Oil sucks. Treasure Peddler is worse than ordinary Peddler, a $4, and Treasure Squire, a $2. The flexbility does not push this into $% territory. I don't think that this is even good at $4.
Good point. It should increase in price as more are Trashed.
Rare Art does not work. Why would you waste several plays in order to build this up when they opponents can then free-ride?
My submission:
Graper
$3
Action - Oinos
Reveal the top 2 cards of your deck and discard them. +$1 per differently named card. If they're both Victory cards, +1 Action
You may rotate the Oinos
Vintner
$4
Action - Reaction - Oinos
+1 Card
+1 Action
Gain a Silver to your hand.
-
When you discard this other than in Clean-up, look at the top 4 cards of your deck. Discard any number, and put the rest back in any order.
Taverner
$5
Action - Reserve - Oinos
+3 Cards
+1 Buy
Put this on your Tavern mat
--
At the start of your Buy phase, you may call this for +2 Buys, and you may rotate the Oinos.
Sommelier
$6
Action - Oinos
You may play a Treasure or Victory card from your hand.
+1vp per $2 it costs, (round down).
Water
$2
Action - Duration - Element
Either now or at the start of your next turn, +2 Cards.
You may rotate the Elements.
You may rotate the Elements.
Either now or at the start of your next turn, +2 Cards.
Either now or at the start of your next turn:
+2 Cards.
You may rotate the Elements.
Earth
$3
Action - Reaction - Element
Choose one: Trash a Treasure from the Supply; or gain a Treasure from the trash to your hand.
-
When you discard this other than in Clean-up, you may play it.
Fire
$4
Action - Element
Put your deck into your discard pile. Look through it and you may trash up to 2 cards from it.
Knew I forgot something! It costs $3.How much does this cost?
Recession (Action-Reaction, cost $4)
+$3
-
When a player gains a card costing $6 or more, you may reveal this, for each other player to discard down to 4 cards in hand. If it isn’t your turn, and you haven’t revealed a Recession since the start of your last turn, each other player takes their -1 Card token.
The previous version was fine, you pay $6 to get a $6 onto your deck and a Silver. Might favour BM but it might also be situationally OK for engines.
The new version is crazy, you pay $6 and get a $6 onto your deck plus a card which is worth $5. Although you don’t want too any copies of it, +2 Coffers is pretty strong on a Treasure and you definitely want it far more often than a Silver.
What I said about previous version is that there's no need to it be a card with overpay in cost, since there would be no demand for a buy without overpay. It could simply cost $6 with the same results.
The overpay stops Wish from being able to gain Divine Favors for more Wishes, although there's no real problem with being able to gain a silver each turn.
Yes, you're right and it also is different with TFB.
What I think is that is better if the card would be also good to buy without overpay. But Masterpiece is there to prove it doesn't need to be this way.
Yeah, as you can see, right after I realized it and said about TFB.
Thanks for the feedback! Here’s my card now.QuoteDivine Favor (Treasure, cost $6+)
$2
-
When you buy this, gain a Wish from its pile. You may also overpay $1 for this, to put the gained Wish on top of your deck.
Suggestion of a more concise wording to fit better the space for it in the card:
The previous version was fine, you pay $6 to get a $6 onto your deck and a Silver. Might favour BM but it might also be situationally OK for engines.
The new version is crazy, you pay $6 and get a $6 onto your deck plus a card which is worth $5. Although you don’t want too any copies of it, +2 Coffers is pretty strong on a Treasure and you definitely want it far more often than a Silver.
What I said about previous version is that there's no need to it be a card with overpay in cost, since there would be no demand for a buy without overpay. It could simply cost $6 with the same results.
The overpay stops Wish from being able to gain Divine Favors for more Wishes, although there's no real problem with being able to gain a silver each turn.
Yes, you're right and it also is different with TFB.
What I think is that is better if the card would be also good to buy without overpay. But Masterpiece is there to prove it doesn't need to be this way.
Yeah, as you can see, right after I realized it and said about TFB.
Divine Favor (Treasure, cost $6+)
$2
-
When you buy this, gain a Wish from its pile. You may also overpay $1 for this, to put the gained Wish on top of your deck.
That’s fair.
