Man, this game was intense!
Game-Log :
http://dominion.isotropic.org/gamelog/201201/19/game-20120119-113958-f3b78563.html (I will post Councilroom link later)
The Setup was Bishop, Embassy, Ill-Gotten Gains, Laboratory, Native Village, Nomad Camp, Throne Room, Village, Woodcutter, and Young Witch ( Bane: Secret Chamber )
with veto against Witch, Possession, Great Hall (for whatever reason) and Trader.
The Bane to Young Witch being Secret Chamber, which is funny in itself, but I guessed, it won't be bought enough to deterr from YW, so I went double YW. By the time I bought IGG, there were 9 Curses already dealt, but it kept me ahead 1 Curse.
Someone almost emptied the Village pile so I thought about Duchy rushing (if it is still a rush after the Cursing phase). I concentrated on money and ignored the Bishops, because I profited enough from my opponents'.
Well the Duchy rush didnt work out so well, because everyone else ignored them long time and I had to empty almost the whole pile. When it was empty, I overlooked the lonely Village waiting for the game to finish (as 3rd pile), and the Point Counter was always on (but Thog, fair despot's points were visible anyways, since he had no green at all).
I think I could have won this game if
1. I had gone for a more Province-buying engine and not switched to Duchy too early or
2. I had bought the Village, if I had the opportunity (I don't know, because later it was always 1 or 2 points difference to Thog, fair despot) or
3. I had bought Bishop earlier.
What are your thougts on this game?
Was the Bishop so strong because the game lasted so many turns? (later on, Thog, fair despot only trashed 2-3 cost cards, but often played 3 Bishops per round)
PS: Oh another funny thing happening in our 3rd turns: Thog, fair despot revealed the Secret Chamber to YW and buried it in the pile without revealing it a second time (as a Bane) and didn't have it in his hand against our Young Witches, which resulted in him gaining 3 Curses unnecessarily (but maybe this kept the early game balanced).