17251
Mafia Game Threads / Re: ZM22: Shakespeare (Sorta) Blitz - Day 1
« on: October 29, 2015, 08:49:45 am »
Vote: Awaclus
I voted you because I wanted to see how you would respond to pressure. I was hoping someone would follow and put you at L-1, really. Hence, 'there's an easier way'. But I didn't get so much from it, you're still pretty null. Faust seems to have strengthened his town read, but I don't know if I trust Faust.
Vote: Awaclus
PASTE | PANTS | PIANO | BAR | COURT |
BOARD | WHEEL | IVORY | CONCERT | SUPERHERO |
DEATH | CARROT | SOUL | WEB | LOCK |
TRIANGLE | MATCH | ORGAN | GERMANY | BUG |
SPY | DATE | CLUB | HIRE | TOOTH |
I don't really want to lynch Roadrunner... do people really think he comes out scummy from all this?
Yes
And I will vengekill whoever hammers without first posting intent.
Really? I mean, quickhammers aren't great, but it's not like there's anything to claim, so why do we need intent to hammer?
I want people's reads before the day is over. That gives a lot of information.
And I will vengekill whoever hammers without first posting intent.
Well I can tell you I'm not lying.
So, WW is either telling truth and hadn't read his PM (in which case he is exactly average lynch, so I'm ok with that considering D1 lynch statistics I did some time ago) or lying (and most likely scum)
Yes, I love his lynch very much now, need to consult vote count before voting though
And no, I don't know how old he is. But that really isn't a defense, it's an excuse. A good excuse maybe, but still.
Yeah... I feel like I can read RR, but he hasn't flipped in any game so far, so I might just be completely fooled. But at any rate, I don't want to lynch him today. I feel like partnerless!scum!newbie!RR is likely to slip up at some point, and he hasn't so far.
I tried to generate some confusion earlier, but it didn't work too well.
Trying to generate scum slips? Wait until he says he is scum in the thread? What kinds of slip do you require? Evolving personality within the game is normal for a new player, I will give him that. But I am suspicious of how that evolution is happening in this game, and think it is characteristic of newbie scum
Well, I'm operating under the assumption that I'm town. You are welcome to do the same
And no, I don't know how old he is. But that really isn't a defense, it's an excuse. A good excuse maybe, but still.
I also don't believe that witherweaver hasn't looked at his PM. Although, if he was going to do it, this would be the game to do it in.
No reason to lie about it. Game started before I woke up and could confirm. I got the alert but didn't read it.
Well... you not having read your PM basically makes me want to lynch you a lot, because if it is true, that means any interaction you have today is worthless and since you cannot know that you're town, your play will default to a bit more self-serving (and thus scummy) than that of a known townie.
You not reading your PM is self-serving and hurting our ability to scumhunt, and thus anti-town.
Since there are two scum teams, my motivation as scum would be the same as my motivation as town: to find the scum. So I'm not really sure the difference in this case.
So, what's the case on Awaclus?
Lynch him and find out.
That's a compelling case, but not as good as the one I made against RR
Faust and Hydrad look bad, Awaclus maybe
Witherweaver (3): faust, Awaclus, Hydrad
I also don't believe that witherweaver hasn't looked at his PM. Although, if he was going to do it, this would be the game to do it in.
No reason to lie about it. Game started before I woke up and could confirm. I got the alert but didn't read it.
One way of finding scum is finding people who are looking for one scum out of 6 players, rather than two. The difference is more subtle than it usually is, but it's still there and it affects the way how people think and sometimes it shows even if you're trying to hide it. For instance, when I was playing (almost) this setup as scum in M67, I scumslipped here by trying to convince silverspawn that Seprix is scum without even appearing to consider the possibility that he could be Seprix's partner. Then I noticed it, and had to come up with an explanation why that was the case, and then I somehow got away with it.
And just to get it on record - scum probably would scumhunt in this game, which makes it a little bit harder
so in this game. wagon analysis and stuff will be almost useless? I feel like it might turn into a game of chance to see if we catch scum as there isn't really any way to gain info I guess.