devil-may-care attitude has gotten him lynched before. But who the hell knows with this guy.

Can the person to robz's left confirm 2 scouts?

It is me, and actually I cannot.

Anyone but you.  Crap. I'm going to bed.

1028
Also, morgrim, can I get the actual card description of secret chamber?

1029
Hedging comment was obviously a joke. Boo at me not being funny!


I did think that if I ever had to "prove my Hand," it would be believed that Robz888 has two Scouts.
Heh. This looks so much like a scum slip, I think scum-Robz would actually be more likely to self-censure it away. Town-Robz's devil-may-care attitude has gotten him lynched before. But who the hell knows with this guy.

Can the person to robz's left confirm 2 scouts?

1030
What concerns me is that you announced your scout targets after your targets had already named what they did (or it was derivable per cayvie).

Yeah, they just beat me to the punch. I was around only intermittently these past few days.

What is the other intrigue card in your hand?

1031
What concerns me is that you announced your scout targets after your targets had already named what they did (or it was derivable per cayvie).


1032
@Qvist

As the organizer of community rankings, you are accutely aware of the relative strengths of cards.

Would you care to explain why you selected not one, but two "underpowered cards"?

@RobZ
Were you stuck with the scout, or did you go out of your way to pick it?

I judged that the best use of my available cards was to play Scout.

Look, I'm not opposed to having more discussion, obviously. Nor am I opposed to Frisk's inquisition. But like, if I said, "Nah, man, Scout's all I got. My hand sucks" or "I'm saving the really good stuff for tonight" that would be helping scum decide who to kill. I'm in favor of revealing stuff that will help box scum into a corner, but this specific question seems like the answer doesn't benefit town much, but potentially really helps scum. So perhaps if you could give us more of the rationale behind your line of questioning...?

I was more curious about the draft order of your scout.  Were you forced to take it because it was passed to you?

1033
General Discussion / Re: His Dark Materials?
« on: November 26, 2012, 11:52:34 pm »
Armored Bears.

1034
Yeah - I'm just saying that even if we knew that DSell was 100% scum, I still haven't revealed, and as such we shouldn't end the day.

I don't see any compelling reason to reveal at this time, so I'm not - hence my plea for unvotes to prevent loss of information.

1035
Mafia Game Threads / Re: BM VII: You're in a game... RUN BY MORGRIM!!!
« on: November 26, 2012, 11:47:31 pm »
Can I come back too?  My Fight Club night action was going to be awesome.
Hey! Don't talk about Fight Club...

You make it sound like a cult or something.

Trash.  I don't think we should be talking about this trash.

1036
What confirmed CF as town? I've got my investigation on Joth, but I think I missed somebody clearing CF.

I'm not clear, but I did play a spy last night, which gives me all sorts of information.  I'd like to make maximum use of this info, because its not like i have any more spies in my hand.

I seem to remember that you have in the past done similar things - held back on investigation results to see if you could catch someone in a lie.

1037
Will someone unvote before something stupid happens?

You are leading the town but acting very mysterious with short posts that look to be from mobile. If you have something to say, might as well say it before the day ends or tell us when you will be at a computer to do so. All of these single-sentence posts make it hard to follow your train of thought.

Also, for someone who is leading town, you are quite good at forgetting what has already been stated (like me claiming WW and Eevee claiming TR).

I'm at my machine now.  I just don't think we should hastily lynch 7 days in advance of deadline when there's plenty to discuss.

1038
Will someone unvote before something stupid happens?

1039
Vote: Dsell, since there is one more until hammer.

RobZ - is there any reason why you're pushing so hard?  Don't you want to learn possibly confirmed townies from joth and I?

1040
Juggle some balls?

No class token, won't use a weapon token either

1041
@Qvist

As the organizer of community rankings, you are accutely aware of the relative strengths of cards.

Would you care to explain why you selected not one, but two "underpowered cards"?

@RobZ
Were you stuck with the scout, or did you go out of your way to pick it?

1042
It makes me invulnerable to any night actions.

Are you going to claim the sets remaining in your hand?

1043
I have told everything I know already.

Any thoughts?  Want to hunt some scum?

Want to lynch some Dsell.

Whats the hurry?

1044
I have told everything I know already.

Any thoughts?  Want to hunt some scum?

1045
It makes me invulnerable to any night actions.

So then PPS must have played it, and whoever did the kill must have used a strong man?

Makes sense.  Our D1 planning probably would have worried scum that doctoring, etc. would get in the way of NKing, and after a no lynch, they really needed someone to die.

Were you really worried about day 1 random doctoring?  Myself, I'd be more worried about tracking / watching etc., but maybe thats just my experience from the last RMM game.

1046
Ok, so that leaves us with 2 players who are confirmed to have 3 cards in hand.

Does anyone have reason to believe that anyone who's described their card abilities is lying?

1047
It makes me invulnerable to any night actions.

So then PPS must have played it, and whoever did the kill must have used a strong man?

1048
secret chamber was a defense card.

Can you elaborate please?

Seems that if this was true, then pps should be alive?

1049
secret chamber was a defense card.

Can you elaborate please?

1050
Yes.  Not sure I can paste, though.  Arch, can I get a ruling?

I will say that YN wasn't lying when he said what he said he did.

That's fine.

Just need morgrim for secret chamber.

Pages: 1 ... 40 41 [42] 43 44 ... 218

Page created in 2.226 seconds with 18 queries.