I also actually didn't know what L-1 meant. But god I am so lucky. I guess this is why there are newby games.
So now i know why a wagon is so good.
SK was a newby so I don't think that voting him as mafia could have been a good idea. So the wagon starter, ww probably town just like (joth) and pacovf
i am rereading the whole thing (altough i am probably not analising as thoroughfully and good as you) and it so nice to read how SK tries to talk himself out) and it does makes sense that he was indeed a mafia.
Hmmm I don't like how easily Hydrad moved his vote and was able to directly answer my question. His initial post sounded unsure as to whether SK was town or scum -- he could see both sides. But when asked he definitively picked a side -- I'd suspect scum would 100% pick a side there, while town might just say "I'm really unsure, I'd think scum but I am unsure at this point". It just reads like Hydrad was presented with a question and then decided "since town is asking me a question, I NEED to give an answer one way or the other."
Vote: Hydrad
Can we get a replacement for Infinite Duress if he still hasn't shown up? Sooner is better, it will be tougher for someone replacing in if there's only a day or two left before deadline.
I am leaning towards TA here, I think there has been a more thoroughfull analysis been done of this couple, but i am feeling something too here.
Of course with my luck TA is mafia now
There has been a better analysis done on the couple by pacovf but i am feeling it now too.
With my luck, TA must be mafia of course now
) and it does makes sense that he was indeed a mafia.Hmmm I don't like how easily Hydrad moved his vote and was able to directly answer my question. His initial post sounded unsure as to whether SK was town or scum -- he could see both sides. But when asked he definitively picked a side -- I'd suspect scum would 100% pick a side there, while town might just say "I'm really unsure, I'd think scum but I am unsure at this point". It just reads like Hydrad was presented with a question and then decided "since town is asking me a question, I NEED to give an answer one way or the other."
Vote: Hydrad
Can we get a replacement for Infinite Duress if he still hasn't shown up? Sooner is better, it will be tougher for someone replacing in if there's only a day or two left before deadline.
I am leaning towards TA here, I think there has been a more thoroughfull analysis been done of this couple, but i am feeling something too here.
Of course with my luck TA is mafia now
I can imagine that lynching a random player is better than following others, as the mafia can quickly group up and vote the same person.
Completely agree, but how do you intend to lynch a random player without anyone following others at some point, though?
Pacovf gets a D1 pass for activity alone, I don't wanna lynch him today. Don't wanna lynch WW either.
I'm sorry about the double and triple posting. I know why we can't edit posts, but man do I wish we could, I'm always forgetting stuff.Well, yeah, generating reactions is good... but convincing other people that you are scum isn't.Ok, walk me through your thought process, was there anyone you specifically wanted to talk to?
No, just like I said "I know this game from IRL, and there I have the habit to talk to the people beside me, trying to trigger a 'mafia-slip' as you call it I think.
So I asked if this kind of thing is allowed/happens online too."
IRL I say something like: i am town, are you too? and if there is no immediate response sometimes you can tell they are 'scum'. Of course, i know, you can't do this online,but thats why i asked about pms.
Ok, I understand the tactic in real life. Let's assume that you could send PMs to other players. Give me an example of how you would try to draw a scumslip with a PM.
Well, yeah, generating reactions is good... but convincing other people that you are scum isn't.