Update:QuoteDivine Favor (Treasure, cost $5)
$2
-
When you buy this, you may overpay $1 for it, to gain a Wish from its pile to the top of your deck.
This way it's the same to it costs $6, since no one would spend $5 to buy a Silver.
Divine Favor (Treasure, cost $5)
+2 Coffers
-
When you buy this, you may overpay $1 for it, to gain a Wish from its pile to the top of your deck.
Updating my entry:Looks far too strong compared to other >$4 gainers. It might even be overpowered if it did not yield any Coins.QuoteDivine Favor (Treasure, cost $6)Okay. This card needs a little explaining. I’m assuming Dominion is in a fantasy, D&D-esque world where the gods give favors in exchange for temple service. Favors are probably the currency of gods to mortals.
$2
Gain a Wish from its pile. You may trash this, to put the gained Wish on your deck.QuoteDivine Favor (Treasure, cost $4)
$2
-
When you buy this, you may overpay for it. If you overpaid $1, gain a Wish from its pile. If you overpaid $2 or more, you may put the gained Wish on top of your deck.
Why not just make it cost $5, and tie the topdecking to overpaying at all?
Also paying $5 for a wish is crazy, even if you don't want the silver.
Divine Favor (Treasure, cost $5)
$2
-
When you buy this, you may overpay $1 for it, to gain a Wish from its pile to the top of your deck.
Updating my entry:Looks far too strong compared to other >$4 gainers. It might even be overpowered if it did not yield any Coins.QuoteDivine Favor (Treasure, cost $6)Okay. This card needs a little explaining. I’m assuming Dominion is in a fantasy, D&D-esque world where the gods give favors in exchange for temple service. Favors are probably the currency of gods to mortals.
$2
Gain a Wish from its pile. You may trash this, to put the gained Wish on your deck.
Divine Favor (Treasure, cost $4)
$2
-
When you buy this, you may overpay for it. If you overpaid $1, gain a Wish from its pile. If you overpaid $2 or more, you may put the gained Wish on top of your deck.
Divine Favor (Treasure, cost $6)Okay. This card needs a little explaining. I’m assuming Dominion is in a fantasy, D&D-esque world where the gods give favors in exchange for temple service. Favors are probably the currency of gods to mortals.
$2
Gain a Wish from its pile. You may trash this, to put the gained Wish on your deck.
This would be valuable, but I feel it would lose much of its value if there weren’t any exiling cards in the supply.I’ll save you all the google and tell you the definition of thelony is, “A toll or custom required from travelling merchants as a tax on doing business.” (Source: Wikipedia)First of all, I love the name!QuoteThelony — ($6)(Action - Attack - Duration)(005v2)
At the start of your next turn: +1 Card, +1 Action, +1 Buy, and +$1. While this is in play, when any other player discards a card from their Exile mat, they take 1 [Debt Token].
On interaction with Coven, the issue is that two rarely involuntary actions collide: Coven is the only official card that forces discarding from Exile.
It can be solved with only taxing on the player's own turn.
The cost looks too high to me: a delayed Marked is a weak $4 (similar to Caravan which is $1 less than Lab), and a relatively weak attack brings the cost to $5 (similar to Smithy -> Rabble). It still can be a reasonable purchase in absence of exilers, for example, for +Buy.
Thank you! And thank you for the simple fix. However, I think I need to leave the price at $6. Even though the card says +1 Card, +1 Action, +1 Buy, and +$1, it being at the start of your next turn makes it worth more. If a Caravan this turn is a Laboratory next turn, then a Thelony this turn is a level 3 City next turn.
Update to my entry:QuoteThelony — ($6)(Action - Attack - Duration)
At the start of your next turn: +1 Card, +1 Action, +1 Buy, and +$1. While this is in play, when any other player discards a card from their Exile mat on their turn, they take 1 [Debt Token].
All in all, I think this would be a valuable card in any kingdom, and it would likely be highly sought after if the attack can gain traction via other cards in the kingdom (like Camel Train).
[Edit] FYI: the definition of thelony is, “A toll or custom required from travelling merchants as a tax on doing business.” (Source: Wikipedia)
Pony (Action, Cost $4)
+2 Cards
+1 Action
Exile an Action card from your hand (or reveal a hand with no Action cards)
Pony (Action, Cost $4)
+2 Cards
+1 Action
Exile a card from your hand
