Dominion Strategy Forum
Dominion => Rules Questions => Topic started by: TheMirrorMan on July 20, 2013, 09:03:49 pm
-
Two questions on combining Alchemy with other sets :
1) If you trash a squire, are you able to take a scrying pool ?
2) Can you use the band of misfits as an alchemy card ?
-
1) Yes
2) No (except Herbalist, since it doesn't have potion in its cost)
A bunch of people will post after this saying the same thing, but with a lengthy confusing explanation.
-
Anything with a potion its cost cannot cost less than Band of Misfits because potion is not directly comparable to coins.
-
Consider the following image:
(http://oi42.tinypic.com/2u6ph0j.jpg)
You see, a relation on the collection of all costs (i.e., a subset of the cartesian product of this set with itself) is called a partial order if it is reflexive, transitive, and anti-symmetric...
-
Thank you. Very clear.
-
2) No (except Herbalist, since it doesn't have potion in its cost)
Also Apprentice.
-
2) No (except Herbalist, since it doesn't have potion in its cost)
Also Apprentice.
But Apprentice never costs less than Band of Misfits.
-
2) No (except Herbalist, since it doesn't have potion in its cost)
Also Apprentice.
But Apprentice never costs less than Band of Misfits.
Possibly the first time anyone has said something Dominion-related on this board that doesn't have an edge case.
-
2) No (except Herbalist, since it doesn't have potion in its cost)
Also Apprentice.
But Apprentice never costs less than Band of Misfits.
Possibly the first time anyone has said something Dominion-related on this board that doesn't have an edge case.
I actually thought twice before posting to make sure.
-
2) No (except Herbalist, since it doesn't have potion in its cost)
Also Apprentice.
But Apprentice never costs less than Band of Misfits.
Possibly the first time anyone has said something Dominion-related on this board that doesn't have an edge case.
Yet.
-
2) No (except Herbalist, since it doesn't have potion in its cost)
Also Apprentice.
But Apprentice never costs less than Band of Misfits.
Possibly the first time anyone has said something Dominion-related on this board that doesn't have an edge case.
Yet.
The outtake (http://dominionstrategy.com/2013/06/24/dominion-outtakes/) Flea Market could have caused that.
-
2) No (except Herbalist, since it doesn't have potion in its cost)
Also Apprentice.
But Apprentice never costs less than Band of Misfits.
Possibly the first time anyone has said something Dominion-related on this board that doesn't have an edge case.
Yet.
Victory Points are good if you want to win. Hah.
(Note: you forgot to write "on topic" so I can find an edge case to your saying there will be an edge case later maybe that will stop a not-edge-case to have an edge case)
(And yes, I did cleverly put "if you want to win" so you obsessive edge casers couldn't say "unless you want to lose")
-
2) No (except Herbalist, since it doesn't have potion in its cost)
Also Apprentice.
But Apprentice never costs less than Band of Misfits.
Possibly the first time anyone has said something Dominion-related on this board that doesn't have an edge case.
Yet.
The outtake (http://dominionstrategy.com/2013/06/24/dominion-outtakes/) Flea Market could have caused that.
Haha, not it couldn't! To play a Band of Misfits, it's already gained, so it costs $4!
Unless you were just trying to find a time where Apprentice costs less, even if you could never use it...
-
2) No (except Herbalist, since it doesn't have potion in its cost)
Also Apprentice.
But Apprentice never costs less than Band of Misfits.
Possibly the first time anyone has said something Dominion-related on this board that doesn't have an edge case.
Yet.
The outtake (http://dominionstrategy.com/2013/06/24/dominion-outtakes/) Flea Market could have caused that.
Haha, not it couldn't! To play a Band of Misfits, it's already gained, so it costs $4!
Wait, what? Flea Market is 'cards no one has gained cost less'. So if you've gained Band of Misfits and no one has gained Apprentice, Band of Misfits costs $5 and Apprentice costs $4, so you could play Band of Misfits as Apprentice.
-
2) No (except Herbalist, since it doesn't have potion in its cost)
Also Apprentice.
But Apprentice never costs less than Band of Misfits.
Possibly the first time anyone has said something Dominion-related on this board that doesn't have an edge case.
Yet.
The outtake (http://dominionstrategy.com/2013/06/24/dominion-outtakes/) Flea Market could have caused that.
Haha, not it couldn't! To play a Band of Misfits, it's already gained, so it costs $4!
Wait, what? Flea Market is 'cards no one has gained cost less'. So if you've gained Band of Misfits and no one has gained Apprentice, Band of Misfits costs $5 and Apprentice costs $4, so you could play Band of Misfits as Apprentice.
*facepalm*